The mancityfans.net football forum

Is it just me that thinks he's shit? I just fail to see what his qualities are. He's slow, gives the ball away, can't pass beyond a short roll to a team mate and has bad positional sense.

Managers love him because he keeps possesion well and has great stamina.

in my opinion he shouldnt be starting because like you say slows the play down,id maybe start him away but not at home you need to let your creative players play and get you a goal. He trys looking for the passes that silva or someone like yaya would, but thats not his game.

He is getting left behind by the quality of players around him. Has never really done anything special for us and obviously loved being big fish in a small bond. Then again, Milner is starting to worry me just as much.

clueless

TheGOAT wrote:clueless

Favorite word today?

he was at fault for the first game for not tracking the other snidey shit the ballerina called nasri. Apart from that he put some important challenges in today imo. Agree re Milner tho.

I'm usually a staunch defender of all out players, but, in my humble opinion, Barry and Bridge are just along for the ride. I cannot remember a game when either have played well for us.

Barry is so off the pace it's untrue. And sorry BlueMoonAwoken, but he gives the ball away endlessly and has no stamina at all.

LookMumImOnMCF.net wrote:I'm usually a staunch defender of all out players, but, in my humble opinion, Barry and Bridge are just along for the ride. I cannot remember a game when either have played well for us.

Barry is so off the pace it's untrue. And sorry BlueMoonAwoken, but he gives the ball away endlessly and has no stamina at all.

lol yeah but if we are not looking for a goal, he is great at playing it backwards and sideways (best in the league at that) but its when he trys creating goals he gives it away endlessly.

Barry has stamina? Yea because he jogs around for 90 mins, very rarely runs.

I remember late runs in to the box last season and some fucking passion and energy. i remeber De-Jong type dominance and regular danger.

Not anymore, move along.

simon12 wrote:he was at fault for the first game for not tracking the other snidey shit the ballerina called nasri. Apart from that he put some important challenges in today imo. Agree re Milner tho.

Barry gave a free header to Djorou and was there fucking up with Bridge. But honestly, he has been off the pace for a while now. I reckon we need more positive player in his place in future. He will be good squad player but we need better starter imo.

Better against the more physical sides - not the Arse´s of this world though - Milner also worries me as mentioned

I thought Barry and Milner both did OK under the circumstances. Just goes to show that we all see a slightly different game. Wouldn't like to criticise any of the lads today - Arsenal have to be the most difficult team in the league to play against with 10.

Brad wrote:

TheGOAT wrote:clueless

Favorite word today?

yup

to call Barry "shit", you must have no clue about the game of football!

Position?

i think he must have a strain somewhere- cos he looked slow, forward passes were lost- looked like a pit pony next to the arsenal guys

Milner is a clogger- u see what ya get- what other top 4 nation would he get into?

Longball wrote:Milner is a clogger- u see what ya get- what other top 4 nation would he get into?

Can't begin to explain what is wrong with this statement.

He's been really good a few times this season. Chelsea especially.

Today was his worst game I can remember, fair dos he's in for a bit of stick as he was awful.

That said has Milne had a good game for us yet? I'm sire being played as one of the front 3 isn't his spot, but why put ade and aj on the bench when milner can't do the job up top?

I think right now, instead of picking a formation and making tough decisions on who starts and who rests, mancini has been shoehorning players he wants on the field for various reasons in positions where they don't necessarily serve the team best. I think part of it is having a lot of talent available and the other part is key members having been injured for so long that we have had to adapt. As our players come back from injury I'm hoping we settle into a more stable formation with a more stable starting 11 with more clearly defined roles. I believe that we will.

I think milner in particular is a result of this policy we have implemented up to this point. I think barry is a victim of it, and our midfield in general really. I think we will get over it though.

I don't see that he brings very much positive for us. He'd be the one dropped for a more attacking line up. I still firmly believe we need to do that.