Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Here is the place to talk about all things city and football!
Post Reply
salford city
Shaun Goater's 103 Goals
Posts: 7073
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2007 4:21 pm

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by salford city »

Harry Dowd scored wrote:This is getting bizarre, Beeb guessing what would have happened if we hadn’t “cheated” what about all the clubs who have benefited via receiving our money from transfer fees. We are living in very strange times.
Only strange in Mr Roan's head. He seems to be on a personal crusade at the moment & must surely be sailing close to the wind.
I see he has drummed up support from the Independant football regulator for foorball. Ah, the sweet irony badgering an independant regulator over potential political influence.
Your job is cleaning boots
TrueBlue4610
Danny Mills' Wages
Posts: 71
Joined: Fri Aug 14, 2026 7:56 am
Supporter of: Manchester City
My favourite player is: Any CB
Location: County Durham

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by TrueBlue4610 »

nottsblue wrote:
zuricity wrote:Wow, BBC really has lost the plot

https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/arti ... 5nljx7972o

the mind boggles. Dan Roan is living dangerously
Quite possibly one of the worst, most illogical and simply inaccurate and unprovable articles the BBC have ever written

And that really is saying something as there’s a lot of competition for that
Wonder when they're going to do the "how much has your club gained from City's tainted money" article, followed by the "when is your club going to repay the tainted money" article. I'll not hold my breath...
Harry Dowd scored
Pablo Zabaleta's Manc Accent
Posts: 13245
Joined: Sun Aug 13, 2017 5:01 pm
Supporter of: Manchester City
My favourite player is: David Silva
Location: Derry/Londonderry/Doire/Maiden City - Originally from Hyde Cheshire

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by Harry Dowd scored »

salford city wrote:
Harry Dowd scored wrote:This is getting bizarre, Beeb guessing what would have happened if we hadn’t “cheated” what about all the clubs who have benefited via receiving our money from transfer fees. We are living in very strange times.
Only strange in Mr Roan's head. He seems to be on a personal crusade at the moment & must surely be sailing close to the wind.
I see he has drummed up support from the Independant football regulator for foorball. Ah, the sweet irony badgering an independant regulator over potential political influence.
What about Holt, every article is toxic bile about City, I think he is not right in the head, it’s to obsessive to be normal.
Ban politics from sport and this forum
nottsblue
Anna Connell's Vision
Posts: 34454
Joined: Sat Oct 05, 2013 5:17 pm
Supporter of: manchester city
My favourite player is: niall Quinn & Kun
Location: Nottingham

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by nottsblue »

bigblue wrote:Normally I think the level of discussion on the MCFC reddit is terrible but the current environment has brought together City supporters more than I've ever seen. And this is hilarious, maybe mancityfans.net should adopt similar policies:

https://www.reddit.com/r/MCFC/comments/ ... self_as_a/
Very funny
nottsblue
Anna Connell's Vision
Posts: 34454
Joined: Sat Oct 05, 2013 5:17 pm
Supporter of: manchester city
My favourite player is: niall Quinn & Kun
Location: Nottingham

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by nottsblue »

TrueBlue4610 wrote:
nottsblue wrote:
zuricity wrote:Wow, BBC really has lost the plot

https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/arti ... 5nljx7972o

the mind boggles. Dan Roan is living dangerously
Quite possibly one of the worst, most illogical and simply inaccurate and unprovable articles the BBC have ever written

And that really is saying something as there’s a lot of competition for that
Wonder when they're going to do the "how much has your club gained from City's tainted money" article, followed by the "when is your club going to repay the tainted money" article. I'll not hold my breath...
The money the Aguero goal garnered for the PL in extra TV money alone is likely to be in the hundreds of millions, if not actually a billion or more.

