VAR
-
ayrshireblue
- Kinky's Mazy Dribbles
- Posts: 2355
- Joined: Mon Aug 25, 2008 7:08 pm
Re: VAR
Conceding the goal was definitely the City defence's fault. But VAR is in place to look at reasons why the goal shouldn't stand and it SHOULD NOT stand according to Law 16 which clearly states -
"Law 16 - The goal kick
The ball is in play once the kick is taken; it can be played before leaving the penalty area
Opponents must remain outside the penalty area until the ball is kicked"
VAR should have looked at the goal and decided that there was an offence caused by Pukki not being out the area when the ball became active. They didn't do this and I'm asking why?
"Law 16 - The goal kick
The ball is in play once the kick is taken; it can be played before leaving the penalty area
Opponents must remain outside the penalty area until the ball is kicked"
VAR should have looked at the goal and decided that there was an offence caused by Pukki not being out the area when the ball became active. They didn't do this and I'm asking why?
-
zuricity
- Joe Mercer's OBE
- Posts: 19623
- Joined: Sat Dec 17, 2005 10:54 pm
- Location: Zuerich,ch
Re: VAR
ayrshireblue wrote:Conceding the goal was definitely the City defence's fault. But VAR is in place to look at reasons why the goal shouldn't stand and it SHOULD NOT stand according to Law 16 which clearly states -
"Law 16 - The goal kick
The ball is in play once the kick is taken; it can be played before leaving the penalty area
Opponents must remain outside the penalty area until the ball is kicked"
VAR should have looked at the goal and decided that there was an offence caused by Pukki not being out the area when the ball became active. They didn't do this and I'm asking why?
Because the law is an Ass.
"Well I'll go to the foot of our stairs."
- Hutch's Shoulder
- Dickov's Injury Time Equaliser
- Posts: 4424
- Joined: Mon Sep 23, 2013 10:55 am
- Supporter of: City of course
- My favourite player is: David Silva
- Location: Wild country near Glossop
Re: VAR
ayrshireblue wrote:Conceding the goal was definitely the City defence's fault. But VAR is in place to look at reasons why the goal shouldn't stand and it SHOULD NOT stand according to Law 16 which clearly states -
"Law 16 - The goal kick
The ball is in play once the kick is taken; it can be played before leaving the penalty area
Opponents must remain outside the penalty area until the ball is kicked"
VAR should have looked at the goal and decided that there was an offence caused by Pukki not being out the area when the ball became active. They didn't do this and I'm asking why?
VAR doesn't, and was never meant to, look at all types of violations before a goal, just certain things. Which things depends on which set of VAR standards. Its a bit half-arsed right now.
-
Nigels Tackle
- Donated to the site

- Posts: 19015
- Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2007 7:57 pm
- Supporter of: man love
- My favourite player is: riyad meh!rez
- Location: here, there, every fucking where
Re: VAR
zuricity wrote:Nigels Tackle wrote:zuricity wrote:ayrshireblue wrote:Pukki had plenty of time to vacate the penalty area and it is his duty to do so not for the keeper to make sure he has. My point was that VAR should have disallowed the goal as he was in an illegal position when the ball became active. It's not clutching at straws, it's asking for the laws to be applied fairly across all 20 teams. Not too hard to understand.
Doesn't really matter about Pukki being in the area . Pukki can do sod all about Ed wanting to play the ball quickly .
He was walking out of the area and by the time otto screwed up , because of the Stones cough up , he was way out of the box .
Take a look at that photo again . Zinc simply going forward , Rodri running by the otter and the Norwich player closing in on the otter , ready to pounce. The longer distance that Stones passed , right in front of the sticks too, was completely stupid . What we used to call a hospital pass . Bloody dangerous .
if you watch the whole build up to the 3rd goal, pukki keeps walking away from stones. only when otamongi gets tackled does he start moving towards the goal.
that goal was 150% our own fault.
I am certainly not disputing the fact that it was a city cock up. Stones needs a good bollocking for what he did . should have given it back to Ed . to wellie upto Sergio.
i know you get it... just trying to explain to ayrshire why it wasn’t a clear and obvious error for var to review.
-
carl_feedthegoat
- Donated to the site

- Posts: 33598
- Joined: Sun Dec 25, 2005 2:51 am
- Supporter of: Man City
Re: VAR
Dormund penalty and the keeper was well off his line before the ball was even struck.
So what is the rule ? does it depend on whose playing who before VAR intervenes?
