I'd try out the diamond formation:
-------------------------Given---------------------------
Richards------Ned--------------VK-----------------Gaz
----------------------Zabba------------------------------
SWP----------------------------------------------Rigsby
--------------------Stevie-------------------------------
-------------------Benjani-------------------------------
Keep a strong defence, play Zabs in his best position, give SWP and Stevie more gametime then replace after 60-70 mins if all goes well. Benjani should be good enough for one or two goals against Scunny and usually plays better with Stevie in the side.