by ronk » Wed Dec 23, 2009 12:02 am
I don't think Bruce should feel particularly hard done by. His teams appeal everything, dive, cheat and get away with lots of unpunished stuff. Other teams get red cards all the time, we've had a few more questionable ones recently.
Turner led with the elbow, maybe it wasn't deliberate but it was at least careless. Barry was jumping straight(ish) and he was the guy at an angle. If it had happened in reverse we would have been talking about how Barry was stupid for getting himself sent off.
Personally, I think he did know. Turner isn't someone I'd be inclined to give the benefit of the doubt. Proving intent is impossible, it's easy to elbow someone without looking at them. Especially if the intent is to put someone off with your elbow. It wasn't the only bad challenge of the game and sometimes refs give a little benefit it something happens once but really have no alternative if it happens again.
“Do onto others — then run!”
B. Hill