Re: VAR
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 6:51 pm
VAR sucks dick. It's the worst development in the game in years.
The BEST FORUM in all the land and all the world
http://www.mancityfans.net/mcfnet/
I thought that about the blue dotted line so looked it up on the FA website. "Hands and arms of all players are not considered" so there we go. I must admit, it's a new one on me. I thought it only applied to the attacker but they must have changed it.City64 wrote:Ok , it has just been proven that VAR got this decision totally wrong and also proves they haven't got a clue what they are doing . The blue line on the West Ham player should be vertical from his elbow not his shoulder therefore the horizontal blue line on the pitch further forward thus Sterling is clearly onside . Absolute fucking disgrace that a sublime goal not given for an utter arse of technology not used correctly = GAME IS FUCKED LADIES AND GENTS !Beefymcfc wrote:That has to be absolute bollox and subjective at most. Fuck me, I've seen it all now!Saul Goodman wrote:First VAR goal reversal in Premier League history
That's just absolutely ridiculous. What happened to being level meant onside.FA cup winners 2006 wrote:Whatever happened to the rule that there needs to be daylight between the attacker and the defender or was that just some shite that the commentators used to bang on aboutSaul Goodman wrote:First VAR goal reversal in Premier League history
So why is the line going from the defenders armpit, but the other one from halfway down Raz's upper arm?branny wrote:I thought that about the blue dotted line so looked it up on the FA website. "Hands and arms of all players are not considered" so there we go. I must admit, it's a new one on me. I thought it only applied to the attacker but they must have changed it.City64 wrote:Ok , it has just been proven that VAR got this decision totally wrong and also proves they haven't got a clue what they are doing . The blue line on the West Ham player should be vertical from his elbow not his shoulder therefore the horizontal blue line on the pitch further forward thus Sterling is clearly onside . Absolute fucking disgrace that a sublime goal not given for an utter arse of technology not used correctly = GAME IS FUCKED LADIES AND GENTS !Beefymcfc wrote:That has to be absolute bollox and subjective at most. Fuck me, I've seen it all now!Saul Goodman wrote:First VAR goal reversal in Premier League history
I've just seen that. Clearly hits the defenders arm. Why was no penalty given? We've had them given against us!FA cup winners 2006 wrote:Watching the Watford Brighton game on MOTD. How come Watford were not awarded a penalty.
Free-kick was clearly blocked by a defenders elbow. I thought the rule now was if it hits the arm, it's a penalty.
Premier League referees have said that they won’t be applying that interpretation of the law in EnglandMase wrote:I've just seen that. Clearly hits the defenders arm. Why was no penalty given? We've had them given against us!FA cup winners 2006 wrote:Watching the Watford Brighton game on MOTD. How come Watford were not awarded a penalty.
Free-kick was clearly blocked by a defenders elbow. I thought the rule now was if it hits the arm, it's a penalty.
You sure? I swear they said the opposite. Other leagues do that but the PL is letting ARs make the calls and only when they dont will VAR review.Mase wrote:When it happened on the US commentary they said that. "Linesmen have been told to keep their flags down on tight calls and it will then be reviewed by VAR. We've seen that not be the case in other matches already played" not sure whether the last bit was a dog at Liverpool but thankfully they said it how it is.nottsblue wrote:What hasn’t been mentioned much and was glossed over very quickly during the match, was the offside given against Mahrez from Ederson’s clearance. He was level and the cameras and McManaman spotted it and said as much but not another word was said.
The point being I thought linesman were only supposed to flag when it was obvious as VAR would check if a goal resulted. This is where we will get the shitty end of the stick, the little decisions that don’t go to VAR but could have led to a breakaway or a chance or a goal. I notice that Norwich were dealt similar cards last night.
If the powers that be want us to suffer poor decisions like we have done for what seems like ages now, they will continue to do so, they will just have to be more subtle about it
So, does that mean that it can be interpreted differently in different leauges/competitions/internationals? Absolute bollocks if so. One game, one set of rules.london blue 2 wrote:Premier League referees have said that they won’t be applying that interpretation of the law in EnglandMase wrote:I've just seen that. Clearly hits the defenders arm. Why was no penalty given? We've had them given against us!FA cup winners 2006 wrote:Watching the Watford Brighton game on MOTD. How come Watford were not awarded a penalty.
Free-kick was clearly blocked by a defenders elbow. I thought the rule now was if it hits the arm, it's a penalty.
Yes it can be applied differently and it yes it is stupid. Even if done honestly it will confuse the fans (the pundits will be confused anyway).Blue Noodle wrote:So, does that mean that it can be interpreted differently in different leauges/competitions/internationals? Absolute bollocks if so. One game, one set of rules.london blue 2 wrote:Premier League referees have said that they won’t be applying that interpretation of the law in EnglandMase wrote:I've just seen that. Clearly hits the defenders arm. Why was no penalty given? We've had them given against us!FA cup winners 2006 wrote:Watching the Watford Brighton game on MOTD. How come Watford were not awarded a penalty.
Free-kick was clearly blocked by a defenders elbow. I thought the rule now was if it hits the arm, it's a penalty.
As I said in the match thread - So basically an operator can decide a match.blues2win wrote:If there genuinely is a margin of error in the equipment the obvious answer is to apply it as in cricket and make it referee’s call.