Page 1 of 1
Hypothetical Question about Ades ban
Posted:
Wed Sep 16, 2009 10:38 amby Vhero
Hypothetical Question here if Ade gets say a 4 game ban would you rather lose him for the rags match which is super important and only 4 match's in total OR get him for the rags by contesting the ban and losing him for possibly even more?
Re: Hypothetical Question about Ades ban
Posted:
Wed Sep 16, 2009 10:46 amby lets all have a disco
Miss the rags match and get him back ASAP for me.:-(:-(:-(:-(:-(:-(:-(
Im still holding hope our crack team of lawyers will have a top case.
Re: Hypothetical Question about Ades ban
Posted:
Wed Sep 16, 2009 10:49 amby Beefymcfc
Vhero wrote:Hypothetical Question here if Ade gets say a 4 game ban would you rather lose him for the rags match which is super important and only 4 match's in total OR get him for the rags by contesting the ban and losing him for possibly even more?
Non hypothetically - we don't have a choice.
Re: Hypothetical Question about Ades ban
Posted:
Wed Sep 16, 2009 11:41 amby Slim
Definitely get him in for the filth match. With Tevez, RSC and Robinho coming back over the next month he isn't as vital as he is for this match.
Re: Hypothetical Question about Ades ban
Posted:
Wed Sep 16, 2009 11:52 amby ronk
The FA have never interpreted acceptance of a punishment as anything other than a sign of weakness.
If there's even the slightest case for an appeal it's worth appealing unless you'd rather miss the next match.
It is without precedent to my knowledge for a ban to be increased for defending yourself. If a red card had been issued during the match we'd be appealing. There's a reasonable case for stating that this was an accident, I think it was.
Re: Hypothetical Question about Ades ban
Posted:
Wed Sep 16, 2009 11:54 amby Ted Hughes
The decision will be made before the rags match whether we contest it or not. That is a fact. It's being 'fast tracked' & will be done & dusted, whatever we do, probably by tomorrow.
As imo they've already decided the outcome before we appeal, he won't be playing at OT so there's probably no point appealing.
Re: Hypothetical Question about Ades ban
Posted:
Wed Sep 16, 2009 12:02 pmby razor400
B, what was the question?
Re: Hypothetical Question about Ades ban
Posted:
Wed Sep 16, 2009 12:32 pmby dazby
He will get off because the charges are baseless and should be chucked out.
Re: Hypothetical Question about Ades ban
Posted:
Thu Sep 17, 2009 1:24 pmby BlueinBosnia
Beefymcfc wrote:Vhero wrote:Hypothetical Question here if Ade gets say a 4 game ban would you rather lose him for the rags match which is super important and only 4 match's in total OR get him for the rags by contesting the ban and losing him for possibly even more?
Non hypothetically - we don't have a choice.
I didn't know he'd been found guilty yet.
Re: Hypothetical Question about Ades ban
Posted:
Thu Sep 17, 2009 2:43 pmby Slim
BlueinBosnia wrote:Beefymcfc wrote:Vhero wrote:Hypothetical Question here if Ade gets say a 4 game ban would you rather lose him for the rags match which is super important and only 4 match's in total OR get him for the rags by contesting the ban and losing him for possibly even more?
Non hypothetically - we don't have a choice.
I didn't know he'd been found guilty yet.
Now he has. 3 match ban.