Page 23 of 28

Re: VAR

Posted: Mon Dec 30, 2019 10:05 pm
by Hutch's Shoulder
I fully expect one day to see an offside photo frame shown with a line looping round a City player hand-drawn with a black sharpie, à la Trump’s weather map.

Re: VAR

Posted: Tue Dec 31, 2019 3:07 am
by Piccsnumberoneblue
Whether it's an attacker being slightly forward or slightly backward of a defender, the gap will still be minimal. It solves nothing.
Unless you have super accurate measuring there is no such thing as level.
This clear and obvious is the key.
I never wanted VAR and it's even worse than I thought it would be.
Whilst it's a subjective opinion, the controversy will never really be settled.
There is worse to come. Once we get used to the fact that every goal is possibly going to be ruled out, the wild celebrations will stop. Once that happens, there is little point in being a supporter. It's the best part, the pay off for all the dross you watch.

I sum VAR up with "Solves nothing, ruins everything.

Bin it off now before it does anymore damage!

Re: VAR

Posted: Tue Dec 31, 2019 6:19 am
by zuricity
Actually, i would like to see VAR binned, but for this season , they have to stick with the way it is being implemented otherwise the season becomes a farce.

Re: VAR

Posted: Tue Dec 31, 2019 6:28 am
by zuricity
Piccsnumberoneblue wrote:Whether it's an attacker being slightly forward or slightly backward of a defender, the gap will still be minimal. It solves nothing.
Unless you have super accurate measuring there is no such thing as level.
This clear and obvious is the key.
I never wanted VAR and it's even worse than I thought it would be.
Whilst it's a subjective opinion, the controversy will never really be settled.
There is worse to come. Once we get used to the fact that every goal is possibly going to be ruled out, the wild celebrations will stop. Once that happens, there is little point in being a supporter. It's the best part, the pay off for all the dross you watch.

I sum VAR up with "Solves nothing, ruins everything.

Bin it off now before it does anymore damage!
and might i add , it depends on when the ball is released forward from the passing player, with whatever part of his body it can be legally played forward.

Re: VAR

Posted: Tue Dec 31, 2019 1:10 pm
by Beefymcfc
I note that the PL have been called out by the media for the assistance VAR has given them this season so far. LiVARpool was one headline and the table showing how they’ve benefitted and would only be 6 points clear are just 2 examples. A good time to bury these story’s, I think.

What is not written about is where the decisions haven’t been referred to VAR such as the TAA handball, Van Dikes clattering of an Everton player in the box during the Derby or the none VAR review of a possible offside for Salah against us. That’s just a few of many, and this, following the extraordinary amount of dodgy decisions last season, just proves to me how special the Treble Season was.

When you not only have to beat the teams around you but beat the establishment who are trying to halt your progress, it’s an outstanding achievement. Against all odds!

Re: VAR

Posted: Tue Dec 31, 2019 3:22 pm
by patrickblue
Piccsnumberoneblue wrote: There is worse to come. Once we get used to the fact that every goal is possibly going to be ruled out, the wild celebrations will stop. Once that happens, there is little point in being a supporter. It's the best part, the pay off for all the dross you watch.
You're quite right. At the moment in the short term it's the fact that the PL are using it for their own ends that is winding everyone up, but long term it'll kill football as a spectator sport for the reason you've quoted.

Still, maybe that's what the PL want, the match going public are just an inconvenience to them.

Re: VAR

Posted: Tue Dec 31, 2019 5:33 pm
by carl_feedthegoat
patrickblue wrote:
Piccsnumberoneblue wrote: There is worse to come. Once we get used to the fact that every goal is possibly going to be ruled out, the wild celebrations will stop. Once that happens, there is little point in being a supporter. It's the best part, the pay off for all the dross you watch.
You're quite right. At the moment in the short term it's the fact that the PL are using it for their own ends that is winding everyone up, but long term it'll kill football as a spectator sport for the reason you've quoted.

Still, maybe that's what the PL want, the match going public are just an inconvenience to them.
Good - Ill then start watching Rugby (My mate owns the Wolf Pack ) and Ill get my enjoyment from that.

Re: VAR

Posted: Tue Dec 31, 2019 9:27 pm
by Saul Goodman
VAR is not the problem. Its the English refs. Theyre not using it properly. The IFAB--or whomever--just said as much.
The Bundesliga is using it much better and both the ARs and VAR refs are doing well.

Re: VAR

Posted: Tue Dec 31, 2019 9:31 pm
by carl_feedthegoat
Saul Goodman wrote:VAR is not the problem. Its the English refs. Theyre not using it properly. The IFAB--or whomever--just said as much.
The Bundesliga is using it much better and both the ARs and VAR refs are doing well.
Our game is corrupt , that’s the problem

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 3:56 pm
by Simister
Beefymcfc wrote:I note that the PL have been called out by the media for the assistance VAR has given them this season so far. LiVARpool was one headline and the table showing how they’ve benefitted and would only be 6 points clear are just 2 examples. A good time to bury these story’s, I think.

