The mancityfans.net football forum

Another stone wall penalty on sterling AND a red card not given to milner.

As well as aguero being held back in the same move.

Oliver on course to out do mason and even taylor.

Impressive

If I was playing against City and especially if I was manager of one of the Sky 4 I'd tell my players if anyone shoots in the box just rugby tackle him. Kick him whilst he's down as well for good measure.

edge275 wrote:If I was playing against City and especially if I was manager of one of the Sky 4 I'd tell my players if anyone shoots in the box just rugby tackle him. Kick him whilst he's down as well for good measure.

i would take a different approach.

When i have the ball , i would make sure that i kicked it with maximum power in his gonads so that the twat had to be carried off and we get a referee . This guy is not a referee. I don't know what he thinks he is but he knows nothing about football.

zuricity wrote:

edge275 wrote:If I was playing against City and especially if I was manager of one of the Sky 4 I'd tell my players if anyone shoots in the box just rugby tackle him. Kick him whilst he's down as well for good measure.

i would take a different approach.

When i have the ball , i would make sure that i kicked it with maximum power in his gonads so that the twat had to be carried off and we get a referee . This guy is not a referee. I don't know what he thinks he is but he knows nothing about football.

I'd boot Sterling up and down the field all game long.

Probably get a medal for doing it.

Mase wrote:

zuricity wrote:

edge275 wrote:If I was playing against City and especially if I was manager of one of the Sky 4 I'd tell my players if anyone shoots in the box just rugby tackle him. Kick him whilst he's down as well for good measure.

i would take a different approach.

When i have the ball , i would make sure that i kicked it with maximum power in his gonads so that the twat had to be carried off and we get a referee . This guy is not a referee. I don't know what he thinks he is but he knows nothing about football.

I'd boot Sterling up and down the field all game long.

Probably get a medal for doing it.

Well Mase, Sterling is not the problem .

Oliver shocking today.

Inexplicably gave nothing, during the blatant foul on Sterling causing him to miss an open net.

zabbadabbado wrote:Oliver shocking today.

Inexplicably gave nothing, during the blatant foul on Sterling causing him to miss an open net.

I would have to say that he was not shocking at all mate as I think the majority of us know by now we are going to get done by dubious refereeing and this clown is near the top of the tree for such misdemeanours.

I'm confused. Everytime we see a challenge by the Sky 4 and they get the slightest touch on the ball prior to taking the player out in the box, we're told that the ref got it right as the player got to the ball first. CamelGob argued the point only last week when the Rags did the same. So, why today was it the opposite? Firstly the ref gave the pen, which doesn't happen when the likes of the Rags do it, then secondly the pundits don't stick to their previous statements and now say it's a cert' penalty.

Although a well fought game today there were too many instances of the ref favouring one team and let them get a breather when we were putting them under more and more pressure, breaking the game up to slow our play down.

I don't know what could have happened but our games are not played according to the rules of the game, they are played by the PLs thoughts on what suits their bank account.

Still stinks and this season has been the most blatant to get the Rags back into the top 4.

I don't think Oliver is bent, I think he's just incompetent, if he is bent his paymasters won't be best pleased that he passed up the opportunity to send Yaya off and that he didn't give Mane a penalty, which btw was the best decision he made all game, I can only assume he guessed.

I do think he suffers from the subconscious bias driven by the media that is ingrained in ref's psyche whereby the benefit of the doubt is never given to City, the British football media's pantomime villain.

how else do you explain that we out fouled them 14-7 with 60% possession on our own patch? It's ridiculous.

Blatant today.

It was shocking. Oliver and his lineos might as well have had a scouse shirt on. It wasn't even numbers at all today.

What a fun game. There were times in this game where I was getting ridiculously frustrated and annoyed at the standard of the referee and his assistant. You really do get to the point there is something going on and I have never believed there is a conspiracy. That's how I think Silva and his players viewed it when Clichy was penalised for his foul even though he clearly (to us) got the ball. Yes it was clumsy and he knocked the guy over but was it really a penalty? I was worried Silva just w asn't going to let it go and get a red card.

50/50 I think even Gary Neville said so that means it probably wasn't a penalty.It's a shame actually that Clichy's flick of the ball hit Firminho's arm as otherwise it would have gone out for a corner and the ref might have seen it differently. The 2 fouls in one move should both have warranted penalties, the ref seemed to be looking straight at it but nothing. The lino who was sticking his flag up all the time saw nothing.