Id like to know
thanks
So what is the rule ? does it depend on whose playing who before VAR intervenes?
Id like to know
thanks
THEY SAY SWEARING IS DUE TO A LIMITED VOCABULARY. I KNOW THOUSANDS OF WORDS, BUT I STILL PREFER "FUCK OFF" TO "GO AWAY"
-
Foreverinbluedreams
- Denis Law's Backheel
- Posts: 9224
- Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2011 8:34 pm
- Supporter of: Euthanasia
Re: VAR
carl_feedthegoat wrote:Dormund penalty and the keeper was well off his line before the ball was even struck.
So what is the rule ? does it depend on whose playing who before VAR intervenes?
Id like to know
thanks
Apparently VAR won't intervene unless it's a "blatant and clear violation", following the farce that saw penalties scrutinised to the nth degree in the Women's World Cup they decided to relax it, giving authority on it back to the ref on the pitch.
-
Mase
- Anna Connell's Vision
- Posts: 46755
- Joined: Wed Aug 27, 2008 10:08 pm
- Supporter of: Warnock's Ref Rants
- My favourite player is: Danny Tiatto
- Location: The North Pole.
Re: VAR
Foreverinbluedreams wrote:carl_feedthegoat wrote:Dormund penalty and the keeper was well off his line before the ball was even struck.
So what is the rule ? does it depend on whose playing who before VAR intervenes?
Id like to know
thanks
Apparently VAR won't intervene unless it's a "blatant and clear violation", following the farce that saw penalties scrutinised to the nth degree in the Women's World Cup they decided to relax it, giving authority on it back to the ref on the pitch.
They're basically saying, the ref can still cheat and we'll say it wasn't blatant.
-
Foreverinbluedreams
- Denis Law's Backheel
- Posts: 9224
- Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2011 8:34 pm
- Supporter of: Euthanasia
Re: VAR
Mase wrote:Foreverinbluedreams wrote:carl_feedthegoat wrote:Dormund penalty and the keeper was well off his line before the ball was even struck.
So what is the rule ? does it depend on whose playing who before VAR intervenes?
Id like to know
thanks
Apparently VAR won't intervene unless it's a "blatant and clear violation", following the farce that saw penalties scrutinised to the nth degree in the Women's World Cup they decided to relax it, giving authority on it back to the ref on the pitch.
They're basically saying, the ref can still cheat and we'll say it wasn't blatant.
Yep but to be fair I'd rather common sense was applied on this rather than that type of scrutiny. I don't see the issue with keepers being a foot or so off their line and if they want to stop encroaching in the box then put a line 21 yards out that they've to stay behind while pens are taken.
-
harveytravis
- Richard Edghill Whipping Boy
- Posts: 496
- Joined: Thu Sep 19, 2013 3:47 pm
- Supporter of: Man City
Re: VAR
Foreverinbluedreams wrote:Mase wrote:Foreverinbluedreams wrote:carl_feedthegoat wrote:Dormund penalty and the keeper was well off his line before the ball was even struck.
So what is the rule ? does it depend on whose playing who before VAR intervenes?
Id like to know
thanks
Apparently VAR won't intervene unless it's a "blatant and clear violation", following the farce that saw penalties scrutinised to the nth degree in the Women's World Cup they decided to relax it, giving authority on it back to the ref on the pitch.
They're basically saying, the ref can still cheat and we'll say it wasn't blatant.
Yep but to be fair I'd rather common sense was applied on this rather than that type of scrutiny. I don't see the issue with keepers being a foot or so off their line and if they want to stop encroaching in the box then put a line 21 yards out that they've to stay behind while pens are taken.
The point about the Ter steven penalty save is that the referee specifically went up to the goal keeper to tell him to keep his feet on the line just before he moved two feet forwards before Neuer struck the ball. Why bother???
-
zuricity
- Joe Mercer's OBE
- Posts: 19623
- Joined: Sat Dec 17, 2005 10:54 pm
- Location: Zuerich,ch
Re: VAR
harveytravis wrote:Foreverinbluedreams wrote:Mase wrote:Foreverinbluedreams wrote:carl_feedthegoat wrote:Dormund penalty and the keeper was well off his line before the ball was even struck.
So what is the rule ? does it depend on whose playing who before VAR intervenes?
Id like to know
thanks
Apparently VAR won't intervene unless it's a "blatant and clear violation", following the farce that saw penalties scrutinised to the nth degree in the Women's World Cup they decided to relax it, giving authority on it back to the ref on the pitch.
