guv111 wrote:edge275 wrote:guv111 wrote:It's a silly and empty promise. No individual can make a definite claim that their team will win certain matches (not at this level, anyway), unless it's been agreed beforehand of course. To me it sounds like the ramblings of a desperate man.
What a load of shite.
Listen. The journalist said "do you THINK you will finish fourth?"
"Mancini said "Yes"
The journalist then followed up with "Is that a promise?"
Now what is he supposed to say here? Remember he still doesn't have 100% grasp of the English language so he can't go into a full detailed explanation - what's he supposed to do?
"No I don't" - Next day media is all over it, players are disappointed, khaldoon and co are going apeshit
"Maybe" - Next day back page of every newspaper "MANCINIO DOUBTS HE WILL FINISH FOURTH - SQUAD IN DISARRAY"
"Yes we will" - Boosts squad's confidence in the manager, lays down the gauntlet.
They are his choices to the question, what else can he do?
Apologies, but the only "shite" being spoken here is by you. THIS is a transcript of what was said, not your fanciful version:
Interviewer: "If you do not finish fourth, do you think it will be because of today?"
Mancini: "We [will] finish fourth. Sure."
Interviewer: "Do you promise?"
Mancini: "Yes... also if we lost today... but we finish fourth."
So, it turns out I was right in my original post, and you just leapt in there with a load of shite. I don't think I'll take lectures from you about accuracy in future. And THAT'S a promise.
To me it was more "We [can] finish fourth. Sure. [of course we can]."
What I object to is you saying it's the ramblings of a desperate man when he never promised to finish fourth. The question was asked to him.