The mancityfans.net football forum

On the site and everything.

HUGELY talented this kid. He could turn into a world star at City. He's got absolute magic in his boots...

Lads certainly got a lot if potential by the sounds if things. Welcome to Man City, keep working hard and hopefully you will break through.

The 11 million quoted is 5 with 6m add ons. Plus hearing bits about a loan back to Fulham.

twosips wrote:On the site and everything.

HUGELY talented this kid. He could turn into a world star at City. He's got absolute magic in his boots...

Is he that much better than Barker though. You among a few others have likely seen much more of our EDS than most. Or will have direct competition up both their games and then we have the nice problem of a selection headache in a few years?

Also, will he go straight into the EDS or go out on loan? I imagine we will want him to learn the City way before he goes on loan, but it was mooted he could go back to Fulham as part of the deal

He plays on the other wing. Not competition for Barker.

However I'd say for all Barker's potential, Roberts' is a little higher. He'll stay with the EDS for a tiny bit I think

Am I right in thinking that he is a few years younger than Barker ?

mcfc1632 wrote:Am I right in thinking that he is a few years younger than Barker ?

Same age, Barker is a few months older.

First 3 signings, all English. Next 3?

This lad looks a real prospect and good to see the board getting the players in.

Beefymcfc wrote:First 3 signings, all English.......

You've forgotten the Turk & French lads ;-)

Excellent signing, bags and bags of potential here.

Cue the rag media making every story about "City's desperate move to remedy 'aging squad'".

It must be true, Gillie and Stu Brennan just started following him on Twitter ;-)

I will be seeing a Fulham season ticket this pm for a pint or two, I will see what he has to say about the lad.

twosips wrote:He plays on the other wing. Not competition for Barker.

However I'd say for all Barker's potential, Roberts' is a little higher. He'll stay with the EDS for a tiny bit I think

Almost hurts me to agree with you on this re the potential. Having already played some in Fulham's first team I can't see him playing only youth football so i would expect him to be loaned somewhere but yes maybe some bedding in time with the EDS so he gets to know us, the players and our ways and thinking.

Slim wrote:Excellent signing, bags and bags of potential here.

Cue the rag media making every story about "City's desperate move to remedy 'aging squad'".

Not quite the aging squad bit but SSN up to their usual tricks....



Patrick Roberts is a HUGE talent, the type who by the time he is 21 could be the name on everyones lips... make no mistake this is a coup by city, no matter how the media spins it!

Personally I don't think he is better than what we have in attacking positions, but I think we have exceptional talent in those positions & I do think he is comparable, & is certainly one of the best opponents City have faced. He is also different to what we have.

The other lad who impressed me is Jerome Sinclair at Liverpool who, when I was home, appeared to have turned down a contract & asked to leave. Now wouldn't that be funny ?

If Football Managers scouting and performance database is anything to go by, we may have just signed a player who will go onto to great things.

Delighted to have signed him and it may look a no brainer in a few years time but it does not look good on our academy when this is the second u18 we have bought for big money in the past month.

If Football Managers scouting and performance database is anything to go by, we may have just signed a player who will go onto to great things.

Delighted to have signed him and it may look a no brainer in a few years time but it does not look good on our academy when this is the second u18 we have bought for big money in the past month.

To an extent yes, you are probably right. At the same time, creating even fiercer competion will pressure those who have the ability to improve to improve even further and pick things up from their new competitors. I don't know but I wouldn't think that Vieiria is under pressure to play Unal or Roberts if he doesn't feel they're good enough, in the same way as Pellegrini is definitely under pressure to play Sterling, considering his wages and transfer fee. That way I don't think these new younger players will stand in the way of the development of any of our current EDS-players, as long as they're good enough.

Just heard good old TShite ( a media based show I think) and some goon saying that the Roberts signing is the one that disappoints me most. He suggested City have bought him as much as anything to stop anyone else getting him and to only use him in our EDS is a nonsense when he made his first team debut over a year ago.

He, whoever he was, even suggested city are having to buy talent from elsewhere because our academy has nothing of quality coming through. Shame it was a a phone in show as he might have had his head bitten off.

Douglas Higginbottom wrote:Just heard good old TShite ( a media based show I think) and some goon saying that the Roberts signing is the one that disappoints me most. He suggested City have bought him as much as anything to stop anyone else getting him and to only use him in our EDS is a nonsense when he made his first team debut over a year ago.

He, whoever he was, even suggested city are having to buy talent from elsewhere because our academy has nothing of quality coming through. Shame it was a a phone in show as he might have had his head bitten off.

Doug why do you still listen to that sorry excuse for a sports radio station?

gillie wrote:

Douglas Higginbottom wrote:Just heard good old TShite ( a media based show I think) and some goon saying that the Roberts signing is the one that disappoints me most. He suggested City have bought him as much as anything to stop anyone else getting him and to only use him in our EDS is a nonsense when he made his first team debut over a year ago.

He, whoever he was, even suggested city are having to buy talent from elsewhere because our academy has nothing of quality coming through. Shame it was a a phone in show as he might have had his head bitten off.

Doug why do you still listen to that sorry excuse for a sports radio station?

Went for a dump and thought I would see what was on 5 live but got Talk Shite instead. At least I was in the right place.

Douglas Higginbottom wrote:

gillie wrote:

Douglas Higginbottom wrote:Just heard good old TShite ( a media based show I think) and some goon saying that the Roberts signing is the one that disappoints me most. He suggested City have bought him as much as anything to stop anyone else getting him and to only use him in our EDS is a nonsense when he made his first team debut over a year ago.

He, whoever he was, even suggested city are having to buy talent from elsewhere because our academy has nothing of quality coming through. Shame it was a a phone in show as he might have had his head bitten off.

Doug why do you still listen to that sorry excuse for a sports radio station?

Went for a dump and thought I would see what was on 5 live but got Talk Shite instead. At least I was in the right place.

PMSL.

Welcome Patrick lad.