They're basically saying, the ref can still cheat and we'll say it wasn't blatant.
Yep but to be fair I'd rather common sense was applied on this rather than that type of scrutiny. I don't see the issue with keepers being a foot or so off their line and if they want to stop encroaching in the box then put a line 21 yards out that they've to stay behind while pens are taken.
The point about the Ter steven penalty save is that the referee specifically went up to the goal keeper to tell him to keep his feet on the line just before he moved two feet forwards before Neuer struck the ball. Why bother???
Which of course contradicts what has been written justr above about penalties after the joke world cup in the summer. Further, respect to the idea of putting a line at 21 yards.... that's why there is a penalty area and a little D on the box . To stop encroachment , pretty much since day one.
Nail 'em up I say ( the Refs and VAR refs ) and sue them in court for loss of revenues and damages !
"Well I'll go to the foot of our stairs."
- BlueinBosnia
- Donated to the site

- Posts: 10885
- Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2007 3:43 pm
- Supporter of: Team Bridge
- Location: Sarajevo, BiH
Re: VAR
ayrshireblue wrote:Conceding the goal was definitely the City defence's fault. But VAR is in place to look at reasons why the goal shouldn't stand and it SHOULD NOT stand according to Law 16 which clearly states -
"Law 16 - The goal kick
The ball is in play once the kick is taken; it can be played before leaving the penalty area
Opponents must remain outside the penalty area until the ball is kicked"
VAR should have looked at the goal and decided that there was an offence caused by Pukki not being out the area when the ball became active. They didn't do this and I'm asking why?
It's all down to interpretation of the part in bold. I'd interpret 'remain' in this context to mean 'not re-enter once they have left', i.e. if a player is trying to leave the area when the kick is taken, they're not breaking the rule, as it is down to the goalkeeper (if they so wish) to give the player time to leave the area before they take the kick. Otherwise, it could be argued that the goalkeeper is playing contrary to the laws of the game by not allowing sufficient time for a player to leave the area.
"Ferguson. Žvaka kurac."
(Ferguson. Chewing-gum cock.)
Old man in a bar in rural Bosnia.
(Ferguson. Chewing-gum cock.)
Old man in a bar in rural Bosnia.
-
Nigels Tackle
- Donated to the site

- Posts: 19015
- Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2007 7:57 pm
- Supporter of: man love
- My favourite player is: riyad meh!rez
- Location: here, there, every fucking where
Re: VAR
BlueinBosnia wrote:ayrshireblue wrote:Conceding the goal was definitely the City defence's fault. But VAR is in place to look at reasons why the goal shouldn't stand and it SHOULD NOT stand according to Law 16 which clearly states -
"Law 16 - The goal kick
The ball is in play once the kick is taken; it can be played before leaving the penalty area
Opponents must remain outside the penalty area until the ball is kicked"
VAR should have looked at the goal and decided that there was an offence caused by Pukki not being out the area when the ball became active. They didn't do this and I'm asking why?
It's all down to interpretation of the part in bold. I'd interpret 'remain' in this context to mean 'not re-enter once they have left', i.e. if a player is trying to leave the area when the kick is taken, they're not breaking the rule, as it is down to the goalkeeper (if they so wish) to give the player time to leave the area before they take the kick. Otherwise, it could be argued that the goalkeeper is playing contrary to the laws of the game by not allowing sufficient time for a player to leave the area.
brexit means brexit!
-
Scatman
- Dickov's Injury Time Equaliser
- Posts: 4867
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2008 11:06 am
- Location: Manchester
Re: VAR
BlueinBosnia wrote:ayrshireblue wrote:Conceding the goal was definitely the City defence's fault. But VAR is in place to look at reasons why the goal shouldn't stand and it SHOULD NOT stand according to Law 16 which clearly states -
"Law 16 - The goal kick
The ball is in play once the kick is taken; it can be played before leaving the penalty area
Opponents must remain outside the penalty area until the ball is kicked"
VAR should have looked at the goal and decided that there was an offence caused by Pukki not being out the area when the ball became active. They didn't do this and I'm asking why?
It's all down to interpretation of the part in bold. I'd interpret 'remain' in this context to mean 'not re-enter once they have left', i.e. if a player is trying to leave the area when the kick is taken, they're not breaking the rule, as it is down to the goalkeeper (if they so wish) to give the player time to leave the area before they take the kick. Otherwise, it could be argued that the goalkeeper is playing contrary to the laws of the game by not allowing sufficient time for a player to leave the area.
