Page 1 of 2
Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Mon Aug 15, 2011 9:17 pmby paulmclaren
Hart-8- solid.
Richards-7-few uneasy moments but looks like he's getting better and better.
Kompany-8-awesome as usual.
Lesscott-9-brilliant overall.
Clitchy-8-Looks miles better then Kolorov at the back.
Johnson-7-Busy on the wing but i feel if we sign Nasri he will be limited, it's a shame really as the lad is so much better when he's constantly playing like he was right at the very start b4 his injury.
De Jong-7-cut everything up as usual.
Barry-8-poor starting off but as the game went on, looked very good.
Silva-10-absolute class, quiet possibly the best midfielder in the prem.
Yaya-8-poor starting off, didn't chase back, miles better second half, looks like me after 5 a side the way he gets knackered.
Dzetko-9-talk about a different player, class.
Subs...
Aguero-10-errr a bit classy this lad.
Overall-Swansea were very good first half, city were different class second half, and what a debut that was, but Dzetko deserves a bit mention here, he was brilliant as well as Silva as useual.
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Mon Aug 15, 2011 9:24 pmby 21Forsberg
paulmclaren wrote:Hart-8- solid.
Richards-7-few uneasy moments but looks like he's getting better and better.
Kompany-8-awesome as usual.
Lesscott-9-brilliant overall.
Clitchy-8-Looks miles better then Kolorov at the back.
Johnson-7-Busy on the wing but i feel if we sign Nasri he will be limited, it's a shame really as the lad is so much better when he's constantly playing like he was right at the very start b4 his injury.
De Jong-7-cut everything up as usual.
Barry-8-poor starting off but as the game went on, looked very good.
Silva-10-absolute class, quiet possibly the best midfielder in the prem.
Yaya-8-poor starting off, didn't chase back, miles better second half, looks like me after 5 a side the way he gets knackered.
Dzetko-9-talk about a different player, class.
Subs...
Aguero-10-errr a bit classy this lad.
Overall-Swansea were very good first half, city were different class second half, and what a debut that was, but Dzetko deserves a bit mention here, he was brilliant as well as Silva as useual.
Amen to that! Dzeko started first 10 minutes with his usual awful touch, but then he was pure class!
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Mon Aug 15, 2011 10:45 pmby Avalon
I must congratulate Michel Vorm too, Swansea's goalie. He was excellent and saved so many balls going in. Swansea would have gotten a whole lot more goals if he wasn't this excellent. Supposedly he's highly rated in the Netherlands and I can tell why, his first PL game and he only joined the club 5 days ago. Classy act and I hope he keeps that up.
Aside from that, Silva and Aguero... holy smokes! Dzeko was great as well, I think overall the whole team did great. Slow start, but once we picked up the pace, Swansea could do little.
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Tue Aug 16, 2011 3:39 amby Lee_R
Hart - 7 Steady, little to do
Richards - 7 Steady, strong and mobile
Kompany - 8 Solid, over last weeks misshap
Clitchy - 7 Good debut
Johnson - 6 Tried but needs to improve further
De Jong - 7 Reliable as ever
Barry - 6 Does the job but just about IMO
Silva - 9 Rusty to start but still amazing..
Yaya - 7 Scares defences even when not 100% fit
Dzeko - 8 Wheres he been?
Aguero - 11 He goes up to 11
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Tue Aug 16, 2011 6:26 amby john@staustell
You guys were watching a different Barry to me. I thought it was exactly his game and he was excellent. Johnson was dire as usual.
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Tue Aug 16, 2011 6:46 amby irblinx
Lee_R wrote:Hart - 7 Steady, little to do
Richards - 7 Steady, strong and mobile
Kompany - 8 Solid, over last weeks misshap
Clitchy - 7 Good debut
Johnson - 6 Tried but needs to improve further
De Jong - 7 Reliable as ever
Barry - 6 Does the job but just about IMO
Silva - 9 Rusty to start but still amazing..
Yaya - 7 Scares defences even when not 100% fit
Dzeko - 8 Wheres he been?
Aguero - 11 He goes up to 11
Is Lescott dead to you?
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Tue Aug 16, 2011 2:58 pmby Douglas Higginbottom
john@staustell wrote:You guys were watching a different Barry to me. I thought it was exactly his game and he was excellent. Johnson was dire as usual.
Don't think anyone was dire and certainly not AJ who played a decent role in the first 3 goals.As for Barry I thought he played well and got better as the game went on.He just has a knack of seeing trouble early and plugging gaps whilst at the same time being constantly available for a passfrom teammates under pressure.
He isn't fancy and rarely invloved in goals but he has real team quality.
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Tue Aug 16, 2011 3:46 pmby BobbyDazzler
Thought Barry had a great game. Johnno did his usual trick of being entirely anonymous for large parts of the game, but then popping up with a moment of great quality every now and then. If he could perform consistently then any doubts about him would disappear.
Thought Lescott did well defensively, but he still loses possession with misplaced passes an awful lot. Looked good going forward tho.
Yaya looked absolutely bollocksed after about ten minutes (even more so than usual) but improved as the game went on. The only person who performed below their usual standard was de jong. He still had an alright game, but didn't dominate the middle as much as he usually does. Micah was class. Aguero.... nothing you can say really.
