The mancityfans.net football forum

As requested in teh RVP thread. What's your opinion.

From me it's a firm hell, no!

Firm "Hell, no". With his injury record, age and wages he would command it would make it no no.

Confident he will do well (and have a better inuryrecord with our physios instead of the crocks at the emirates) but would rather see us spend 20m on a up-and-comer like muniain.

For 10m I'd take him in a heartbeat, for 20m I'd rather it be an investment with value when contract ends:-)

Thus voted neutral.

Oh, and if he will go to utd if we dont go for him then we have to get him, he will be a too good fit for them.

Hell no for me too, in worst case scenario a minimum yes, but if he stays away from the ball when we have a pk.

I think we can milk this. Offer a small amount of money for him. If we are really on to him, the ball this time (not like Nasri's saga) is in our yard, so we can pull the strings.

For me it is a 'mild yes' - my thinking is that if we went for him it can only be because Bob wants him - in which case he will have planned how he fits in etc and the financial side must have been approved - he is one excellent finisher and if his injury record back to the fore - well at least we will have some good back

so - being a pretty 'limp' yes - I went neutral

No thanks. Would bring more problems than he solves. Let's get the best out of Aguero, Balo, Tevez and Djeko. And Adebayor too if we can't move him on.

Neutral for me.

I'm a limp no. Won't be distraught if we sign him but on balance would rather we didn't.

Niall Quinns Discopants wrote:Firm "Hell, no". With his injury record, age and wages he would command it would make it no no.

Spot on.

If we sell then yes

I know a neutral vote is a bit of a wankers way out but I really can see arguments both ways on this. My fear is that we could get an Aguero dip in form/ injuries, sell Dzeko/Tevez and really need someone of this quality. Can we really rely on Balo throughout the season? What about challenging for all trophies, we need added quality for that as, again, we can't rely on Aguero and Tevez for all games.

On the negative RVP is injury prone, may not have a seaon like the last one and could upset the apple cart in terms of his girly hissy fits in the dressing room. Mancini is the only one who can really juggle the issues above and I trust his judgement. The thing that grates on me is his age and the fact that I think we could get someone younger and better value for money abroad.

Also, he has one of those faces which is crying out to have some sort of excretia smeared on it.

voted yes , i think bob wants him and he knows what hes doing.

keep this twunt the fuck away from our club!!

feedthegreek wrote:voted yes , i think bob wants him and he knows what hes doing.

Bob also signed Jerome Boateng as well.

I don't like him. Don't like his injury record, his cunt horsey face or his cunt i'm the best attitude. Might have just made this up like, but did he not get done for rape? Just don't think this move would work. I voted no, by the way.

Slim wrote:

feedthegreek wrote:voted yes , i think bob wants him and he knows what hes doing.

Bob also signed Jerome Boateng as well.

True, but he was an exception to Bob's normal signings, as in he didn't work out.
Made a profit on him though.

I can see why we would buy him, but I don't want us to.

bobadji wrote:I don't like him. Don't like his injury record, his cunt horsey face or his cunt i'm the best attitude. Might have just made this up like, but did he not get done for rape? Just don't think this move would work. I voted no, by the way.

He almost gone done for rape, but the charges were dropped when it came out that the "victim" had been bragging about doing a famous footballer shortly after it happened.

Slim wrote:

feedthegreek wrote:voted yes , i think bob wants him and he knows what hes doing.

Bob also signed Jerome Boateng as well.

i know but can you turn down a top striker of hes quality? possibly give you 30 goals a season, if he stays fit and if were after him a good signing, plus there,s less pressure on him here, were not a one man team. not a great lover of his personality, but if he bangs the goals in who cares.

http://www.ashburtongrove.co.uk/2012/07 ... e.co.uk%29

Have a look a the same moan that Arse fans have every summer.