That's a beauty of a post. Cheers
-
nottsblue
- Anna Connell's Vision
- Posts: 34454
- Joined: Sat Oct 05, 2013 5:17 pm
- Supporter of: manchester city
- My favourite player is: niall Quinn & Kun
- Location: Nottingham
Re: VAR
Some shocking decisions yesterday. The levels of inconsistency are dreadful. Goals given when in previous weeks they were chalked off for handball. Goals disallowed for the merest infringements when in other games those same infringements aren’t given.
I know it’s a work in progress and I dare say it might improve. The implementation and its communication certainly needs to improve. Even the broadcasters at the Spurs game didn’t know what had happened yesterday.
I was fearful and cynical about the introduction of VAR primarily because it’s still down to the decision of a human and can thus be manipulated to an advantage. This season and the decisions so far VAR has made only reinforces my opinion
I know it’s a work in progress and I dare say it might improve. The implementation and its communication certainly needs to improve. Even the broadcasters at the Spurs game didn’t know what had happened yesterday.
I was fearful and cynical about the introduction of VAR primarily because it’s still down to the decision of a human and can thus be manipulated to an advantage. This season and the decisions so far VAR has made only reinforces my opinion
-
Beefymcfc
- Anna Connell's Vision
- Posts: 46786
- Joined: Thu Jun 21, 2007 7:14 am
- Supporter of: The Mighty Blues
Re: VAR
Turned into an absolute farce and, to be honest, has turned into something that we all feared, used to control results.
In the words of my Old Man, "Life will never be the same without Man City, so get it in while you can".
The Future's Bright, The Future's Blue!!!
The Future's Bright, The Future's Blue!!!
-
Foreverinbluedreams
- Denis Law's Backheel
- Posts: 9224
- Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2011 8:34 pm
- Supporter of: Euthanasia
Re: VAR
Pitchside monitors are needed.
I know it slows things up but it's obvious the VAR refs are reluctant to overrule the ref, let the refs see the replays.
I know it slows things up but it's obvious the VAR refs are reluctant to overrule the ref, let the refs see the replays.
-
zuricity
- Joe Mercer's OBE
- Posts: 19623
- Joined: Sat Dec 17, 2005 10:54 pm
- Location: Zuerich,ch
Re: VAR
nottsblue wrote:Some shocking decisions yesterday. The levels of inconsistency are dreadful. Goals given when in previous weeks they were chalked off for handball. Goals disallowed for the merest infringements when in other games those same infringements aren’t given.
I know it’s a work in progress and I dare say it might improve. The implementation and its communication certainly needs to improve. Even the broadcasters at the Spurs game didn’t know what had happened yesterday.
I was fearful and cynical about the introduction of VAR primarily because it’s still down to the decision of a human and can thus be manipulated to an advantage. This season and the decisions so far VAR has made only reinforces my opinion
You say it is a work in progress. It isn't , it is the finished thing. and the management of it is absolutely disgraceful and not even Amateur. The PL have had years perfecting VAR and we now see why.
It is simply inexcusable . For example, imagine some guy in a Bookies , during the waiting process for the Spuds goal placed a bet that VAR would rule it out and pops "NO GOAL" and the bookie pays out straight away only to find a minute or so later , it is a goal !
Last edited by zuricity on Sun Oct 20, 2019 4:58 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"Well I'll go to the foot of our stairs."
-
Beefymcfc
- Anna Connell's Vision
- Posts: 46786
- Joined: Thu Jun 21, 2007 7:14 am
- Supporter of: The Mighty Blues
Re: VAR
Foreverinbluedreams wrote:Pitchside monitors are needed.
I know it slows things up but it's obvious the VAR refs are reluctant to overrule the ref, let the refs see the replays.
They're already there, just PiGMOL have ordered them not to be used.
In the words of my Old Man, "Life will never be the same without Man City, so get it in while you can".
The Future's Bright, The Future's Blue!!!
The Future's Bright, The Future's Blue!!!
-
Nigels Tackle
- Donated to the site

- Posts: 19015
- Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2007 7:57 pm
- Supporter of: man love
- My favourite player is: riyad meh!rez
- Location: here, there, every fucking where
Re: VAR
it’s just amplifying how fucking shit our officials are. it’s embarrassing and needs to be addressed.