But that would be classed as a sane point of view which the baying hoards won’t accept
bigblue
Neil Young's FA Cup Winning Goal
Posts: 11785
Joined: Tue Jan 18, 2011 7:11 pm
Supporter of: Manchester's Only
My favourite player is: Yaya

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by bigblue »

No mention of the fact that chairman of the Independent Football Regulator, David Kogan, is a Spurs supporter?? How the fuck is that independent??

https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/arti ... ge245n0gzo
salford city
Shaun Goater's 103 Goals
Posts: 7073
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2007 4:21 pm

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by salford city »

bigblue wrote:No mention of the fact that chairman of the Independent Football Regulator, David Kogan, is a Spurs supporter?? How the fuck is that independent??

https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/arti ... ge245n0gzo
Quelle surprise with that name but you could not make this shit up. A spuds fan eh - political no chance
Your job is cleaning boots
Blue Jam
De Jong's Tackle
Posts: 1829
Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 11:31 pm
Supporter of: Manchester City
My favourite player is: Goater
Location: Occupied Caprica

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by Blue Jam »

This 114 situation has been a rollercoaster and a half.so far.

A week ago I was very down about everything to do with the charges.

3 goals later and I'm laughing my tits off.

There you go.

Typical City.

And it's fucking brilliant.
Sparklehorse
De Jong's Tackle
Posts: 1967
Joined: Thu Jan 30, 2014 5:13 pm
Supporter of: Man City
My favourite player is: All of them
Location: Swansea

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by Sparklehorse »

Bloody brilliant piece this……

“If Manchester City supporters are firing back, it’s because we refuse, as Simon Bajkowski of the Manchester Evening News so eloquently put it, to “play the sad clowns that the deluded circus demand.”

And let’s be clear: this entire legal process, together with the relentless outrage from partisan media and punditry, has become a circus that stinks to high heaven.

Before Sheikh Mansour bought Manchester City in 2008, the Cartel was firmly in control of English football. The established Incumbent Four had won 15 of 16 Premier League titles. They occupied every Champions League qualification spot for three consecutive seasons. City had won none.

Then City emerged as a genuine challenger to the established order, thanks to an owner with the resources necessary to compete with the Incumbent Four.

And suddenly, protecting football’s “financial sustainability” became the great crusade.

Shockingly, the rules that emerged—tying permissible spending to existing commercial revenue—overwhelmingly favored the Incumbent Four. The clubs that had spent decades building their financial advantages could continue spending accordingly. Challengers seeking to close the gap would face an entirely different set of constraints.

The established order had built its advantage. Now the rules would help preserve it.

In March 2019, the Premier League, with Richard Masters serving as interim CEO, opened an investigation into whether City had violated its financial rules. Masters would later become the League’s permanent CEO through an appointment process reportedly influenced by United and Liverpool.

Nearly four years later, on February 6, 2023, in the midst of what would become City’s historic treble-winning season, the Club was formally charged. The timing alone raises legitimate questions about the influence of partisan interests within the League.

The commission tasked with hearing the charges was then constituted under the authority of a Judicial Panel chair appointed through a process involving Masters and the Premier League.

And so the cloud hanging over City continued for an absurdly long time.

Finally, on September 29, 2026, we received a guilty verdict.

But that verdict came with a few rather extraordinary asterisks.

First, we don’t get to know who actually rendered the verdict. The identities of the commission members remain undisclosed.

Second, we don’t get to see the underlying evidence the commission supposedly analyzed—at least not yet.

Instead, we’re given a 40-page, heavily redacted decision setting out the commission’s findings, while the evidence underlying those findings and the supporting appendices remain outside public scrutiny.

We’re simply expected to accept on blind faith that an anonymous commission conducted its proceedings without bias, fairly evaluated the evidence, and reached conclusions fully supported by that evidence.

Perhaps it did. But how is anyone outside the proceedings supposed to make that judgment?

We’re talking about allegations carrying potentially devastating consequences for one of the world’s biggest football clubs. Yet the public is asked to accept the conclusions of unidentified decision-makers, reached through proceedings conducted behind closed doors, based on evidence that remains concealed.

And we’re supposed to regard this as a triumph of transparency and fairness?

