The mancityfans.net football forum

Hart-4-terrible all round performance, give Given a chance, no reason y shay should be dismissed the way he has, terrible tonight.
Boyatta-4-like a hare in lights, stunned by how good Liverpool was, out of position, cb at rb, just a nightmare in the making.
Lesscott-5-struggled against Carrol.
Kompany-6-as ever our best player.
Kolorov-3-no comment, a shambles, get rid asap.
Johnson-5-not a good day at the office, not alone though.
Barry-5-was he even playing?
yaya-5-why is this guy starting games every game as if he is our best player?
Milner-4-got skinned everytime, shocking
Tevez-3-so half assed it's untrue, his commitment to the corse it getting very questionable indeed, you not happy tevez, fuck off, simple..
Dzetko-2-oh deary me, wtf have we bought here, is this guy actually a footballer or ice stater, pathetic from start to finish.

Subs.

de jong-5-what the hell was this sub about?
Ballatelli-5-the sub got subbed.
Silva-7-why on earth he never started i'll never no, this was a massive game.

Manager.

Mancini-3-the cracks are opening, not going to be ,many happy faces tomoz i doub't.

paulmclaren wrote:Hart-4-terrible all round performance, give Given a chance, no reason y shay should be dismissed the way he has, terrible tonight.

Except that Given's out for the season with a shoulder injury

freshie wrote:

paulmclaren wrote:Hart-4-terrible all round performance, give Given a chance, no reason y shay should be dismissed the way he has, terrible tonight.

Except that Given's out for the season with a shoulder injury

True, but he didn't deserve to be over looked the way he has, hart is an over rated keeper imo, needs to sort his kicking out for a start.

paulmclaren wrote:

freshie wrote:

paulmclaren wrote:Hart-4-terrible all round performance, give Given a chance, no reason y shay should be dismissed the way he has, terrible tonight.

Except that Given's out for the season with a shoulder injury

True, but he didn't deserve to be over looked the way he has, hart is an over rated keeper imo, needs to sort his kicking out for a start.

Another shocker from Hart for the first Liverpool goal.
How many howlers does he have to make to get dropped?

Hard to rate the players after that but I think going as low as 2 or 3 isn't right.Except for Balotelli as not only did he play crap but his effort and attitude stinks.
I would disagree that Kompany was our best out there as well. He had a rare bad night last night right from the off.A bad header gave Suarez that early chance and a bad clearance helped Carroll for the first goal.I would actually have rated Yaya as our best out there last night.Not great by any stretch but he was just about the only part positive I could see.( SIlva apart of course)

I agree about Vinny; poor clearences put us under pressure. Lescott was better imo but Lescott & Vinny were the only players who had any kind of problem to deal with. They were up against Caroll & Suarez who are currently much much better than Dzeko & Balotelli. Carroll is a nightmare to defend against in the air & Suarez is a real handful on the ground. Baring that in mind, with no help, Vinny & Lescott weren't so bad. Even if we'd won, the CB's would have had a tough game; that was obvious before kick off.

The rest of the team were up against nothing. Absolutely nothing. They were a disgrace to the shirts & don't deserve a mark.

Likewise Hart (pathetic) & Bob (even worse).

Ratings? Ha ha.

1 for the effin lot of them, apart from Balotelli who gets a half. The management team get a big fat zero. Even Kompany had a shocker which tells you how bad we were.

Balotelli is a joke.

0

Big and Fat