The mancityfans.net football forum

Hart 8 - dealt with was thrown
Sagny 4- no resposibilty for a man of his age
Otamendi 8 - up for it
Managala 7 - highest ive ever given him
Kolo 5- piss poor crsossing
KDB 7- looked knackered but showed up
Silva 7 - getting back to match fitness
Toure 6 - on the wane and he knows hes gone in the summer
Ferd 8 - put in a shift
Sterling 8- great first half
Kun 7 - trying to get match fit

Navas- 6 - Ineachu- not long on

Sagna worse than Kolarov

Rubbish

Longball wrote:Hart 8 - dealt with was thrown
Sagny 4- no resposibilty for a man of his age
Otamendi 8 - up for it
Managala 7 - highest ive ever given him
Kolo 5- piss poor crsossing
KDB 7- looked knackered but showed up
Silva 7 - getting back to match fitness
Toure 6 - on the wane and he knows hes gone in the summer
Ferd 8 - put in a shift
Sterling 8- great first half
Kun 7 - trying to get match fit

Navas- 6 - Ineachu- not long on

Very harsh on sagna.
If you think Aguero was a 7 then I have no idea wtf your sniffing. Aguero was beyond shit.

Hart 7
Sagny 7
Otamendi 8
Managala 8
Kola 3
KDB 7
Silva 6
Toure 7
Ferd 7
Sterling 1st half 8 2nd 4 (stop falling over)
Kun 5

Navas 6
Bony 5

sagna wasnt the worst.
nacho should have been on for aguero not sterling.
silly substitutions.

you didnt rate the boss, he got the 4.

No rating for Bony?

Aguero a seven? Not on your fucking nelly, not on tonights game unless it was out of 100.

Mangala was decent tonight. As was the Otter. For all the hoo ha about Vardy and Mahrez this season, they were kept fairly quiet

difference between sagna and kolo was one- i could give them both 5 at a push -7 for aquero because he was going at it even tho he was not match fit as opposed to being match fit and not putting it in

Like the thread idea though

i didnt rate Bony because there was no point

london blue 2 wrote:Hart 7
Sagny 7
Otamendi 8
Managala 8
Kola 3
KDB 7
Silva 6
Toure 7
Ferd 7
Sterling 1st half 8 2nd 4 (stop falling over)
Kun 5

Navas 6
Bony 5

This is pretty much how I saw it. Especially about Sterling. He does deserve more free kicks, but he needs to earn them by staying on his feet more often.

Toure 7, ffs he was no better then a 4, in this team we need to have pace and I'm afraid toure has less pace them me and I'm 58

mr_nool wrote:

london blue 2 wrote:Hart 7
Sagny 7
Otamendi 8
Managala 8
Kola 3
KDB 7
Silva 6
Toure 7
Ferd 7
Sterling 1st half 8 2nd 4 (stop falling over)
Kun 5

Navas 6
Bony 5

This is pretty much how I saw it. Especially about Sterling. He does deserve more free kicks, but he needs to earn them by staying on his feet more often.

No way Sagna should get a 7. Absolutely useless in their half of the field and we miss Zabba so badly I almost want to cry.

Kolarov might have fucked up 19/20 crosses today but at least he gave us an outlet to stretch their defence. Our left side, him with Sterling, was our best weapon today but unfortunately the final ball was poor throughout.

I'm failing to see what KDB did to get the 7's.

stevefromdonny wrote:Toure 7, ffs he was no better then a 4, in this team we need to have pace and I'm afraid toure has less pace them me and I'm 58

i think the 7 was for the 7 steps he took in the game.

Harsh on Sagna, better than kola for playing the overlap and getting crosses in tonight. Silva also a country mile better than Yaya despite being marked off the field.

Yaya will always get a 7 from me because he has hugely contributed to city at a time when our club was rising off its knees, im not forgetting all the bull his agent has stirred up- but i think he should be gone in the summer with our thanks and best wishes

Longball wrote:i didnt rate Bony because there was no point

Harsh but quite accurate.

Longball wrote:Yaya will always get a 7 from me because he has hugely contributed to city at a time when our club was rising off its knees, im not forgetting all the bull his agent has stirred up- but i think he should be gone in the summer with our thanks and best wishes

What the fuck has that got to do with his ratings v Leicester?

Fair enough in Yaya thread but this thread is pointless if you use that kind of arguments

Camebro wrote:Harsh on Sagna, better than kola for playing the overlap and getting crosses in tonight. Silva also a country mile better than Yaya despite being marked off the field.

I think Sagna has been very poor since the Liverpool match. Doesn't look like same player that started season. Maybe he has just been over used and its caught up on his legs at his age but been played in league cup games and the refusal to give Maffeo and minutes certainly hasn't helped him.

cos i just know hes gone in the summer and im not gonna just piss over his parade for the next 6 months, the guys been class mostly since hes been here- that is my point, a city player moving on should always be at least slapped on the back on the way out, its called class