What is not written about is where the decisions haven’t been referred to VAR such as the TAA handball, Van Dikes clattering of an Everton player in the box during the Derby or the none VAR review of a possible offside for Salah against us. That’s just a few of many, and this, following the extraordinary amount of dodgy decisions last season, just proves to me how special the Treble Season was.

When you not only have to beat the teams around you but beat the establishment who are trying to halt your progress, it’s an outstanding achievement. Against all odds!
Exactly

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 3:58 pm
by Simister
zuricity wrote:Actually, i would like to see VAR binned, but for this season , they have to stick with the way it is being implemented otherwise the season becomes a farce.
Actually it couldn't be more of a farce than it is now, and if VAR was dropped now it might make Livarpool a bit nervous.

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 4:10 pm
by Sideshow Bob
Fucking cunt spuds benefit yet again. should be 2 down after an obvious handball that mike dean and VAR predictably ignore.

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 6:23 pm
by Saul Goodman
Simister wrote:
zuricity wrote:Actually, i would like to see VAR binned, but for this season , they have to stick with the way it is being implemented otherwise the season becomes a farce.
Actually it couldn't be more of a farce than it is now, and if VAR was dropped now it might make Livarpool a bit nervous.
According to the "no VAR table" Liverpool are still first and a handful of points above us

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 7:42 pm
by Scatman
Saul Goodman wrote:
Simister wrote:
zuricity wrote:Actually, i would like to see VAR binned, but for this season , they have to stick with the way it is being implemented otherwise the season becomes a farce.
Actually it couldn't be more of a farce than it is now, and if VAR was dropped now it might make Livarpool a bit nervous.
According to the "no VAR table" Liverpool are still first and a handful of points above us
But that's only because now they're so far ahead they've started giving other teams a fair go to make it look balanced

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 7:42 pm
by aaron bond
The second VAR review today was a strange one:
- Mahrez was flagged for offside by the linesman
- Before the ref blew the whistle Mahrez went down in the penalty box
- VAR reviewed it and showed Mahrez wasn’t offside
- VAR then reviewed if we should have had a penalty but decided no penalty
- The ref restarted play with a free kick for offside even though VAR showed it actually wasn’t offside

Perhaps I misread the situation but that’s what appeared to happen to me. But how can the ref proceed with the free kick for offside even when it was shown to be incorrect?

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 7:44 pm
by zuricity
aaron bond wrote:The second VAR review today was a strange one:
- Mahrez was flagged for offside by the linesman
- Before the ref blew the whistle Mahrez went down in the penalty box
- VAR reviewed it and showed Mahrez wasn’t offside
- VAR then reviewed if we should have had a penalty but decided no penalty
- The ref restarted play with a free kick for offside even though VAR showed it actually wasn’t offside

Perhaps I misread the situation but that’s what appeared to happen to me. But how can the ref proceed with the free kick for offside even when it was shown to be incorrect?
Did you expect anything better ? these idiots do not know what they are doing.

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 7:45 pm
by salford city
Has the VAR review taken place for the scissor tackle on Fern? Ni, thought bot. Must admit to not know the rules but am guessing they are not bumping up incorrect yellows to red?

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 7:46 pm
by nottsblue
aaron bond wrote:The second VAR review today was a strange one:
- Mahrez was flagged for offside by the linesman
- Before the ref blew the whistle Mahrez went down in the penalty box
- VAR reviewed it and showed Mahrez wasn’t offside
- VAR then reviewed if we should have had a penalty but decided no penalty
- The ref restarted play with a free kick for offside even though VAR showed it actually wasn’t offside

Perhaps I misread the situation but that’s what appeared to happen to me. But how can the ref proceed with the free kick for offside even when it was shown to be incorrect?
It was given as handball against Mahrez.

Despite the fact it wasn’t handball. I honestly think the VAR shat himself and couldn’t bring himself to award a penalty and giving a handball was his get out of jail card

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 7:52 pm
by zuricity
salford city wrote:Has the VAR review taken place for the scissor tackle on Fern? Ni, thought bot. Must admit to not know the rules but am guessing they are not bumping up incorrect yellows to red?
Definite RED there.

Re: VAR

Posted: Wed Jan 01, 2020 9:41 pm
by City64
zuricity wrote:
salford city wrote:Has the VAR review taken place for the scissor tackle on Fern? Ni, thought bot. Must admit to not know the rules but am guessing they are not bumping up incorrect yellows to red?
Definite RED there.
Happened right in front of us in 121 , looked a scissor kick and the linesman 5 yards away and the ref about the same , diabolical .