The mancityfans.net football forum

I feel no disturbances in the Force.

The force will forever be disturbed when he does land.

Especially when he knows we lost by one goal and one of their goals shouldn't have stood.

At least we'll have some evening entertainment

Which one shouldnt have stood?

Saul Goodman wrote:Which one shouldnt have stood?

The one where stones was shoved in the back.
Did you not notice that??

Original Dub wrote:

Saul Goodman wrote:Which one shouldnt have stood?

The one where stones was shoved in the back.
Did you not notice that??

that was just piss weak shit defending
no complaints from me. would be gutted if we weren't given a goal like that.

Free kick every day in the Week. Except today.

Redna wrote:Free kick every day in the Week. Except today.

Of course it was. The whole point of getting your body between you and the attacker is to shield the ball. Obviously, shoulder to shoulder is the exception, but that was a shove in the back.

I watched it with a dipper and he said at the time, the only reason the ref didn't give it was because stones didn't hit the deck.

In the grander scheme if things, our loss was more about the 10 minute brain fart. Very unlike us so hopefully that's it all excorcised in one game.

But of course, all the goals should have stood, except that one.

That's just a simple fact.

Redna wrote:Free kick every day in the Week. Except today.

I agree with this and Dub on this one I said it as it happened definitely a shove in the back , nowhere near shoulder to shoulder for me .

carolina-blue wrote:

Redna wrote:Free kick every day in the Week. Except today.

I agree with this and Dub on this one I said it as it happened definitely a shove in the back , nowhere near shoulder to shoulder for me .

As ever, the good news for folk like looknigel, is that there's video evidence.

Maybe someone could post a clip of the incident?

Original Dub wrote:

carolina-blue wrote:

Redna wrote:Free kick every day in the Week. Except today.

I agree with this and Dub on this one I said it as it happened definitely a shove in the back , nowhere near shoulder to shoulder for me .

As ever, the good news for folk like looknigel, is that there's video evidence.

Maybe someone could post a clip of the incident?

it was piss weak shit defending

Anyone got a clip for Looknige?

He's struggling to see things in front of him.
Again.

Sorry, I'm shit at posting videos.

Here's a link, just scroll down to firmino 2-1 and you can see the shoulder shove in stones back

https://www.google.ie/search?q=firminho ... e&ie=UTF-8

Original Dub wrote:Sorry, I'm shit at posting videos.

Here's a link, just scroll down to firmino 2-1 and you can see the shoulder shove in stones back

https://www.google.ie/search?q=firminho ... e&ie=UTF-8

I thought it was a shove initially but if you watch that clip frame by frame it is actually shoulder to shoulder when the initial contact is made....

Go to 0:50s. Looks shoulder to shoulder to me.

I must be losing the plot, I can't see shoulder to shoulder after watching it about ten times now.

And I can't understand how stones would fall in that direction after a shoulder to shoulder.

look how stones reacted more
to the point didn't react. he would have gone mental if he thought he had been fouled
he fucked up. simple as.

Not that it makes a shit of difference now But TBH I still see a shoulder in the back , I swear I’ve took off my Blue Tinted Specs .

Original Dub wrote:I must be losing the plot, I can't see shoulder to shoulder after watching it about ten times now.

And I can't understand how stones would fall in that direction after a shoulder to shoulder.

Any other game that’s given as foul. Simples

It was to the back of his shoulder. Not sure if that complies with the rules for shoulder to shoulder, but I'd be pissed off if it was given against us.
Just shit defending from Stones imho

Original Dub wrote:I must be losing the plot, I can't see shoulder to shoulder after watching it about ten times now.

And I can't understand how stones would fall in that direction after a shoulder to shoulder.

I don't think you've lost the plot OD; out and out foul all day long.

Case closed, no argument.