The mancityfans.net football forum

Cant see this mentioned elsewhere so my apologies if covered but Irish radio did an interview with Dunnie this morning at the Irish training camp and they discussed his transfer to Villa....Dunnie said that City accepted an offer from Villa and then informed him that the offer had been accepted, Dunnie asked if he could stay and fight for his place but was told that the offer had been accepted and that they (City) needed the money! It was all said in good fun and got a great laugh from the journo's but there was an edge to Dunnies demenour that seemed to infer that he was let go without the opportunity to fight for his place ...basically he was kicked out. The club is entitled to do things as they see fit but I am still not sure this is a good decision and I really got the impression that Dunnie was disappointed he couldnt fight for his spot. City (the club) and its welfare will always come ahead of any individual but I feel that this transfer was a bit strange.

trout man wrote:Cant see this mentioned elsewhere so my apologies if covered but Irish radio did an interview with Dunnie this morning at the Irish training camp and they discussed his transfer to Villa....Dunnie said that City accepted an offer from Villa and then informed him that the offer had been accepted, Dunnie asked if he could stay and fight for his place but was told that the offer had been accepted and that they (City) needed the money! It was all said in good fun and got a great laugh from the journo's but there was an edge to Dunnies demenour that seemed to infer that he was let go without the opportunity to fight for his place ...basically he was kicked out. The club is entitled to do things as they see fit but I am still not sure this is a good decision and I really got the impression that Dunnie was disappointed he couldnt fight for his spot. City (the club) and its welfare will always come ahead of any individual but I feel that this transfer was a bit strange.

What a crock of shite

IanBishopsHaircut wrote:

trout man wrote:Cant see this mentioned elsewhere so my apologies if covered but Irish radio did an interview with Dunnie this morning at the Irish training camp and they discussed his transfer to Villa....Dunnie said that City accepted an offer from Villa and then informed him that the offer had been accepted, Dunnie asked if he could stay and fight for his place but was told that the offer had been accepted and that they (City) needed the money! It was all said in good fun and got a great laugh from the journo's but there was an edge to Dunnies demenour that seemed to infer that he was let go without the opportunity to fight for his place ...basically he was kicked out. The club is entitled to do things as they see fit but I am still not sure this is a good decision and I really got the impression that Dunnie was disappointed he couldnt fight for his spot. City (the club) and its welfare will always come ahead of any individual but I feel that this transfer was a bit strange.

What a crock of shite

OP loses points for artistic expression. However, Dunnie tried to create the same impression on SSN just now. Sounded like a man who was shown the door against his will...

I think your right that Dunnie looks and sounds a bit depressed for someone who has just switched club i think he doesnt want to be at Villa, he wanted to finish his career at the club he loves.
But... He knows that his time was up and better players have arrived Dunnie isnt the main man anymore and knew he had to go i think thats why he probably sounded a bit dissapointed.

IanBishopsHaircut wrote:

trout man wrote:Cant see this mentioned elsewhere so my apologies if covered but Irish radio did an interview with Dunnie this morning at the Irish training camp and they discussed his transfer to Villa....Dunnie said that City accepted an offer from Villa and then informed him that the offer had been accepted, Dunnie asked if he could stay and fight for his place but was told that the offer had been accepted and that they (City) needed the money! It was all said in good fun and got a great laugh from the journo's but there was an edge to Dunnies demenour that seemed to infer that he was let go without the opportunity to fight for his place ...basically he was kicked out. The club is entitled to do things as they see fit but I am still not sure this is a good decision and I really got the impression that Dunnie was disappointed he couldnt fight for his spot. City (the club) and its welfare will always come ahead of any individual but I feel that this transfer was a bit strange.

What a crock of shite

I just heard the fucking interview on the radio, I am only quoting EXACTLY what Dunne said..as I said the reference to the money was tongue-in-cheek but he did make reference to wanting to stay and fight for his place so please explain what the 'crock of shite' is refering to?

not having a go at dunnie has he was a great servant to city but hughes keeps going on about now having a winning mentality
to be honest i don't think dunne had a winning mentality i think he was 1 of those players that as long as he played well that's all what matters in my opinion he was not a great captain . but i wish him well at his new club

trout man wrote:

IanBishopsHaircut wrote:

trout man wrote:Cant see this mentioned elsewhere so my apologies if covered but Irish radio did an interview with Dunnie this morning at the Irish training camp and they discussed his transfer to Villa....Dunnie said that City accepted an offer from Villa and then informed him that the offer had been accepted, Dunnie asked if he could stay and fight for his place but was told that the offer had been accepted and that they (City) needed the money! It was all said in good fun and got a great laugh from the journo's but there was an edge to Dunnies demenour that seemed to infer that he was let go without the opportunity to fight for his place ...basically he was kicked out. The club is entitled to do things as they see fit but I am still not sure this is a good decision and I really got the impression that Dunnie was disappointed he couldnt fight for his spot. City (the club) and its welfare will always come ahead of any individual but I feel that this transfer was a bit strange.

