The mancityfans.net football forum

I've had an irrational, almost CARL esque, dislike of Nasri ever since he joined and always felt we were weaker with him in the side (which was largely true last season).

After his performances this season so far but especially yesterday, it might be time to cut myself a slice.

So, with that in mind, which players over the years have made you eat humble pie for better or worse?

Kolarov yesterday :D

Zaba.....I was a firm believer that Richards was a much better RB than Zabaleta could ever be, but his performances over the past 12 months have proved me wrong....and I glad too

gmercer1 wrote:Kolarov yesterday :D

That goes for me as well.

Wonderwall wrote:

gmercer1 wrote:Kolarov yesterday :D

That goes for me as well.

I was just thinking last night, for all of Clichy's extra pace, and better defensive work, he would never in a million years have sent a cross as perfect as that for Aguero, and because he played so high up the pitch it pushed Valencia back all day.

Same with zabba - used to call him crapelleta, wildly wrong

Wonderwall wrote:

gmercer1 wrote:Kolarov yesterday :D

That goes for me as well.

And me to some extent (although I still don't think he can defend for shit) he was a proper asset pushing Utd back yesterday.

Nasri would have been out the door last Christmas for me, but he is a changed man & was better than Silva yesterday, & Nastasic has really got stuck in doing some proper defending recently, which I've been on his case about. Well done to all 3.

Ted Hughes wrote:

Wonderwall wrote:

gmercer1 wrote:Kolarov yesterday :D

That goes for me as well.

And me to some extent (although I still don't think he can defend for shit) he was a proper asset pushing Utd back yesterday.

Nasri would have been out the door last Christmas for me, but he is a changed man & was better than Silva yesterday, & Nastasic has really got stuck in doing some proper defending recently, which I've been on his case about. Well done to all 3.

Never imagined saying this, but could Nasri actually keep Silva out long term? He just seems so in tune with the players around him and probably offers more of a goal threat, but Silva at his best is like no-one else.

Colin the King wrote:

Ted Hughes wrote:

Wonderwall wrote:

gmercer1 wrote:Kolarov yesterday :D

That goes for me as well.

And me to some extent (although I still don't think he can defend for shit) he was a proper asset pushing Utd back yesterday.

Nasri would have been out the door last Christmas for me, but he is a changed man & was better than Silva yesterday, & Nastasic has really got stuck in doing some proper defending recently, which I've been on his case about. Well done to all 3.

Never imagined saying this, but could Nasri actually keep Silva out long term? He just seems so in tune with the players around him and probably offers more of a goal threat, but Silva at his best is like no-one else.

Silva is very special, as you say, but Nasri (the new version) works harder & the team looks better balanced. Imo, Nasri can play behind a striker as well though, so in theory both could still play in this system. We really do have a lot of options for all kinds of formations.

Wonderwall wrote:

gmercer1 wrote:Kolarov yesterday :D

That goes for me as well.

Bollocks, he's shite and not good enough to play against anyone...
;)
That humble pie must taste pretty good...

where's mase?

kinkylola wrote:where's mase?

Still wanking furiously over the cross for the first goal! :-D

Mines Nasri too.

Until last night his name in our house has simply been "the fanny"

In all honestly though he's been winning me over since preseason. I admire a footballer that can say he's had a shit year and it's up to him to fix it. Didn't moan and took responsibility. This for some reason is as rare as unicorns in today's game.

Colin the King wrote:keep Silva out long term? He just seems so in tune with the players around him and probably offers more of a goal threat, but Silva at his best is like no-one else.

It might be good for Silva to not be one of the first names on the team sheet. He has played a huge amount of football in the past few years for club and country. Similar to Mata at Chelsea there is every chance he may burn out. Players of that size and technical skills do not tend to last as long as players Toure or Gerrard.

Goater.

Goater.

Tony Book

Thinking back a few years, I remember genuinely thinking, and arguing (for no logical reason) that Trabelsi would be a brilliant right-back. Now that's embarrassing. Although he did score a screamer at the swamp.

I have never really been down on Nasri, but does anyone think that possibly, just possibly, Mancini got in his head so much he just couldn't or didn't want to play with him. He was smiling all game, even before the first goal. He is playing with heart that up until last month I never saw in him.

Florida Blue wrote:I have never really been down on Nasri, but does anyone think that possibly, just possibly, Mancini got in his head so much he just couldn't or didn't want to play with him. He was smiling all game, even before the first goal. He is playing with heart that up until last month I never saw in him.

His little flick to kolarov was class.
Seems to be enjoying his game much more under pelligrini, I am sure his form will continue now.