by Beefymcfc » Wed Dec 15, 2010 4:29 pm
Let's break this statement down:
Kia Joorabchian: Manchester City reneged on promises made to Carlos Tévez
The transfer of Yaya Touré.
“I’m not an agent so I don’t act as an agent,” he said. “You can see evidence that Manchester City invited me to help them so to suggest anything else is wrong.”
And that's why you weren't paid, but if you are not an agent, why would the club ask? And, you state later that you are not really welcome at the club, so once again, why would they ask?
Joorabchian refuted suggestions that Tévez might refuse to play for City. “I want to be clear that Carlos has never said he is not going to play or train or be professional. So those rumours are rubbish,” he said.
Then why leak such information to Neil Ashton unless it was a bluff - that has been called?
“He will play if picked and 100 per cent do his best. He feels that is important every time he puts on the shirt. He always gives 100 per cent. ”
And so he should do, he wouldn't want to let the fan's, or himself down, especially as he's putting himself in the shop window. Oh, and there's the little matter of his wages and breach of contract, isn't there..
Nevertheless Tévez had wanted to leave City at the end of last season. “When Carlos Tévez first signed for Manchester City there was a reason why he signed. He saw the vision of the owner and the way the club wanted to go,”
So what has changed, the project and vision is still in place?
“Carlos is a winner, everywhere he has been in his life he has been a winner. He decided he would sign for the club, play one year outside of the Champions League and hopefully take this club into the next phase.
What about West Ham, was he a winner there? And, why did he not sign a one year contract or at least write in a get-out clause?
“When he joined City he made a commitment that this was what he wanted to do. At the end of last season, after all the turmoil that went on, Carlos was bitterly disappointed because they didn’t qualify for the Champions League.
So, he should try twice as hard for not getting us there in the 1st place, afterall, we allowed him the time to sort himself out in his first season and subsequently since then.
"And he felt the situation at the club was not going in the same direction as he imagined it would be going. He played out of his skin, did everything he possibly could.
So, second in the league when this came out is not the same direction, afterall, he does want Championsm League doesn't he?
“In the summer he wanted to leave. I then spent most of my summer travelling all around the world talking to the chairman of Manchester City [Khaldoon Al Mubarak] and to Carlos in order to try and convince him that we should try to find an agreement that would allow us and help us to go to the next phase.
Why would you travel around for him, you're not his agent, are you? And, what was the agreement - money perhaps?
"He would then not feel like he wanted to leave. I think I managed to successfully convince Carlos to speak to the chairman and let the two of them find a harmonious way to get this back on track.
So, a satisfactory outcome was found and he played on. And if you'd already sorted it with Khaldoon, why the problem with Cook - who's the boss?
“I’m surprised at the club’s reaction because they were fully aware of the situation and how I was helping. The two of them spoke and they spoke with the rest of the management.
Still not an agent then?
"The chairman asked Carlos to stay and the management agreed that he had certain issues that he wanted dealt with. They wanted to wait until Sept 1 to address the issues he had because they wanted to concentrate on the transfer window.”
Issue's, what issue's? We got the player's, we've got the staff, we are next to the top of the league - what issue's? And why wait until he wouldn't be able to leave knowing he would be stuck here?
However, Joorabchian said, it was the failure to address these ‘issues’ that changed everything. “Through September Carlos again began to get disillusioned because his viewpoint was it was not happening. His view was that they had agreed and spoke and promises were made to him and now the window was closed these issues were not being resolved.
Issue's again, eh? We've been in or around the top of the league all season, so it couldn't be that, could it? Couldn't be a player thing either, because he was willing to wait for them to come in in the first place and knew no more could be brought in. Or, was it the style of play with him needing help up-front? Well, it may have been an issue but that has now clearly been adressed so should no longer be a concern.
"Carlos wanted to leave, I went to speak to them and they said there would be a new contract, new clauses in the contract etc. They sent the proposal, we countered one time and then we said ‘you know what Carlos doesn’t want it, thank you very much, no’.”
Is that because it wasn't effective immediately and you'd have to wait until the summer? If it was about clauses regarding him able to leave, why didn't he sign it and then just leave, afterall, he would've got the get-out clause he wanted? But obviously, clearly not about the money!
“I’m absolutely confident that the emails will show we acted in a correct manner at all times,” Joorabchian said. “I feel absolutely confident that if everyone is happy to make that public we have not done anything unprofessional or behaved in anything other than a correct manner.
So, if you are negotiating with the club on behalf of Carlos, does that not make you an agent?
“If we have to show a dossier that is chronological and shows the whole picture from start to finish, so that people can see what has gone on, then I’m confident that I have nothing to hide and nothing to worry about.”
Please show it, it would make for interesting reading. Also, do we now do deal's by way of E-Mail, especially multi-million pound ones?
He added: “Carlos has been very clear that this was his decision and he has not been influenced by anyone else.
I would hope not, but what advice have you been giving him? Oh, and isn't that his agents duty?
“The people who work for the club should be ‘thinking there is a problem here, how do we find a solution to this problem’ rather than fuelling the fire.”
I thought he just wanted out, how do you find a solution to an irreversible situation?
Joorabchian’s relationship with City chief executive Garry Cook has also come under scrutiny. “For anyone to think that either me or Garry Cook are bigger than the story of the club is ridiculous. I don’t think I am important enough or he is important enough,” he said of the former Nike executive who Joorabchian says he helped get his job at City.
“I introduced them and in fact I acted as his agent and increased his salary more than four times what he was being earned in the States. He even offered me a commission, which I turned down,” he said.
“Garry was not involved in the Carlos Tévez transfer at all and I think maybe through that and other issues the whole concept of the job took him by surprise. He just thought ‘oh my God, this is brilliant I’m in charge of this club’.
"I definitely don’t see this as about me and Garry Cook. Carlos is his own man and has his own strong opinions and to suggest that this is about me and Garry Cook is a joke. Carlos’ issues with the club have nothing to do with my relationship with Garry. My relationship with him has been like it is for two years, it didn’t start on yesterday.”
Is this why you had to chase Khaldoon around the world, knowing that Cook would not deal with you? 2 years in the wilderness is a bit of a slap in the face, isn't it?
“Right now Carlos has made his point very clearly that he has issues,” he said. “At a certain time the club and Carlos will have to sit down and try and find an amicable solution here It’s much more constructive for people like Garry and myself to work to find solutions rather than any ideas that we are trying to influence.
What is this amicable solution - money, early release or something more? And why would it be easier for you and Garry to work to find solution's when the reality is that you are not an agent and therefore have no bearing on the club whatsoever? Or do you want back into the fold for some reason and real crux of the matter is your issue's with Garry rather than Carlos' issue's with the club?
"Everybody is being hurt by this right now.”
Especially you!
In the words of my Old Man, "Life will never be the same without Man City, so get it in while you can".
The Future's Bright, The Future's Blue!!!