PrezIke wrote:zuricity wrote:We will not get any improvement until the spafia get the boot.
They have destroyed what Bobby Manc was producing.
I hope josef gets rid of those two .
Ummm...
Don't agree.
We were a different type of team then. Defensive oriented under Mancini, and the players miserable by the end.
Txiki and Soriano can't manage the team on the pitch. We had FFP hurting us two summers ago, which is why we didn't sign Pogba, as far as I understand, and all of the hierarchy thought we would pass. We were punished and set us back a season when we needed a top signing.
Soriano has made us a global force, and increased our revenues substantially where we are the fastest growing club in the world. So, Khaldoon/Sheik Mansour should sack him? That's crazy talk, bro.
I also "love" reading the list of Txiki's signings that only list the scape goats, and always exclude the best players he's brought in (i.e. Fern1, KDB, Sterling, Delph). Even those that have fizzled were almost all widely seen as smart ones, spoken about with praise for their potential/quality (Jovetic, Mangala, Bony) even if some irked at some of their price tags.
We wouldn't be getting Pep, arguably the best manager in the world, if it wasn't for Txiki, so you may want to reconsider what you are asking for (which won't happen anyway, fortunately). Remember, we thought we would get Pep after he left Barca, but we ended up having to wait, so we had to do something knowing that would happen later, and Pellegrini was the best manager willing to come in knowing whoever took the job would be replaced by Pep after his contract with Bayern. It was a long term strategy that still netted us 4 trophies.
I'm not please with things either, but let's not write revisionist history because of it. Mancini, who I of course appreciate, needed to go as his big mouth to the press before talking to players, and harsh discipline in house, doesn't fit into man managing many top players in modern football, whether one likes it or not. Pellegrini's approach has it's pros and its cons, but doesn't have the juice to be a straight up disciplinarian, nor is it his style. His stubbornness has been an issue, but so have the abilities and attitudes of some of the players that have been here since before he even arrived when it comes to playing a more pressing style. Who knows what else it is, but I can tell you today we missed Yaya tremendously, because for as great as Silva can be he doesn't dictate the tempo the same way Yaya does, nor do either Ferns play that way.
I would have started Nacho and Sterling, so how is that Txiki or Soriano's fault exactly? Oh, they picked him as manager, right. Yet, again, all that I wrote above is reality, so we weren't really going to fire Manuel unless things really unravelled this season. Also consider all of the injuries over the past few seasons, and you can't entirely blame Pellegrini for that either (we also have been missing KDB, our "crack signing" who has played to expectations, at least, and drove us to several wins while he was fit).
Ray78 wrote:Mase wrote:Ray78 wrote:It isn't solely down to the manager, he is powerless when the players cross the white line.
That's ridiculous! What's the point in having him there on the sidelines then?
Can the manager win headers, win tackles track runners pick the right pass, . make intelligent runs and finish chances from the touchline? Bottom line it has been collective failure as far as the league goes.
Mase wrote:Ray78 wrote:Mase wrote:Ray78 wrote:It isn't solely down to the manager, he is powerless when the players cross the white line.
That's ridiculous! What's the point in having him there on the sidelines then?
Can the manager win headers, win tackles track runners pick the right pass, . make intelligent runs and finish chances from the touchline? Bottom line it has been collective failure as far as the league goes.
So why have a manager then at all? Get the owners to pick the best eleven and just had Kiddo on the touch line. You're trying to stick up for Pellers but going the wrong way about it and making a case for just fuckin him off altogether without you realising it.
If the manager isn't important why are top managers top managers and why has McClaren just been sacked?
The rag team that won the league in the final year of Slur Alex. That was pretty much the same team that Moyes fucked up. Yet Slur won the league with them. Why is that?
Ray78 wrote:Mase wrote:Ray78 wrote:Mase wrote:Ray78 wrote:It isn't solely down to the manager, he is powerless when the players cross the white line.
That's ridiculous! What's the point in having him there on the sidelines then?
Can the manager win headers, win tackles track runners pick the right pass, . make intelligent runs and finish chances from the touchline? Bottom line it has been collective failure as far as the league goes.
So why have a manager then at all? Get the owners to pick the best eleven and just had Kiddo on the touch line. You're trying to stick up for Pellers but going the wrong way about it and making a case for just fuckin him off altogether without you realising it.
If the manager isn't important why are top managers top managers and why has McClaren just been sacked?
The rag team that won the league in the final year of Slur Alex. That was pretty much the same team that Moyes fucked up. Yet Slur won the league with them. Why is that?
That rag team won the league in that season because of another collective failure from both Mancini and the players.
iwasthere2012 wrote:There's a lot of truth in that Ray.
But that was us not doing the job again.
