Sister of fu wrote:It looked shocking last night when Demichaels comes haring out claiming offside and everyone else was stood behind him. Very school boy and very basic. We have serious issues if we can’t get the basic aspects of defending sorted like all stepping up together as a unit. Will give them the slight benefit that the back line is forever chopping and changing from one game to the next so no partnerships are forming. This does need to be addressed ASAP though as better teams will take advantage.
Hazy2 wrote:Ted, before I comment, thanks for starting threads like this. I watched from the Colin Bell last night, Both James Milner and Micah looked rusty to be fair to them, however as a combo I can see your points on Blend, both have nothing this City , and for me they are never going to move us forward, they lack a touch they lack a pass, sad to say Micah is still that raw all power 18yr old. Milner sorry to say he is a great lad but nothing more than a worker. Bardsley scoring that side with these two plus last night sorry for all fans of the players they are old City against poor opos. Last year Milner had Nasri in his sights, this year Nasri looks 3 levels above him.
Hazy2 wrote:Ted, before I comment, thanks for starting threads like this. I watched from the Colin Bell last night, Both James Milner and Micah looked rusty to be fair to them, however as a combo I can see your points on Blend, both have nothing this City , and for me they are never going to move us forward, they lack a touch they lack a pass, sad to say Micah is still that raw all power 18yr old. Milner sorry to say he is a great lad but nothing more than a worker. Bardsley scoring that side with these two plus last night sorry for all fans of the players they are old City against poor opos. Last year Milner had Nasri in his sights, this year Nasri looks 3 levels above him.
Foreverinbluedreams wrote:Hazy2 wrote:Ted, before I comment, thanks for starting threads like this. I watched from the Colin Bell last night, Both James Milner and Micah looked rusty to be fair to them, however as a combo I can see your points on Blend, both have nothing this City , and for me they are never going to move us forward, they lack a touch they lack a pass, sad to say Micah is still that raw all power 18yr old. Milner sorry to say he is a great lad but nothing more than a worker. Bardsley scoring that side with these two plus last night sorry for all fans of the players they are old City against poor opos. Last year Milner had Nasri in his sights, this year Nasri looks 3 levels above him.
Funny, it was the left hand side that looked exposed to me first half, when Milner went left second half that vulnerability was adressed somewhat. I do accept that Milner is lacking in quality though, although that was a sweet cross for Dzekchair's header.
@Ted, can't argue with any of the points you made. The defensive five are all decent players in their own right but as a unit they are painfully slow and a counter attacking side's wet dream.
Twobob wrote:Be a quicker response than the OP deserves i'm afraid. Great thread again Ted, something thought provoking.
I noticed several times last night that Martin D rushed forward to defend into the huge hole in midfield, initial thoughts are 'what the fuck is he doing - again!?'
However he had to, the gap was there in midfield as there was no one covering in front of the back four, in positions where typically Barry would have sat back in anticipating their break.
We've had to do that before so it's nothing new as its pulled Lescott and Nasti out of position too.
I noticed several timed that the back four where not working together, MD was trying to pull us forward in a line but too many times Richards was dawdling and the line was more of a wave. I seriously get the impression that the amount of prep and hard work needed to get a back for in unison is either not there, with very little planning or the players involved are leaving their brains in the changing room.
With regards to Richards, he seems to have regressed 4 years where he seed almost unaware of what was happening around him, at Sunderland for their goal he was wandering somewhere and last night seemed to be out of touch tactically (from a defensive perspective). Now i Know he's a better player than that as do most of us so have to simply put it down to lack of game time due to injury etc affecting him more than others.
I totally agree with the sentiments about Milner playing centrally - he should now be the one taking on that Barry role we're clearly missing. Garcia is a waste of space and actually looked lethargic yesterday. What Milner is missing in flair he more than makes up for in worth ethic, positional sense and all-round play - skills that add Balance to the team - we cant win anything with a team of David Silva's. He's one of our most important players in the squad who should feature ahead of Garcia every time!