But is it anything but incompetence. Liverpool thought they were hard done to! Most teams think they are being hard done to.

I can't recall a game at the Etihad where I thought the ref had a good game. But I wear blue glasses.

prob. no one on here agrees with me but i thought Oliver had a fine match. he wasn't great but i think he was closer to great than he was to terrible. yes, he obviously missed the pen on Aguero/Sterling (pick one) but he also missed one on Wijnaldum...so, for as as much as you can even say this, it evened itself out. he didnt make the error that he could've and give a penalty on Mane when Otamendi got tight (i know it wasnt a pen but it looked like it could've been one of those where you could see how a ref would give it).

phips wrote:prob. no one on here agrees with me but i thought Oliver had a fine match. he wasn't great but i think he was closer to great than he was to terrible. yes, he obviously missed the pen on Aguero/Sterling (pick one) but he also missed one on Wijnaldum...so, for as as much as you can even say this, it evened itself out. he didnt make the error that he could've and give a penalty on Mane when Otamendi got tight (i know it wasnt a pen but it looked like it could've been one of those where you could see how a ref would give it).

And he isn't banned for this shit?

phips wrote:i thought Oliver had a fine match. he wasn't great

And that was when the violence started, your Honour.

Peter Doherty (AGAIG) wrote:

phips wrote:prob. no one on here agrees with me but i thought Oliver had a fine match. he wasn't great but i think he was closer to great than he was to terrible. yes, he obviously missed the pen on Aguero/Sterling (pick one) but he also missed one on Wijnaldum...so, for as as much as you can even say this, it evened itself out. he didnt make the error that he could've and give a penalty on Mane when Otamendi got tight (i know it wasnt a pen but it looked like it could've been one of those where you could see how a ref would give it).

And he isn't banned for this shit?

banned for having a different opinion? k. just accept that i see things differently.
and why are you getting so bent out of shape about it anyways?

Douglas Higginbottom wrote:What a fun game. There were times in this game where I was getting ridiculously frustrated and annoyed at the standard of the referee and his assistant. You really do get to the point there is something going on and I have never believed there is a conspiracy. That's how I think Silva and his players viewed it when Clichy was penalised for his foul even though he clearly (to us) got the ball. Yes it was clumsy and he knocked the guy over but was it really a penalty? I was worried Silva just w asn't going to let it go and get a red card.

50/50 I think even Gary Neville said so that means it probably wasn't a penalty.It's a shame actually that Clichy's flick of the ball hit Firminho's arm as otherwise it would have gone out for a corner and the ref might have seen it differently. The 2 fouls in one move should both have warranted penalties, the ref seemed to be looking straight at it but nothing. The lino who was sticking his flag up all the time saw nothing.

But is it anything but incompetence. Liverpool thought they were hard done to! Most teams think they are being hard done to.

I can't recall a game at the Etihad where I thought the ref had a good game. But I wear blue glasses.

MOTD seemed to suggest our pen shout was far more valid than theirs, out of Murphy and Shearer's mouths.

phips wrote:prob. no one on here agrees with me but i thought Oliver had a fine match. he wasn't great but i think he was closer to great than he was to terrible. yes, he obviously missed the pen on Aguero/Sterling (pick one) but he also missed one on Wijnaldum...so, for as as much as you can even say this, it evened itself out. he didnt make the error that he could've and give a penalty on Mane when Otamendi got tight (i know it wasnt a pen but it looked like it could've been one of those where you could see how a ref would give it).

You really want to wind folks up, huh? lol

Had a fine match? You must be kidding.

PrezIke wrote:

phips wrote:prob. no one on here agrees with me but i thought Oliver had a fine match. he wasn't great but i think he was closer to great than he was to terrible. yes, he obviously missed the pen on Aguero/Sterling (pick one) but he also missed one on Wijnaldum...so, for as as much as you can even say this, it evened itself out. he didnt make the error that he could've and give a penalty on Mane when Otamendi got tight (i know it wasnt a pen but it looked like it could've been one of those where you could see how a ref would give it).

You really want to wind folks up, huh? lol

Had a fine match? You must be kidding.

I suppose it depends on your point of view really. If you are, say for argument's sake, a dortmund fan who loves the current liverpool manager and has very little affection for Manchester City, mister oliver must have been absolutely out of this world.