Page 1 of 1

QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 8:14 am
by Esky
QPR'S automatic promotion into the Premier League is set to be blocked by the FA.
SunSport understands the runaway Championship leaders are likely to face a big points deduction - possibly up to 15 - if they are found guilty of breaking strict third-party ownership rules over the signing of Alejandro Faurlin.

The evidence against the West London club is said to be damning and they could now end up in the play-offs.

The only winners would be Cardiff and Norwich who could then go up automatically.

The hearing into the signing of the Argentine midfielder two years ago begins next Tuesday and a verdict will be delivered three days later.

A four-man panel will comprise an independent QC, two from the FA's disciplinary panel and a football expert who will be either a former player or boss.

In theory, they should begin with a blank sheet of paper but many at the FA are openly discussing the case and reckon QPR - five points clear at the top of the table - are in big trouble. Those who have seen the evidence say Rangers are defending the indefensible.

An FA source said: "There's no question QPR have broken the rules. They know it as well. The only debate is what to do about it.

"If they aren't found guilty you might as well scrap the rules about third-party owners."

Some within the corridors of power believe QPR should be hit hard because they were well aware they were acting outside the regulations.

When West Ham were punished over the Carlos Tevez affair they were actually found guilty of failure to disclose information - not of breaking third-party ownership rules because such legislation did not exist.

Since then the FA have made third-party ownership illegal so the argument is QPR were worse offenders because they were well aware they were committing an offence.

If Neil Warnock's side are found guilty they will have seven days to appeal.

However, if QPR take legal action or other clubs decide to seek legal avenues because of points they lost when Faurlin played against them, the whole issue could drag on throughout the summer.

The nightmare scenario could even be that the Championship promotion play-offs do not take place at all until the issue is resolved.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Wasn't Warnock manager when Sheff Utd were relegated by West Ham and Tevez? Reversal of fortunes if true. Was hoping to see them back in the Prem, personally.

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 8:17 am
by Curlie
Oops!

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 8:18 am
by Dameerto
If they get a bigger deduction than a club going into administration it wouldn't make sense. 5-10 points sounds more reasonable. And they deserve it.

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 8:53 am
by jodrellblue
If this happens bet the irony won't be lost on Colin after West Ham & Tevez

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 8:58 am
by Arjan Van Schotte
i suspect they'll bottle it, and remove just enough points to stop them being champions but ensure they still go up.

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:30 am
by walmai
jodrellblue wrote:If this happens bet the irony won't be lost on Colin after West Ham & Tevez


Image
Calm down, dear!

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:31 am
by Blue Since 76
they'll deduct enough points to put them into second - it's the only way to avoid all the legal action that will follow. Wonder if warnock will be quite as vocal this time round?

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 12:21 pm
by ronk
West Ham also brought the information to light themselves after the takeover. If QPR manage to delay this they should apply the points deduction to next season. Send them up but knock 10-15 points off right at the start so they have to go down.

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 12:53 pm
by john68
Now here's an interesting scenario...if they dock 15pts from QPR (85pts), it would still leave then in 6th place, above Forest (69pts) and they would still qualify for the play offs.

Oops!
By the time this is fully investigated, heard, a decision made, an appeal lodged, the appeal heard and a final decision made etc. It is likely that the play offs will be already done and dusted. This leaves the authorities with a huge headache.
They can only deduct the points from next season, they have no other option open to them.

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 12:55 pm
by Mark (Blue Army)
Arjan Van Schotte wrote:i suspect they'll bottle it, and remove just enough points to stop them being champions but ensure they still go up.


Same here mate.

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 10:39 pm
by dazby
It should have been sorted the season it occurred.

Re: QPR - Possible 15 point deduction?

PostPosted: Sat Apr 30, 2011 12:07 am
by Piccsnumberoneblue
Shame, I like QPR, Loftus Rd, and Colin.