I'm going to have to leave it there for now, this is as I see it so may be slightly warped from reality :-)
Foreverinbluedreams wrote:Twobob wrote:Be a quicker response than the OP deserves i'm afraid. Great thread again Ted, something thought provoking.
I noticed several times last night that Martin D rushed forward to defend into the huge hole in midfield, initial thoughts are 'what the fuck is he doing - again!?'
However he had to, the gap was there in midfield as there was no one covering in front of the back four, in positions where typically Barry would have sat back in anticipating their break.
We've had to do that before so it's nothing new as its pulled Lescott and Nasti out of position too.
I noticed several timed that the back four where not working together, MD was trying to pull us forward in a line but too many times Richards was dawdling and the line was more of a wave. I seriously get the impression that the amount of prep and hard work needed to get a back for in unison is either not there, with very little planning or the players involved are leaving their brains in the changing room.
With regards to Richards, he seems to have regressed 4 years where he seed almost unaware of what was happening around him, at Sunderland for their goal he was wandering somewhere and last night seemed to be out of touch tactically (from a defensive perspective). Now i Know he's a better player than that as do most of us so have to simply put it down to lack of game time due to injury etc affecting him more than others.
I totally agree with the sentiments about Milner playing centrally - he should now be the one taking on that Barry role we're clearly missing. Garcia is a waste of space and actually looked lethargic yesterday. What Milner is missing in flair he more than makes up for in worth ethic, positional sense and all-round play - skills that add Balance to the team - we cant win anything with a team of David Silva's. He's one of our most important players in the squad who should feature ahead of Garcia every time!
I'm going to have to leave it there for now, this is as I see it so may be slightly warped from reality :-)
I agree with most of what you've said but I have to take issue with a couple of things.
First up Richards, don't take this as a general defence of his performances because it's not, he has been well below par in the limited game time he has got since his return from injury but I have to take issue with the finger pointing over Sunderland's goal, I know Micah's positional sense is one of his biggest flaws but on this occasion he was doing exactly what he should be doing. He was marking Johnson, who had dropped deep, meanwhile Bardsley made a run up our right side which Milner ( his man ) tracked, now tell me what is Micah meant to do? Should he leave Johnson free and double up on Phil Bardsley or should he let Milner deal with it and not let Johnson out of his sight? If you look at the replay again you will see Micah at the edge of our box when the goal goes in and he's goal side of Johnson who had burst forward to support Bardsley.
Second thing is Milner in the centre doing the mopping up, I've seen/heard quite a few suggesting Milner would be ideal in this role but what I want to know is what are people basing this on? Has he ever played this role? I've seen him play brilliantly in the centre of the park but that was in a more advanced role where we have Silva and/or Nasri but I've never seen him in a more defensive minded midfield role.
Ted Hughes wrote:Foreverinbluedreams wrote:Twobob wrote:Be a quicker response than the OP deserves i'm afraid. Great thread again Ted, something thought provoking.
I noticed several times last night that Martin D rushed forward to defend into the huge hole in midfield, initial thoughts are 'what the fuck is he doing - again!?'
However he had to, the gap was there in midfield as there was no one covering in front of the back four, in positions where typically Barry would have sat back in anticipating their break.
We've had to do that before so it's nothing new as its pulled Lescott and Nasti out of position too.
I noticed several timed that the back four where not working together, MD was trying to pull us forward in a line but too many times Richards was dawdling and the line was more of a wave. I seriously get the impression that the amount of prep and hard work needed to get a back for in unison is either not there, with very little planning or the players involved are leaving their brains in the changing room.
With regards to Richards, he seems to have regressed 4 years where he seed almost unaware of what was happening around him, at Sunderland for their goal he was wandering somewhere and last night seemed to be out of touch tactically (from a defensive perspective). Now i Know he's a better player than that as do most of us so have to simply put it down to lack of game time due to injury etc affecting him more than others.