Rather than wait for City—which maintains that the decision is factually and legally incorrect—to complete its appeal, the media and punditry, including former players associated with the Incumbent Four, are demanding immediate and severe punishment.

Many have spent years treating allegations as established facts. Now they treat a decision still subject to appeal as the final word.

This is a complete mockery of due process and fundamental fairness.

Even if City ultimately prevails, it will already have been punished in the court of public opinion. Years of reputational damage, attacks on the legitimacy of its accomplishments, and efforts to discredit the Club cannot simply be undone by a successful appeal.

And consider the broader picture.

A League historically dominated by a handful of established clubs adopts financial regulations that substantially favor those incumbents. Its chief executive, appointed through a process reportedly influenced by some of those same clubs, oversees an investigation into the challenger that broke their dominance. Charges arrive during that challenger’s greatest season. An anonymous commission, constituted under a disciplinary structure connected to the League, ultimately issues a guilty verdict based on evidence the public cannot examine.

Meanwhile, a partisan media and punditry demands that the Club be punished before the appeals process has run its course.

How could anyone reasonably expect City supporters not to question this process?

So, for those wondering why Manchester City supporters are sticking together, defending their Club, and refusing to accept the prevailing narrative, there’s your answer.

We’re entitled to demand transparency. We’re entitled to question whether the process has been fair. And we’re entitled to defend our Club against those who decided long ago what they wanted the outcome to be.

We will not apologize for any of that.

And we certainly won’t play the sad clowns that this deluded circus demands.
"Its better to be thought of as being a fool and remain silent than to speak up and remove all doubt" - Abraham Lincoln
sheblue
Donated to the site
Donated to the site
Posts: 13102
Joined: Mon Oct 10, 2011 2:28 pm
Supporter of: city
My favourite player is: silva

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by sheblue »

That's a very good article.
nottsblue
Anna Connell's Vision
Posts: 34454
Joined: Sat Oct 05, 2013 5:17 pm
Supporter of: manchester city
My favourite player is: niall Quinn & Kun
Location: Nottingham

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by nottsblue »

^^^^^^^^^

Superb stuff Sparklehorse
salford city
Shaun Goater's 103 Goals
Posts: 7073
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2007 4:21 pm

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by salford city »

Your job is cleaning boots
TrueBlue4610
Danny Mills' Wages
Posts: 71
Joined: Fri Aug 14, 2026 7:56 am
Supporter of: Manchester City
My favourite player is: Any CB
Location: County Durham

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by TrueBlue4610 »

Sparklehorse wrote:Bloody brilliant piece this……

“If Manchester City supporters are firing back, it’s because we refuse, as Simon Bajkowski of the Manchester Evening News so eloquently put it, to “play the sad clowns that the deluded circus demand.”

And let’s be clear: this entire legal process, together with the relentless outrage from partisan media and punditry, has become a circus that stinks to high heaven.

Before Sheikh Mansour bought Manchester City in 2008, the Cartel was firmly in control of English football. The established Incumbent Four had won 15 of 16 Premier League titles. They occupied every Champions League qualification spot for three consecutive seasons. City had won none.

Then City emerged as a genuine challenger to the established order, thanks to an owner with the resources necessary to compete with the Incumbent Four.

And suddenly, protecting football’s “financial sustainability” became the great crusade.

Shockingly, the rules that emerged—tying permissible spending to existing commercial revenue—overwhelmingly favored the Incumbent Four. The clubs that had spent decades building their financial advantages could continue spending accordingly. Challengers seeking to close the gap would face an entirely different set of constraints.

The established order had built its advantage. Now the rules would help preserve it.

In March 2019, the Premier League, with Richard Masters serving as interim CEO, opened an investigation into whether City had violated its financial rules. Masters would later become the League’s permanent CEO through an appointment process reportedly influenced by United and Liverpool.

Nearly four years later, on February 6, 2023, in the midst of what would become City’s historic treble-winning season, the Club was formally charged. The timing alone raises legitimate questions about the influence of partisan interests within the League.

