Manchester 11 - Pick your team

[Nijinsky]

Reading this: http://www.redcafe.net/f7/how-many-man-city-players-would-make-into-man-utd-1st-team-336264/ I'm interested in seeing a City perspective

My hypothetical line-up would be:

_______________Hart

Richards__Kompany__Vidic__Evra

_______________NDJ

_______Toure_________Nasri (I'm hopeful)/Barry

______________Silva

________Rooney_____Augero

Bench: De Gea, Zabaleta, Ferdinand, Balotelli, [b]Hernadez[b], Barry

Discounting Tevez, of course (who'd replace Rooney for me, should he stay).

In my opinion, whatever the formation, there'd be more City players.. we're just missing that know-how, mentality and spirit.

The formation is definitely up for debate.. and I feel as though I'm missing someone hugely important (that's the beauty of our squad, so many stars). Anyway, your line-ups?

[Dingus McDouchey]

IMO Nani would be in ahead of Nasri/Barry

[1950]

Hart
Richards Kompany Vidić Evra
de Jong Yaya
Nani Silva Agüero
Tévez

[Kladze]

Hart
Richards Kompany Vidić Evra
de Jong
Nani Yaya Silva

Agüero Rooney

[Nijinsky]

Hard to disagree with Nani in there.

So far though, still a balance largely in our favour, yet on ragcafe it's not so.. Suppose that's expectable, but I'd like to see a neutrals opinion.

[lets all have a disco]

Hart
Richards
vidic
kompany
evra
Valencia
de jong
yaya
Silva
Rooney
tevez

[Slim]

Hart
Richards, Kompany, Lescott, Clichy
Yaya,de Jong, Barry
Aguero, Balotelli, Silva

NO FUCKING RAGS EVER.

[Douglas Higginbottom]

Hard to disagree with Nani in there.

So far though, still a balance largely in our favour, yet on ragcafe it's not so.. Suppose that's expectable, but I'd like to see a neutrals opinion.

and yet Nani was struggling to get into the scum side in the latter part of last season

[King Kev]

Hart
Richards
Kompany
Lescott
Clichy
De Jong
Barry
Yaya
Silva
Ageuro
Tevez

[smurfsdabomb]

As a neutral:

De Gea

Rafael Vidic Kompany Evra

Nani De Jong Yaya Silva

Aguero Hernandez


Hart and Rooney are two of the most overrated players in the league. So was Rio Ferdinand but I think people have been warming to the idea that hes utter shite in recent years. I'm not really happy with Nani or Rafael in that team but I think they're narrowly the best of a bad bunch in those positions.

[Crossie]

Why the fuck would anyone think that twat Rafael or his brother are better than Richards? FUCK OFF get real.

Scum fans would all donate a finger to have Richards in their team, as well as the following players WHO WOULD ALL WALK INTO ANY TEAM IN THE LEAGUE:

De Jong
Yaya
Silva
Aguero
Tevez
Kompany
Hart
/ the real Balotelli

[Buffalo Soldier]

That thread is fucking hilarious. The number of people who have put Carrick in the team is astonishing.

[Crossie]

Plus it shows how much they are shitting themselves, 2 years ago they wouldnt have taken any of our players.

[1950]

That thread is fucking hilarious. The number of people who have put Carrick in the team is astonishing.

I rate Carrick, but not over Yaya (in central midfield) or Silva (as a ball distributor).

They only really have more quality on the wing & at LB (until Clichy finds his form from 3 years ago).

Any of Nani, Valencia & Young would walk into our first 18.

[The Foggy Blue]

I'm at best EXTREMELY uncomfortable reading this.

[guv111]

One of the most mature threads I've ever seen on Red Cafe.

By the way, is Red Issue dead now, or just some secret place where Pete Boyle and other Man U nutjobs hang out?

[OhDannyBoy]

As a neutral:

De Gea

Rafael Vidic Kompany Evra

Nani De Jong Yaya Silva

Aguero Hernandez


Hart and Rooney are two of the most overrated players in the league. So was Rio Ferdinand but I think people have been warming to the idea that hes utter shite in recent years. I'm not really happy with Nani or Rafael in that team but I think they're narrowly the best of a bad bunch in those positions.

Who is this guy?

[Goataldo]

Odd that you say the rags are including Carrick. I don't know one ManUre fan who rates him.

[1950]

I'm at best EXTREMELY uncomfortable reading this.

Sorry. rags cunts munichs twats rubbish shrek fuck hate piss scum bollocks. Better?

[Typical City]

…………………De Gea
Richards - Vidic - Kompany - Clichy
…………………Nigel
Johnson - Aguero - Silva
…Bell The Telly - Rooney