I totally agree with the sentiments about Milner playing centrally - he should now be the one taking on that Barry role we're clearly missing. Garcia is a waste of space and actually looked lethargic yesterday. What Milner is missing in flair he more than makes up for in worth ethic, positional sense and all-round play - skills that add Balance to the team - we cant win anything with a team of David Silva's. He's one of our most important players in the squad who should feature ahead of Garcia every time!
I'm going to have to leave it there for now, this is as I see it so may be slightly warped from reality :-)
I agree with most of what you've said but I have to take issue with a couple of things.
First up Richards, don't take this as a general defence of his performances because it's not, he has been well below par in the limited game time he has got since his return from injury but I have to take issue with the finger pointing over Sunderland's goal, I know Micah's positional sense is one of his biggest flaws but on this occasion he was doing exactly what he should be doing. He was marking Johnson, who had dropped deep, meanwhile Bardsley made a run up our right side which Milner ( his man ) tracked, now tell me what is Micah meant to do? Should he leave Johnson free and double up on Phil Bardsley or should he let Milner deal with it and not let Johnson out of his sight? If you look at the replay again you will see Micah at the edge of our box when the goal goes in and he's goal side of Johnson who had burst forward to support Bardsley.
Second thing is Milner in the centre doing the mopping up, I've seen/heard quite a few suggesting Milner would be ideal in this role but what I want to know is what are people basing this on? Has he ever played this role? I've seen him play brilliantly in the centre of the park but that was in a more advanced role where we have Silva and/or Nasri but I've never seen him in a more defensive minded midfield role.
Last night would have been a pretty good time to find out.
Because of the urge to play Garcia, we learned very little positive information about the squad & achieved nothing new tactically.
But does he have to 'pick up' on his own anyway ? What about Milner, Fernandinho, Yaya as a 3 man, tight central midfield, rotating positions, for an experiment, then say Nasri Navas (Silva) making it into a five, potentially for away games in C League ?
We could have tried that for 45 with Dzeko upfront as an added handicap, to put pressure on it, & see how it coped at both ends of the pitch.
Hazy2 wrote:Ted Hughes wrote:Foreverinbluedreams wrote:Twobob wrote:Be a quicker response than the OP deserves i'm afraid. Great thread again Ted, something thought provoking.
I noticed several times last night that Martin D rushed forward to defend into the huge hole in midfield, initial thoughts are 'what the fuck is he doing - again!?'
However he had to, the gap was there in midfield as there was no one covering in front of the back four, in positions where typically Barry would have sat back in anticipating their break.
We've had to do that before so it's nothing new as its pulled Lescott and Nasti out of position too.
I noticed several timed that the back four where not working together, MD was trying to pull us forward in a line but too many times Richards was dawdling and the line was more of a wave. I seriously get the impression that the amount of prep and hard work needed to get a back for in unison is either not there, with very little planning or the players involved are leaving their brains in the changing room.
With regards to Richards, he seems to have regressed 4 years where he seed almost unaware of what was happening around him, at Sunderland for their goal he was wandering somewhere and last night seemed to be out of touch tactically (from a defensive perspective). Now i Know he's a better player than that as do most of us so have to simply put it down to lack of game time due to injury etc affecting him more than others.
I totally agree with the sentiments about Milner playing centrally - he should now be the one taking on that Barry role we're clearly missing. Garcia is a waste of space and actually looked lethargic yesterday. What Milner is missing in flair he more than makes up for in worth ethic, positional sense and all-round play - skills that add Balance to the team - we cant win anything with a team of David Silva's. He's one of our most important players in the squad who should feature ahead of Garcia every time!
I'm going to have to leave it there for now, this is as I see it so may be slightly warped from reality :-)
I agree with most of what you've said but I have to take issue with a couple of things.