The commission tasked with hearing the charges was then constituted under the authority of a Judicial Panel chair appointed through a process involving Masters and the Premier League.

And so the cloud hanging over City continued for an absurdly long time.

Finally, on September 29, 2026, we received a guilty verdict.

But that verdict came with a few rather extraordinary asterisks.

First, we don’t get to know who actually rendered the verdict. The identities of the commission members remain undisclosed.

Second, we don’t get to see the underlying evidence the commission supposedly analyzed—at least not yet.

Instead, we’re given a 40-page, heavily redacted decision setting out the commission’s findings, while the evidence underlying those findings and the supporting appendices remain outside public scrutiny.

We’re simply expected to accept on blind faith that an anonymous commission conducted its proceedings without bias, fairly evaluated the evidence, and reached conclusions fully supported by that evidence.

Perhaps it did. But how is anyone outside the proceedings supposed to make that judgment?

We’re talking about allegations carrying potentially devastating consequences for one of the world’s biggest football clubs. Yet the public is asked to accept the conclusions of unidentified decision-makers, reached through proceedings conducted behind closed doors, based on evidence that remains concealed.

And we’re supposed to regard this as a triumph of transparency and fairness?

Rather than wait for City—which maintains that the decision is factually and legally incorrect—to complete its appeal, the media and punditry, including former players associated with the Incumbent Four, are demanding immediate and severe punishment.

Many have spent years treating allegations as established facts. Now they treat a decision still subject to appeal as the final word.

This is a complete mockery of due process and fundamental fairness.

Even if City ultimately prevails, it will already have been punished in the court of public opinion. Years of reputational damage, attacks on the legitimacy of its accomplishments, and efforts to discredit the Club cannot simply be undone by a successful appeal.

And consider the broader picture.

A League historically dominated by a handful of established clubs adopts financial regulations that substantially favor those incumbents. Its chief executive, appointed through a process reportedly influenced by some of those same clubs, oversees an investigation into the challenger that broke their dominance. Charges arrive during that challenger’s greatest season. An anonymous commission, constituted under a disciplinary structure connected to the League, ultimately issues a guilty verdict based on evidence the public cannot examine.

Meanwhile, a partisan media and punditry demands that the Club be punished before the appeals process has run its course.

How could anyone reasonably expect City supporters not to question this process?

So, for those wondering why Manchester City supporters are sticking together, defending their Club, and refusing to accept the prevailing narrative, there’s your answer.

We’re entitled to demand transparency. We’re entitled to question whether the process has been fair. And we’re entitled to defend our Club against those who decided long ago what they wanted the outcome to be.

We will not apologize for any of that.

And we certainly won’t play the sad clowns that this deluded circus demands.
Where's that from, Sparkle? Do you have a link, as I know a good few people that will be getting it sent to them!
TrueBlue4610
Danny Mills' Wages
Posts: 71
Joined: Fri Aug 14, 2026 7:56 am
Supporter of: Manchester City
My favourite player is: Any CB
Location: County Durham

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by TrueBlue4610 »

Not sure this has ever happened before but on Oddschecker - a site that groups all the betting company odds together - we're 2nd favourites at 4/1 to win the PL,

While also being 3rd favourites at 7/4 to get relegated!

Any betters/mathematicians among you know if there's a win/win amount to place on both outcomes? :lol: :lol:
zuricity
Joe Mercer's OBE
Posts: 19620
Joined: Sat Dec 17, 2005 10:54 pm
Location: Zuerich,ch

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by zuricity »

TrueBlue4610 wrote:Not sure this has ever happened before but on Oddschecker - a site that groups all the betting company odds together - we're 2nd favourites at 4/1 to win the PL,

While also being 3rd favourites at 7/4 to get relegated!

Any betters/mathematicians among you know if there's a win/win amount to place on both outcomes? :lol: :lol:
It's a false premise. City will not get relegated.
"Well I'll go to the foot of our stairs."
Crossie
Denis Law's Backheel
Posts: 9959
Joined: Thu Dec 15, 2005 4:51 pm
Supporter of: Manchester City
My favourite player is: Vinny

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by Crossie »

Holt, etc are trained to create emotion. The most powerful one being hate. Write a headline that grabs everyone’s attention and be paid by the modern currencies of clicks, likes and comments.