Bacon Chops still got an average team over the line easily enough. I still think it was to the detriment of the club in the end. It was his ego and not the building for the future that mattered to him.
He still got the job done.
Ray78 wrote:iwasthere2012 wrote:There's a lot of truth in that Ray.
But that was us not doing the job again.
Bacon Chops still got an average team over the line easily enough. I still think it was to the detriment of the club in the end. It was his ego and not the building for the future that mattered to him.
He still got the job done.
They still had a helping hand from the officials in that season which also prominent throughout Bacon chops reign,
iwasthere2012 wrote:Ray78 wrote:iwasthere2012 wrote:There's a lot of truth in that Ray.
But that was us not doing the job again.
Bacon Chops still got an average team over the line easily enough. I still think it was to the detriment of the club in the end. It was his ego and not the building for the future that mattered to him.
He still got the job done.
They still had a helping hand from the officials in that season which also prominent throughout Bacon chops reign,
Agreed. But I'm not denying that we were every bit as miserable in our defense of the title.
South Stand Balti wrote:PrezIke wrote:Ummm...
Don't agree.
We were a different type of team then. Defensive oriented under Mancini, and the players miserable by the end.
Txiki and Soriano can't manage the team on the pitch. We had FFP hurting us two summers ago, which is why we didn't sign Pogba, as far as I understand, and all of the hierarchy thought we would pass. We were punished and set us back a season when we needed a top signing.
Soriano has made us a global force, and increased our revenues substantially where we are the fastest growing club in the world. So, Khaldoon/Sheik Mansour should sack him? That's crazy talk, bro.
I also "love" reading the list of Txiki's signings that only list the scape goats, and always exclude the best players he's brought in (i.e. Fern1, KDB, Sterling, Delph). Even those that have fizzled were almost all widely seen as smart ones, spoken about with praise for their potential/quality (Jovetic, Mangala, Bony) even if some irked at some of their price tags.
We wouldn't be getting Pep, arguably the best manager in the world, if it wasn't for Txiki, so you may want to reconsider what you are asking for (which won't happen anyway, fortunately). Remember, we thought we would get Pep after he left Barca, but we ended up having to wait, so we had to do something knowing that would happen later, and Pellegrini was the best manager willing to come in knowing whoever took the job would be replaced by Pep after his contract with Bayern. It was a long term strategy that still netted us 4 trophies.
I'm not please with things either, but let's not write revisionist history because of it. Mancini, who I of course appreciate, needed to go as his big mouth to the press before talking to players, and harsh discipline in house, doesn't fit into man managing many top players in modern football, whether one likes it or not. Pellegrini's approach has it's pros and its cons, but doesn't have the juice to be a straight up disciplinarian, nor is it his style. His stubbornness has been an issue, but so have the abilities and attitudes of some of the players that have been here since before he even arrived when it comes to playing a more pressing style. Who knows what else it is, but I can tell you today we missed Yaya tremendously, because for as great as Silva can be he doesn't dictate the tempo the same way Yaya does, nor do either Ferns play that way.
I would have started Nacho and Sterling, so how is that Txiki or Soriano's fault exactly? Oh, they picked him as manager, right. Yet, again, all that I wrote above is reality, so we weren't really going to fire Manuel unless things really unravelled this season. Also consider all of the injuries over the past few seasons, and you can't entirely blame Pellegrini for that either (we also have been missing KDB, our "crack signing" who has played to expectations, at least, and drove us to several wins while he was fit).
Best players....Sterling and Delph? It really has been a long day.
Spot on it was in the last 3rd we were found wanting. Frankly I'm fucking sick to the back teeth of listening to people blaming pellegrini. Look at today nobody would have quibbled with the line up in terms of formation and quality. The players should have been able to have been good enough to have won the game comfortably simple as.
gillie wrote:Last two away games no Yaya. It seems no Yaya no Mojo.
This ..we were crying out for YaYa Not just from shots outside the box But his Bulldozer attitude when defense is packed out
Cocacolajojo wrote:This ..we were crying out for YaYa Not just from shots outside the box But his Bulldozer attitude when defense is packed out
I see where you're coming from but it's not like it worked against West Ham, Aston Villa, Everton, and so on, where Yaya played.
Wonderwall wrote:Cocacolajojo wrote:This ..we were crying out for YaYa Not just from shots outside the box But his Bulldozer attitude when defense is packed out
I see where you're coming from but it's not like it worked against West Ham, Aston Villa, Everton, and so on, where Yaya played.
It would have been nice to have the yaya option to bring on, I thought we missed him on Saturday and I have been his biggest critic of late
Return to The Maine Football forum
Users browsing this forum: branny, Google [Bot], Majestic-12 [Bot] and 133 guests