First up Richards, don't take this as a general defence of his performances because it's not, he has been well below par in the limited game time he has got since his return from injury but I have to take issue with the finger pointing over Sunderland's goal, I know Micah's positional sense is one of his biggest flaws but on this occasion he was doing exactly what he should be doing. He was marking Johnson, who had dropped deep, meanwhile Bardsley made a run up our right side which Milner ( his man ) tracked, now tell me what is Micah meant to do? Should he leave Johnson free and double up on Phil Bardsley or should he let Milner deal with it and not let Johnson out of his sight? If you look at the replay again you will see Micah at the edge of our box when the goal goes in and he's goal side of Johnson who had burst forward to support Bardsley.
Second thing is Milner in the centre doing the mopping up, I've seen/heard quite a few suggesting Milner would be ideal in this role but what I want to know is what are people basing this on? Has he ever played this role? I've seen him play brilliantly in the centre of the park but that was in a more advanced role where we have Silva and/or Nasri but I've never seen him in a more defensive minded midfield role.
Last night would have been a pretty good time to find out.
Because of the urge to play Garcia, we learned very little positive information about the squad & achieved nothing new tactically.
But does he have to 'pick up' on his own anyway ? What about Milner, Fernandinho, Yaya as a 3 man, tight central midfield, rotating positions, for an experiment, then say Nasri Navas (Silva) making it into a five, potentially for away games in C League ?
We could have tried that for 45 with Dzeko upfront as an added handicap, to put pressure on it, & see how it coped at both ends of the pitch.
Richards is in need of games taht is fair, I just do not see him as the right back or back up central defender. He has just for me never improved, Raw Powe, same as Milner, model pro who lacks the quality needed every week for us, 1st half Wed was so bad from them my mate said we must have EDS players with more ability than the two them.
mcfc1632 wrote:Ted - great thread and thought provoking - but on a train so not able to respond to your key points.
Do not want to distract but I must take issue with your taking issue with:"
"but I have to take issue with the finger pointing over Sunderland's goal, I know Micah's positional sense is one of his biggest flaws but on this occasion he was doing exactly what he should be doing. He was marking Johnson, who had dropped deep, meanwhile Bardsley made a run up our right side which Milner ( his man ) tracked, now tell me what is Micah meant to do? "
I do not think that he was marking anyone - the fact that Johnson was vaguely within 5 yards at that time does not = marking. If that was marking - on that basis in that game at various times Micah was probably marking all 11 players, some of ours and a few people in the crowd.
He is lacking any football brain at the moment - IMO.
Anyway - do not want to distract from an excellent thread
getdressedmctavish wrote:As I said on the day, this is the one aspect where Pellers is completely fucking up.However, with a day to cool down one can usefully ask"if every man and his dog can see Milner for Garcia, is it possible Pellers can't?"why does he persist.? Has he had a look at Milner at DM in training and decided it don't work. Does Garcia train brilliantly. This latter is possible because Doug always rated him on what he saw on the training field. The worry is that the Count is just blind to this. He gave Nasri short shrift for telling him what was required. At 2-1 that was the time to go to a five and try some options, ie getting behind the ball and moving up as a unit. The most alarming thing about Garcia's awfulness on Weds was the number of times I saw him running towards our goal. Did he make on key interception v a team of mugs? Imagine Bayern, RM, Barcelona....it doesn't bare thinking about.as for Edin, an absolutely disgraceful display but one we have seen many times. I doubt he'll ever start a game for us again other than the league cup and he shouldn't start that.
zuricity wrote: To refer to the plsen team as a team of 'mugs' is highly disrespectful. The rest isn't worth commenting on. It was a dead game , we are going through the motions , building up to a very important winter. No injuries, do enough to win. Leave it at that. EDIT: Garcia is not as bad as people on this website try to make out.
Return to The Maine Football forum
Users browsing this forum: Harry Dowd scored, Majestic-12 [Bot], salford city and 147 guests