What a crock of shite

I just heard the fucking interview on the radio, I am only quoting EXACTLY what Dunne said..as I said the reference to the money was tongue-in-cheek but he did make reference to wanting to stay and fight for his place so please explain what the 'crock of shite' is refering to?

From the interview they showed on SSN, that was pretty much exactly what he said.

'What annoyed me was not being given the chance to stay and fight for my place, they said I had to go.'

I liked Dunne, however his time was up at City, we knew it Dunnie, will long be thanked for great service and never forgot,Hughes just did what was required for the club. Hughes is showing us the real side of football sentiment is dead.

From team captain to get shown to the door in a very short amount of time. Disgraceful really. Bit sad to see it develop the way it did. But looking for whats good for the team for the long term then Dunne would be out of place as he just wouldnt edge a starting spot, and having him on the bench would effectively kill ned's and mee's future careers and opportunities. Someone had to give and Dunne fitted the bill better than anyone else.

Good luck Dunnie

I thought all along that he wanted to leave as well , not that he was forced out. If he was forced out, that's not on in my opinion, he deserved better than that for 9 years of service.

giokingkladze wrote:
From the interview they showed on SSN, that was pretty much exactly what he said.

'What annoyed me was not being given the chance to stay and fight for my place, they said I had to go.'

I read that on their website and thought to myself. Hmmm so just because we got 2 other players your gonna start playing well now? I mean he was fucking terrible most of last season what would change now we have 2 new players?

Fair play to him, that's pretty funny.

It's sad to see him leave and also clear that he feels the same way. It must be especially difficult for him the way he stood tall and was a rock during the hard times to be shown the door and miss out on a project like this.

But I think he could have done a lot worse than going to Villa and it shows how highly regarded that he didn't have difficulty finding a club. But then, he never was short of an offer when times were leaner for us.

lets all have a disco wrote:He knows that his time was up and better players have arrived Dunnie isnt the main man anymore and knew he had to go i think thats why he probably sounded a bit dissapointed.

Yeah but he had to know that better players would come in all positions, once the takeover happened, including his own.

Is Dunnie pissed up or something? City needed £6 Million from Villa?

I Know going forward we need better and better players But actually saddend me to read that, I was hoping the club spin of we could of tried to keep him but he deserved better, we didn't want to stand in his way, a player of his standing on the bench ,blah blah was true.

ronk wrote:Fair play to him, that's pretty funny.

It's sad to see him leave and also clear that he feels the same way. It must be especially difficult for him the way he stood tall and was a rock during the hard times to be shown the door and miss out on a project like this.

But I think he could have done a lot worse than going to Villa and it shows how highly regarded that he didn't have difficulty finding a club. But then, he never was short of an offer when times were leaner for us.

Sounded like he was dead serious mate.

MaseCTID wrote:Is Dunnie pissed up or something? City needed £6 Million from Villa?

No Mase, he was just 'taking the piss' as opposed to 'pissed up'. He made a joke of the money, but still made it clear that he was very sad to be leaving and it felt like he wanted to stay and fight for his place.

He could have just said to City,''No fuck off i love this club despite you accepting an offer im staying''

Didnt though did he.

Puttin sentiments aside.
Im glad hes gone.We have moved on to better signings and in dunnes own interest he had to be sold instead of losin the captaincy and rotting in the reserves.He also has a world cup campaign to be involved with and needs to be playin 1st team with Villa.

His "love" of the club didn't prevent him having a swipe at us did it. ALL footballers are just the same as us, they are in their job to get whatever they can out of it. All this loyalty shit is just bollocks, if someone offers more money they will go in 99% of cases or if they are shown the door, 99% have a bitch about it. The simple fact is that he isn't good enough and I'm glad Hughes had the bottle & good sense to get rid ( there's a first- me praising Hughes!)