Should i choose Shay Given or Joe Hart in ready,steady,cook.

[Sister of fu]

Ready, steady, cook.

On Thursday I am doing an event with the pair and some school children and I have to choose which one I'm cooking with.

I can't make my mind up so I'm throwing it open to you guys to assist.

**edit. title changed for those of you not reading the full bloody thing....twunts**

[MaineRoadMemories]

Just from gut feeling I reckon Shay would be the better choice. He always looks really interested in the mascots and generally got involved with the kids when he used to play for us.

[Blue in the face]

Oops. I didn't read your post before voting and went for Joe. So I will stick with him.

He doesn't look like he can cook, but he looks like he will fit in with a bunch of kids. Especially if they stand on boxes.

P.S.
Dont depend on him to lift anything out of the oven............. Just in case (you know what I'm getting at).

[BlueMoonAwoken]

I didnt read your post i assumed it was who i wanted currently in net and i chose shay, but id guess joe will be more funny and shay be more into the kids.

[Abu Dhabi]

Some people didn't get it, or was it me?

She is saying that both will be at the event, but need to choose who will help in cooking.
Seeming to be nice with children is irrelevant.

[lets all have a disco]

Joe needs to sort his recipe out Given has been preparing a while.

Given for me,plus Joe will prolly drop an egg.

[dazby]

Depends. What's going to be in your bag?

[Slim]

Hart, whatever good work has gone into making him a better keeper will be destroyed if we drop him now, loss of confidence could turn him into another Kirkland.

[dazby]

Hart, whatever good work has gone into making him a better keeper will be destroyed if we drop him now, loss of confidence could turn him into another Kirkland.

Reread the thread Mr Pedantic.

[Slim]

Hart, whatever good work has gone into making him a better keeper will be destroyed if we drop him now, loss of confidence could turn him into another Kirkland.

Reread the thread Mr Pedantic.

I thought she was being overly cryptic.

[Dameerto]

Shay's more likely to have a wider range of kitchen skills since he's older than Joe - Joe looks like someone who lives on takeaways to me.

[Niall Quinns Discopants]

Just from gut feeling I reckon Shay would be the better choice. He always looks really interested in the mascots and generally got involved with the kids when he used to play for us.

Absolutely.

Seems to me like great family man, always posing for and with the kids. Seems great in official site charity videos as well.

It HAS to be Given.

[Fullartj]

Sorry I didnt read the post either. I would defo go for Shay he's older and i'm sure that his cooking has improved a lot since he hasnt been playing!

[Nickyboy]

Saw Given with his wife and kids a couple of weeks ago and he was a proper family man.

Imagine Joe to more interested in the kids older sisters and doubt he'd be knocking up nothing more than cheese on toast

[gaudy]

met shay before and sat to have a drink with us,really down to earth,genuine bloke-comes across the same way when you see him larkin about in any of the os videos.
shay for me without a doubt.............or balotelli!

[Blue Blood]

Gotta be Joe.

Mancini says its not possible to rotate keepers in competitions..

Bobby knows best.

[Slim]

Gotta be Joe.

Mancini says its not possible to rotate keepers in competitions..

Bobby knows best.

-chortle- Seems I am not the only one who didn't read SoF's post, but then again she doesn't understand the offside rule.

[Blue Blood]

Gotta be Joe.

Mancini says its not possible to rotate keepers in competitions..

Bobby knows best.

-chortle- Seems I am not the only one who didn't read SoF's post, but then again she doesn't understand the offside rule.

I read it, i was just trying to be witty. lol.

No keeper rotations in any competitions, whether its Prem, Europa, FA cup or Ready, Steady, Cook.

Mancini says it's "not possible" so it's not.

Bobby is the law in this town.

*oh and yes women have no idea about the offside rule, although one did try to explain it to me with pepper pots which totally threw me as I know nothing about the kitchen and things that reside within it, lol*

[Slim]

Gotta be Joe.

Mancini says its not possible to rotate keepers in competitions..

Bobby knows best.

-chortle- Seems I am not the only one who didn't read SoF's post, but then again she doesn't understand the offside rule.

I read it, i was just trying to be witty. lol.

No keeper rotations in any competitions, whether its Prem, Europa, FA cup or Ready, Steady, Cook.

Mancini says it's "not possible" so it's not.

Bobby is the law in this town.

*oh and yes women have no idea about the offside rule, although one did try to explain it to me with pepper pots which totally threw me as I know nothing about the kitchen and things that reside within it, lol*

-sniff- I just didn't want to be alone.

[DoomMerchant]

Hart, whatever good work has gone into making him a better keeper will be destroyed if we drop him now, loss of confidence could turn him into another Kirkland.

Reread the thread Mr Pedantic.

I thought she was being overly cryptic.

your best post ever. FACT.

it would be Shay for me, tho i Slim'd it all up and voted Joe since i thought it was about who i want between the sticks without even reading your post. Doh!

I think Shay would be a nicer, more talkative bloke and you'd prollee get more of a sense for how things were going with the team too during idle chit chat. Once Joe sniffs out that he's not getting in your knickers? Game over. Can't say i blame him.

cheers