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Tue Aug 16, 2011 4:41 pmby phips
Hart-7
Richards-8
Kompany-9
Lescott-8
Clichy-7
De Jong-7
Barry-8
Johnson-7
Silva-9
Yaya-7
Dzeko-8
Subs...
Aguero-9
Milner-4
Savic-3
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Tue Aug 16, 2011 7:10 pmby paulmclaren
Lee_R wrote:Hart - 7 Steady, little to do
Richards - 7 Steady, strong and mobile
Kompany - 8 Solid, over last weeks misshap
Clitchy - 7 Good debut
Johnson - 6 Tried but needs to improve further
De Jong - 7 Reliable as ever
Barry - 6 Does the job but just about IMO
Silva - 9 Rusty to start but still amazing..
Yaya - 7 Scares defences even when not 100% fit
Dzeko - 8 Wheres he been?
Aguero - 11 He goes up to 11
you missed lescott.
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Tue Aug 16, 2011 9:53 pmby anthonytomo
Bit harsh! Thought he looked fairly steady to be honest. Considering it was his prem debut ( i know, aguero)
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Wed Aug 17, 2011 7:08 amby Niall Quinns Discopants
anthonytomo wrote:Bit harsh! Thought he looked fairly steady to be honest. Considering it was his prem debut ( i know, aguero)
Really mate?
I mean, it was just a cameo and probably shouldn't even been rated but he was in deep trouble every time ball came towards him. One of their players glided past him with ease on one occasion and when he was on ball he looked far from convincing. Not going to hammer the lad but he didn't look too good in that short spell on the pitch.
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Wed Aug 17, 2011 9:43 amby MaineRoadMemories
I thought it was a good move to bring Savic on for some experience for 15-20 mins when the game was won. Unfortuntely I think the occassion got to him and he let Swansea in twice and looked far too nervous on the ball. For this year I'd continue bringing him on when the games are won but I don't expect to see him start any premier league games this season unless we struggle with injuries.
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Wed Aug 17, 2011 1:05 pmby paulmclaren
anthonytomo wrote:Bit harsh! Thought he looked fairly steady to be honest. Considering it was his prem debut ( i know, aguero)
I know yeah whats with the 3 rating ffs, is this man a glory hunter?
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Wed Aug 17, 2011 1:07 pmby twosips
Savic will be fine when he's settled in. Takes anyone a few games to adjust to this league. He's got a lot of potential though.
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Wed Aug 17, 2011 1:28 pmby paulmclaren
twosips wrote:Savic will be fine when he's settled in. Takes anyone a few games to adjust to this league. He's got a lot of potential though.
He looks like richard ashcroft from the verve?
Savic...
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Wed Aug 17, 2011 1:41 pmby twosips
I have no idea why that was addressed to me as a question, but yes, yes he does. Well done :)
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Wed Aug 17, 2011 5:23 pmby phips
Niall Quinns Discopants wrote:anthonytomo wrote:Bit harsh! Thought he looked fairly steady to be honest. Considering it was his prem debut ( i know, aguero)
Really mate?
I mean, it was just a cameo and probably shouldn't even been rated but he was in deep trouble every time ball came towards him. One of their players glided past him with ease on one occasion and when he was on ball he looked far from convincing. Not going to hammer the lad but he didn't look too good in that short spell on the pitch.
paulmclaren wrote:I know yeah whats with the 3 rating ffs, is this man a glory hunter?
I gave him and Milner low ratings because they were on for 10-15 minutes and therefore didnt have an opportunity to do much and didnt. the 3 doesnt mean, in my ratings and opinion, that savic was awful or anything; he just didnt have enough time on the pitch. plus, like NQDP, i thought he wasnt too impressive on a few occasions. it was good that he got a run out though.
im not a glory hunter. whenever i've seen short time subs rated theyre almost always below a five (unless they score or add an assist which these 2 didnt) because they dont have enough time on the pitch...
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Thu Aug 18, 2011 12:59 amby halnone
thought the entire team was brilliant. But when Aguero came on he looked a class above everyone, except Silva
Re: Ratings vrs Swansea
Posted:
Thu Aug 18, 2011 2:40 amby Slim
Hart(7) Only one real save to make and little else to do.
Richards(8) Fantastic start from Micah, great cross for the 2nd goal.
Kompany(7) Solid without being spectacular.
Lescott(8) Amazingly comfortable on the ball for a defender.
Clichy(7) Good debut, nothing really to do defensively.
Johnson(8) Inconsistent with his results, but direct running forces the defence every time, involved in 3 goals and better than the criticism he gets.
De Jong(7) is de Jong, nuff said, quiet game for him though.
Barry(8) So composed it's scary, does everything simple and unrewarded that gives the forwards licence to roam.
Yaya(8) Could have had a couple, hitting the ground running which is encouraging.
Silva(9) Freaking magician, still giddy about him.
Dzeko(8) So much better than we've seen from him so far, needs a bit more consistency but a decent run should bring him good.
Aguero(10) I laugh every time I see that second goal, such an OMG moment I think we'll be saying that a lot this season.
Milner(N/A)
Savic(N/A)