The mancityfans.net football forum

Just read the above headline so thought I'd pop in and see what the spanners have to say.

Le Tissier went for Silva.

Charlie Nicholas, Crackhead and Phl the nose Thompson all went for Fabregas!!! he has hardly played this season if my memory serves me correct!

And they are getting paid for these comments

Well it depends how you determine playmaker.

No player in the league has created more chances than de bruyne.
No player in the league has more assists.
No player in the league has hit the woodwork more times.

Saying that, silva creates so much from deeper.

It's between those two but I think it has to be kdb overall.

It's certainly not fabregas ffs

Original Dub wrote:Well it depends how you determine playmaker.

True.

Since I'm partial to playmakers who influence the rhythm of the game, I'd always go for Silva. That said, KDB's final ball is ridiculously good.

fangsanalsatan wrote:

Original Dub wrote:Well it depends how you determine playmaker.

True.

Since I'm partial to playmakers who influence the rhythm of the game, I'd always go for Silva. That said, KDB's final ball is ridiculously good.

I don't remember his final ball against Monaco being that great

Otamendi.

No one creates more chances for the opposition.

Silva.

I am trying to figure if there was a better playmaker than him since EPL started. I think Silva is still very underrated comparing to how good he really is.

Fabregas' stats say it's him in terms of assists. No body has more since he's been in England.

That said I think I heard nobody has more than Silva since he's been in England.

Silva for me but coutino fab Ericsson and hazard all stand out for me.

Is this for this season? Or all time (prem lge)?

littlebig wrote:Is this for this season? Or all time (prem lge)?

At the present moment

Kolarov.

Mase wrote:Kolarov.

Because he makes you play with yourself?

Silva for me. He's an awesome player, truly capable with both feet and I can't think of anyone in the history of our club like him.

BookJunior wrote:Silva for me. He's an awesome player, truly capable with both feet and I can't think of anyone in the history of our club like him.

Just ask yourself. If you were a supporter of a club that is not City or chelsea/Arsenal.

Who would you have Fabregas or Silva..... it would be a landslide victory for Silva IMO

BookJunior wrote:Silva for me. He's an awesome player, truly capable with both feet and I can't think of anyone in the history of our club like him.

Not sure about the both feet bit but he awesome

Silva hands down. Yaya's pretty nifty as a deep-lying playmaker as well.

The only won in recent years who has come close to Silva, in my humble opinion, is Carzola, who has one great season for Arsenal. But even then he wasn't as good (+ he's been pretty poor since).

as a playmaker and not overall. KDB > silva >>>> fabregas

What I like to think of a playmaker is what effect his mere presence has on the game.

Sure, it's a toss-up stats-wise across the league, and I'd also go for Silva because of how immaculately he controls the flow of the game, but think of the psychological effect it has when Vinnie, Yaya, Fern or Aguero, at their best, are on the field - or even Willy and now Gabriel.
But in the clinical sense it's either Silva or Kev.

Fuckregas and Hazard don't count because they wear a crap shade of blue.

Silva all day. No one else comes close

Silva without a doubt - one of the most underrated players in the Prem while he's been here (alongside Aguero - kind of a pattern emerging here, wouldn't you say?)

Dameerto wrote:Silva without a doubt - one of the most underrated players in the Prem while he's been here (alongside Aguero - kind of a pattern emerging here, wouldn't you say?)

It's got to be Merlin the Incomparable Magician all day long - and every day after that as well.

If it was a boxing match, the referee wouldn't even let any other contenders get into the ring to stare at him, let alone fighting him.

Silva the Supremo; a towering colossus of skill and flair and he belongs to us


(and that's without me wearing my blue tinted spectacles)