Robinho and Elano [MERGED]

[s1ty m]

Simple question, would you have them both back?

How sweet it woul have been to hear that goal described as two manchester city players combining.

no. robinho is a turd and elano is a windy tart, always was alays will be. their attitudes are horrible. elano is where he belongs and i don't really give a toss about the tubby brazilian robinho, he clearly does not give a toss about a club that paid him over 100k a week. eye-watering.

[Mase]

Robinho played well, Elano scored but otherwise did fuck all. That was against a team that wouldn't get in the PL. What basis is that for having Elano back? In place of who?

At least Robinho scored goals & did pretty well in home games in his 1st season under Hughes. Elano had 5-6 decent games under 2 managers. He's not even starring in Turkey ffs. Jo would have done ok v North Korea, perhaps we should get him back?

I thought he still played for us? Or am I missing something??

[Mase]

You never know though, if Robson does come back he might get a start in his proper position.

[Fish111]

Robinho show-ponying against North Korea? Whoopee Do. Wait to see if he turns on the style against Spain, Holland, Italy or even us!! And wait to see if Elano spits his dummy out when he doesn't get as much time on the ball as North Korea allowed him.

I would, however, have Maicon & Alves at City.

[shadz69]

Neither.2 moany muppets.Doing it 1 game in 3 aint good enough anymore and causing shit all the time wont be tolerated,good on the club and the managers concerned.Robbie is 1 of those players,great to watch but you dont want him in your team.

[btajim]

You never know though, if Robson does come back he might get a start in his proper position.

The substituted Substitute under Mancini. Everton Away, IIRC. Robinho could have a future at City but things would need to change on his part. One of the most exciting Players on the ball in a City Shirt yet a shadow of that last season. Who remembers when he walked out of a training camp without permission? Imagine if that had been Joey Barton?

Elano has gone and will not be coming back. He ended up playing in Turkey and I've no idea how he's getting on over there.

[Vhero]

Always said Robinhos game went to pot after Elano left and everytime he plays with him for Brazil he plays better. I still miss Elano though and wish we never got rid fucking Hughes.

Suddenly my opinion seems all the more valid ........

I don't think he is really saying that he wants Hughes back, just missed punctuation.

You on the other hand....

Indeed thankyou lol just realised I missed it. I blame Hughes falling out for Elano for the fact he started playing shit on pitch on was eventually shipped off.

[dick dastardley]

the simple answer is- THEY DONT LIKE IT UP 'EM, in other word the prem has been too hard for them in the spanish leagues they get all the time in the world, the prem is more a mans game as in hard tackles and lots of action with no time on the ball!!

[Kladze]

Always said Robinhos game went to pot after Elano left and everytime he plays with him for Brazil he plays better. I still miss Elano though and wish we never got rid fucking Hughes.

Suddenly my opinion seems all the more valid ........

I don't think he is really saying that he wants Hughes back, just missed punctuation.

You on the other hand....

Me on the other hand what? .... I don't want Hughes back dude.
I actually read Vhero's post quite correctly - saying he wanted Elano back and also that Robinho would be magically transformed into a world beater as a result.

[Niall Quinns Discopants]

I hate being called "dude".

[Kladze]

I hate being called "dude".

Sorry dude







;-)

[Niall Quinns Discopants]

I hate being called "dude".

Sorry dude







;-)

Sweet.

[Slim]

I hate being called "dude".

Sorry dude







;-)

Sweet.

Dude, what does mine say?

[Dubaimancityfan]

Both of them will have good world cups. Luckily for them it’s held in between May – September. The only months they bothered to turn up for city.

The temperature was near freezing point yesterday !!

[lets all have a disco]

Fuck Elano,i'd take Robson back as long as he is 100% into it.

[Ted Hughes]

Robinho played well, Elano scored but otherwise did fuck all. That was against a team that wouldn't get in the PL. What basis is that for having Elano back? In place of who?

At least Robinho scored goals & did pretty well in home games in his 1st season under Hughes. Elano had 5-6 decent games under 2 managers. He's not even starring in Turkey ffs. Jo would have done ok v North Korea, perhaps we should get him back?

I thought he still played for us? Or am I missing something??

Have you seen him lately?

[Mase]

Robinho played well, Elano scored but otherwise did fuck all. That was against a team that wouldn't get in the PL. What basis is that for having Elano back? In place of who?

At least Robinho scored goals & did pretty well in home games in his 1st season under Hughes. Elano had 5-6 decent games under 2 managers. He's not even starring in Turkey ffs. Jo would have done ok v North Korea, perhaps we should get him back?

I thought he still played for us? Or am I missing something??

Have you seen him lately?

I didn't see Danny Mills for about 5 years but I knew that slag was still taking our money!

[Ted Hughes]

Robinho played well, Elano scored but otherwise did fuck all. That was against a team that wouldn't get in the PL. What basis is that for having Elano back? In place of who?

At least Robinho scored goals & did pretty well in home games in his 1st season under Hughes. Elano had 5-6 decent games under 2 managers. He's not even starring in Turkey ffs. Jo would have done ok v North Korea, perhaps we should get him back?

I thought he still played for us? Or am I missing something??

Have you seen him lately?

I didn't see Danny Mills for about 5 years but I knew that slag was still taking our money!

Hopefully someone else has been paying Jo's although I noticed he was behaving like an arsehole over there so perhaps they won't to continue doing so.

[Niall Quinns Discopants]

I hate being called "dude".

Sorry dude







;-)

Sweet.

Dude, what does mine say?

Sweet

What does mine say?

[btajim]

Fuck Elano,i'd take Robson back as long as he is 100% into it.

It seems so odd to read people saying this after he was near Legend status within about 3 months of his first season at City. I'm not saying you did - but lots of people were shouting his name from the rooftops.

I know Elano didn't seem to like playing for Hughes but the red hot form of Ireland in his last season at City certainly didn't help. He handed in a transfer request because he wouldn't stay and fight for his place in the Team.