Beefymcfc wrote:What you're saying is that we should be walking the league in our infancy?
I think what both are saying, is that we made remarkably hard work of that season whichever way you look at it.
A title is a title is a title, whether it's won with the last kick, 4 months to spare - nobody is denigrating the achievement of winning the title, but I think the whole issue is that there is a recognition that we should really never have had to win that QPR game, and that a fair bit of the 6 months that preceeded it was very concerning time as we saw the manager come up against problems he didnt seem to have the answer for.
There are the stories like that of lescott who publicly stated that he and vinny ignored the managers instructions to stay back to go forward in the last minute of the qpr game - little snippets like that set a context of a manager prone to doing some really fucking odd things whilst in charge. Then Lescott is bombed out of the squad for a 19 year old, coincidence?
If lescott is to be believed, there is some credence in saying that had the players listened to mancini, we wouldnt have won the league.
BUT, over 38 games we were in the end the best team so Mancini will rightly always be celebrated as the bloke who presided over it, and as time fades the only recollection people will have will be of the most thrilling finish to a league title in history.
The issue here seems to be that some people have clearly already committed ONLY that fact to their memory - with no objective concerns about the little things that led to the title.