Blue Since 76 wrote:johnny crossan wrote:In another thread some distinguished posters lamented the general lack of quality central midfielders but some also had high hopes of Rodwell. The mood was to dispense with chuggers like Gazbaz & Garcia and replace them with athletic types in the mould of Bell.
I ask myself what might Jack have that separates him from the likes of Sidwell, Jenas, Cattermole, Henderson, Shelvey, etc
I have failed to come up with an answer, perhaps I'm asking myself the wrong question.
There's a fine line between any of those and a K#%ne, Vieira, de Rossi etc. A Skoda and a Bentley both do the same job, but I know which I'd prefer. No idea which one Rodwell will turn out to be, but it's harsh to be critical for someone for being athletic.
Rodwell is a bit better at everything than Sidwell, & Henderson & a lot better at everything than the others. Even if he never plays another game for City, he's better than them.
Henderson is a bit of a strange one tbf as he looked like he was about to become a footballer, then moved to Liverpool & turned into Cattermole.