The mancityfans.net football forum

... but wasn't it offside? :)

No

Tony P wrote:... but wasn't it offside? :)

but you are wrong

no look at the full back out with zabba keeping everyone on side.

I agree if your on about their goal, but as Sergio was behind the ball, you cannot be talking about the winner

I mean when Milner plays it to Zaba.

Tony P wrote:I mean when Milner plays it to Zaba.

no they showed that on TV. when milner played the ball there was a few in the box offside but zabba was definitely onside.

everyone else got back onside and counts as a second phase so only counts from when Zabba passes the ball

Even their manager admitted it was ONSIDE!

on a serious note, is a penalty easier to score than the tap in Kun made?

just yknow...sayin.

cheers

DoomMerchant wrote:on a serious note, is a penalty easier to score than the tap in Kun made?

just yknow...sayin.

cheers

no, why?

Barry was the only player in an offside position but he wasn't interfering with play. Nothing dubious about the goal whatsoever

I've only just noticed Dave's flick that took it away from the defenders and into Sergio's path.

Class.

Beefymcfc wrote:I've only just noticed Dave's flick that took it away from the defenders and into Sergio's path.

Class.

At the time I thought he was trying to score a "showboat" goal. Silva stepped over with one leg and played with the inside of his trailing leg.
Having seen the replay on TV I think my original interpetation was correct. If Aguerro and Dzeko werent there it would have missed. I'm sure it wasnt a pass! :-))

Tony P wrote:I mean when Milner plays it to Zaba.

NO! inch perfect.

Duckman wrote:

Tony P wrote:I mean when Milner plays it to Zaba.

NO! inch perfect.

The defender in the middle near the penalty spot plays him on.