The mancityfans.net football forum

Fabregas
Milner
Hart
R**ney

King Kev wrote:Fabregas
Milner
Hart
R**ney

;-)

Would be nice if Hart won it and Tevez got the senior award, highly unlikely but nice.

King Kev wrote:Would be nice if Hart won it and Tevez got the senior award, highly unlikely but nice.

Hart's been excellent, but I reckon Fabergas will get it, which I'm OK with.

King Kev wrote:Fabregas
Milner
Hart
R**ney

I dont think you should be in young player if you're in the senior pool. By that reckoning Rodney could (and maybe should) win both...

london blue 2 wrote:

King Kev wrote:Fabregas
Milner
Hart
R**ney

I dont think you should be in young player if you're in the senior pool. By that reckoning Rodney could (and maybe should) win both...

He's too old, mate.

mr_nool wrote:

london blue 2 wrote:

King Kev wrote:Fabregas
Milner
Hart
R**ney

I dont think you should be in young player if you're in the senior pool. By that reckoning Rodney could (and maybe should) win both...

He's too old, mate.

Nope, he is a genuine nominee for the Young Player award.

King Kev wrote:

mr_nool wrote:

london blue 2 wrote:

King Kev wrote:Fabregas
Milner
Hart
R**ney

I dont think you should be in young player if you're in the senior pool. By that reckoning Rodney could (and maybe should) win both...

He's too old, mate.

Nope, he is a genuine nominee for the Young Player award.

Just checked the PFA´s website and your right. I thought you had to be 23 or under at the start of the competition? Is it 24?

Edit: I´m an idiot. He´s born in October 1985, which means that he actually was 23 at the beginning of the season. I should join Gillie to one of his maths courses.

King Kev wrote:

mr_nool wrote:

london blue 2 wrote:

King Kev wrote:Fabregas
Milner
Hart
R**ney

I dont think you should be in young player if you're in the senior pool. By that reckoning Rodney could (and maybe should) win both...

He's too old, mate.

Nope, he is a genuine nominee for the Young Player award.

If you exempt the lads who are in the top pot from the youngsters' award, then Drogba wins the PFA jaffe, neither Fabregas nor Rooney get anything despite being mustard and young.
Milner and Hart have had good seasons, sure, but they've not contributed more to their sides than Rooney or Cesc.

I think a good solution would be an award for young players in their first 2 Premiership seasons - something like that.

How can a player be in the senior and junior?? Surely that shouldn't happen?

we could end up with 3-5 players in premier team of the year Carlos, Joe, craig, Vincent ( longshot, but he's better than wobblygob )and possibly Bridge out of sympaty from is fellow pro's

Vhero wrote:How can a player be in the senior and junior?? Surely that shouldn't happen?

he plays for united he can do what he wants!

Ryan Giggs is gonna win it.... because he deserves it.

Just like he "deserved" winning the PFA award last year, despite only starting 9 games (or something like that) in the entire season.