Hart - in or out?

[PeterParker]

Really, what the hell is happening with this fella? Every single cross that comes at us i am shitting my pants. It is like Joe before going to B"gham. What is going on with him?

Should Bobby bench him in this last part of the season?

Look at Maureen, look what he did with Casillas. Is that an option?

[Burt]

Excellent choice of timing for creating a negative thread Spiderman!

Peter parker was always good for spinning a good web or yarn.......................

[Crossie]

It's a no from me.

A nice close season break. Hart is mentally good and tough enough to know where he needs to improve. He will.

There is no better goalie in the country.

[PeterParker]

Excellent choice of timing for creating a negative thread Spiderman!

Peter parker was always good for spinning a good web or yarn.......................

Nanana, nanan.

On a serious note, this isn't a negative thread, just a debatable thing about our Joey right here.

[ant london]

He's had a poor season and as long as he has the ability to see that and do something about it in the summer as well as now, I have no concerns with him being City and England's number 1.

[Alex Sapphire]

Joe's medicine will be being benched for Wembley
that is enough

[Original Dub]

Joe's medicine will be being benched for Wembley
that is enough

Exactly

[zuricity]

He's had a poor season and as long as he has the ability to see that and do something about it in the summer as well as now, I have no concerns with him being City and England's number 1.

Well i don't think he need worry about England. I can't see 'em qualifying for the World Cup.

[Hazy2]

15 clean sheets from 33 games.

[Goaters 103]

He's not had his best season but jesus, theres been far far worse than him this year.

Vincent Kompany's very sub-par season appears to have proved he's teflon like from criticism. Our front 3 have all blown too hot and cold, Nasri disappeared for 6 months, Silva has looked tired and needs a break, whilst Ya Ya has had some very poor games and is king of the petulant booking too - how many times has he kicked the ball away, or thrown it down in a tantrum to pick up a needless yellow?

[Sideshow Bob]

his dip in form has been worryingly long. when was the last time you thought to yourself, "wow joe's played a blinder"?

[Peter Doherty (AGAIG)]

his dip in form has been worryingly long. when was the last time you thought to yourself, "wow joe's played a blinder"?

Dortmund at home.

[Cocacolajojo1]

Really, what the hell is happening with this fella? Every single cross that comes at us i am shitting my pants. It is like Joe before going to B"gham. What is going on with him?

Should Bobby bench him in this last part of the season?

Look at Maureen, look what he did with Casillas. Is that an option?

I don't think it's a wise thing to change the keeper just because one of the supporters has problems controlling his bowels during crosses.

Also, the fact that you can't tell the difference in quality in his handling of crosses before he went to Birmingham and now also tells me that you are a perfectionist or likes to find a player that you regulate your bathroom habits after.

[Clowncrete]

He needs to:

1) Improve his distribution.
2) Improve his catching.

He is still one of the best out there and we are fortunate to have him here. Even "world class" keepers like Neuer and Buffon have dropped howlers in the last 3 weeks. Buffon was awful against Bayern and just a couple days back, Neuer's mistake led to a Hanover goal.

And I think that long balls from the back donot suit our style.

[Sideshow Bob]

his dip in form has been worryingly long. when was the last time you thought to yourself, "wow joe's played a blinder"?

Dortmund at home.

good shout. i'd forgotten that one.

[Mike J]

Best keeper in the prem, can still improve on a few things but i wouldnt swap him.

[Nigels Tackle]

only person i'd consider swapping him for would be a young gillie

[PeterParker]

Really, what the hell is happening with this fella? Every single cross that comes at us i am shitting my pants. It is like Joe before going to B"gham. What is going on with him?

Should Bobby bench him in this last part of the season?

Look at Maureen, look what he did with Casillas. Is that an option?

I don't think it's a wise thing to change the keeper just because one of the supporters has problems controlling his bowels during crosses.

Also, the fact that you can't tell the difference in quality in his handling of crosses before he went to Birmingham and now also tells me that you are a perfectionist or likes to find a player that you regulate your bathroom habits after.

Stop taking a piss and look around.

Hart is having some issues, and all this started from the QPR game from last season. I am not the type of person to critisize players just for the fun of it, but i am not blind to see that his isn't Joey anymore. His problems with Bobby, his friendship with the rags and so on.

I am considering Hart having the same problems he had before going to B"gham because his reactions are late and started to have the habit to conceid at the opponent first shot, like he did.

I am not saying he isn't class, i am saying he is complacent with his role, he did so many mistakes and he still played every game.

I dislike that old fuck from the other part of town, but he started to use Lindegaard instead of De Gay, and now that fucker had a good second part of the season, no more shitty performances.

Maybe this is what Joey needs, even though Lemmons is a ticking bomb.

[MilnersJaw]

His ego has gone to his head. We've had 15 clean sheets not because of joe but because he's had fuck all to do thanks to us dominating possession and breaking their attack. Look at the rag game at home, he had nothing to do all game and when he did, he was shite.

Against spurs, hai decision making against bales goal was terrible.

[Cocacolajojo1]

Hart is having some issues, and all this started from the QPR game from last season. I am not the type of person to critisize players just for the fun of it, but i am not blind to see that his isn't Joey anymore. His problems with Bobby, his friendship with the rags and so on.

I am considering Hart having the same problems he had before going to B"gham because his reactions are late and started to have the habit to conceid at the opponent first shot, like he did.

I am not saying he isn't class, i am saying he is complacent with his role, he did so many mistakes and he still played every game.

I dislike that old fuck from the other part of town, but he started to use Lindegaard instead of De Gay, and now that fucker had a good second part of the season, no more shitty performances.

Maybe this is what Joey needs, even though Lemmons is a ticking bomb.

FIrst of all, how is his friendship with players from United affecting him in a negative way? Second of all, problems with Bobby? Sorry but I've missed that. Do you have a link or something of the sort? Honest question, I must've missed something. But in all honesty, how the hell do you connect whatever problems he might have on-field with these factors?

De Gea made worse mistakes than Hart has done this season, which might have had something to do with him being replaced, rather than just mind games.

I don't think anyone would disagree that this season Hart has made more mistakes than the last one but it hasn't been shit and it deffo hasn't been anything close to De Gea's first season in the PL. Now he really had problems with crosses and corners, just like the Joe Hart of the old days.

I hope Mancini judges Hart on more than who his friends are.