The mancityfans.net football forum

Is he the answer in goal?

I’ve got to say, I don’t think his positioning is great and his shots to saves ratio is poor. The distribution we have come to love has all but dried up and he is prone to more errors than a title winner should allow.

He now has a relatively settled back four in front of him so I’m hoping they gel and quickly. But he isn’t the shoo in he was two years ago and for my money needs to improve his game

The thing is every cunt is playing wank week in week out

He has been excellent but now seems a little too cocky, making the wrong decisions regularly. Reminds me of Bravo at the moment.

I think he is off for around a year now.
His penalty saving rate is terrible.
+
when every 1 of 2 chances a team has against us is a goal you start to wonder.

He is no different than any of the rest of them.

We give up 1v1 two text book finishes. We cannot create clear cut chances.

Ederson is the best GK in the world with the ball at his feet and his range of passing is fantastic. His other GK attributes of positioning, shot stopping and reflexes are very average though. This is where Alisson is better as the overall keeper, decent with feet and very good all round ability in goal.

I don't think anyone doubts his class but one thing PeP rarely does is drop players who are under-performing......actually he rewards them with more appearances until they make so many fuckign mistakes that it should be a sack able offense to keep playing them (Stones as an example) .

Ederson is just one example - he should have been ''rested'' and all the excuses in the world used to ensure he felt comfortable ''recharging'' his batteries and working on the weak areas in training before coming back in the team, stronger than before.

Hes been no shittier than any of the rest of them, they all look like they are in end of season friendly game mode.

Kept a clean sheet today !!