The mancityfans.net football forum

who do u think is the worst keeper ever to play for us?

mine has to be Seaman. he was great for arse but when he came to us, he was WANK!!!

never liked Nash was well.

Barry Siddall

Carlo fucking Nash.

John Burridge

Keith McRae was no Dino Zoff either.

Perry Suckling

Simon bastard Tracey

Cunt.

Keith Macrae all day long.

simon tracey or eike immel was to good
i didnt rate that marton fulop character either!

simon tracey. fucking dreadful.

surprised carlo nash got a mention. i always thought he did a decent job for us.

9secondlegend wrote:simon tracey or eike immel was to good
i didnt rate that marton fulop character either!

I know we didn't deserve it I blame Fulop for the Spuds goal at Coms last season

David Seaman

The worst Keegan buy by a mile.

13021J wrote:

9secondlegend wrote:simon tracey or eike immel was to good
i didnt rate that marton fulop character either!

I know we didn't deserve it I blame Fulop for the Spuds goal at Coms last season

That really is ridiculous. He made 2 great saves before they scored. I blame Joey

David Seaman is a good call.
One of the worst, turned it round to become one of the best. 'Hapless' Joe Corrigan became 'International class' Joe Corrigan.

Dibble

Stuhr-Ellegard

Simon Tracey by a country mile

Stuhr-Ellegaard is a good shout, other worthy nominees are Burridge, Siddal, Tracey, Watterhus and Suckling. Tommy Wright was also not very agile and moved like robocop.

How about a special dishonourable mention for non-qualifier Geert De Vlieger - on the books for 2 years, out completely for one with a snapped achilles and ended up never playing a game. Even on a free we got done with that one.

Uuuuuhhh..... there's just too many to choose from. Tracey was shite, Seaman was bad for us, I don't think I ever saw Nash make decent save, Andy Dibble was laughable. But one who really stands out for me was Eike fucking Immel. He was really fucking shite + deserves the title because his purchase forced TC to leave to rags. We should've never let that happen. If we'd kept hold of Coton and earlier Colin Hendry, we would've never been relegated and would've even been challenging in upper mid-table I'd say.

Eike Immel for fucks sake...... how did this guy ever get caps for Germany, I don't know.

Nick wrote:Dibble

no way!!
ok he was...erm..inconsistent but no way was he our worst!

Frank Swift ...no Bert Trautmann... no Harry Dowd...no Alan Ogley ....no Ken Mulhearn...no Joe Corrigan ...no
er...all the ones on here ...no.. everybody who puts on a City goalie jersey is transformed - except Stuart Taylor