by Grob » Fri May 18, 2012 7:55 pm
I must say that I wasnt very impressed by our non academy age players last night. The likes of Assulin and Scapuzzi are 21 years old and both of them as far far behind Rekik in terms of development and he only turned 17 a few months ago and was a regular in the championship for the last couple of months on the season.
Rekik, Facey, and Hiwula are all in the first year academy age group this season and Suarez and Huws are in the second year. Rekik was by far the most developed on the pitch in a blue shirt and there was only Pogba who was more developed than him playing at all.
I think it hammers home the fact that the last few years have been rather dry in terms producing talent. Talent good enough to join the first team squad. Of the non academy age players on show, Razak and Wabara were the only ones to me that would be worth perservering with. Johannson,Helan (or a left back version of Ishmael Miller as he reminded me of), Elabdelouai, Asullin, and Scapuzzi are clearly all not anywhere near the desired level. These 5 are 2 and 3 years past academy age, its time to move them on.
I'd considier having a cull of the EDS this summer, the 5 above for starters. I think Ahmad Benali is already going. Then theres the likes of Sean Tse, Andrea Mancini, Ryan Mcgivern, Abdi Ibrahim, Alex Nimley, Greg Cunningham, Dedryk Boyata, all far past academy age and not good enough. Theres even the likes of Gunner Neilsen still knocking around according to the offical site.
We may aswell get rid or sell the lot of them. The second year Academy boys from this season and also next seasons more developed 16/17 years olds would benefit more with EDS games here in there thrown into their schedule next season (I think theres a U21 league kicking off for Premiership clubs which we are competing in).
I think the decision not to play in the reserve league has hurt the development of alot of the players this year. Regular competitive football would have been good for the likes of Roman, Bunn, Razak and Wabara. Whoever made that decision deserves sacking.
Also, I dont know about anyone else but Andy Welsh always comes across to me a clueless in interviews!