It’s hard to not engage but that’s what’s needed.
salford city
Shaun Goater's 103 Goals
Posts: 7073
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2007 4:21 pm

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by salford city »

Crossie wrote:Holt, etc are trained to create emotion. The most powerful one being hate. Write a headline that grabs everyone’s attention and be paid by the modern currencies of clicks, likes and comments.

It’s hard to not engage but that’s what’s needed.
All true mate. Fuck them all.
Your job is cleaning boots
Sparklehorse
De Jong's Tackle
Posts: 1967
Joined: Thu Jan 30, 2014 5:13 pm
Supporter of: Man City
My favourite player is: All of them
Location: Swansea

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by Sparklehorse »

TrueBlue4610 wrote:
Sparklehorse wrote:Bloody brilliant piece this……

“If Manchester City supporters are firing back, it’s because we refuse, as Simon Bajkowski of the Manchester Evening News so eloquently put it, to “play the sad clowns that the deluded circus demand.”

And let’s be clear: this entire legal process, together with the relentless outrage from partisan media and punditry, has become a circus that stinks to high heaven.

Before Sheikh Mansour bought Manchester City in 2008, the Cartel was firmly in control of English football. The established Incumbent Four had won 15 of 16 Premier League titles. They occupied every Champions League qualification spot for three consecutive seasons. City had won none.

Then City emerged as a genuine challenger to the established order, thanks to an owner with the resources necessary to compete with the Incumbent Four.

And suddenly, protecting football’s “financial sustainability” became the great crusade.

Shockingly, the rules that emerged—tying permissible spending to existing commercial revenue—overwhelmingly favored the Incumbent Four. The clubs that had spent decades building their financial advantages could continue spending accordingly. Challengers seeking to close the gap would face an entirely different set of constraints.

The established order had built its advantage. Now the rules would help preserve it.

In March 2019, the Premier League, with Richard Masters serving as interim CEO, opened an investigation into whether City had violated its financial rules. Masters would later become the League’s permanent CEO through an appointment process reportedly influenced by United and Liverpool.

Nearly four years later, on February 6, 2023, in the midst of what would become City’s historic treble-winning season, the Club was formally charged. The timing alone raises legitimate questions about the influence of partisan interests within the League.

The commission tasked with hearing the charges was then constituted under the authority of a Judicial Panel chair appointed through a process involving Masters and the Premier League.

And so the cloud hanging over City continued for an absurdly long time.

Finally, on September 29, 2026, we received a guilty verdict.

But that verdict came with a few rather extraordinary asterisks.

First, we don’t get to know who actually rendered the verdict. The identities of the commission members remain undisclosed.

Second, we don’t get to see the underlying evidence the commission supposedly analyzed—at least not yet.

Instead, we’re given a 40-page, heavily redacted decision setting out the commission’s findings, while the evidence underlying those findings and the supporting appendices remain outside public scrutiny.

We’re simply expected to accept on blind faith that an anonymous commission conducted its proceedings without bias, fairly evaluated the evidence, and reached conclusions fully supported by that evidence.

Perhaps it did. But how is anyone outside the proceedings supposed to make that judgment?

We’re talking about allegations carrying potentially devastating consequences for one of the world’s biggest football clubs. Yet the public is asked to accept the conclusions of unidentified decision-makers, reached through proceedings conducted behind closed doors, based on evidence that remains concealed.

And we’re supposed to regard this as a triumph of transparency and fairness?

Rather than wait for City—which maintains that the decision is factually and legally incorrect—to complete its appeal, the media and punditry, including former players associated with the Incumbent Four, are demanding immediate and severe punishment.

Many have spent years treating allegations as established facts. Now they treat a decision still subject to appeal as the final word.

This is a complete mockery of due process and fundamental fairness.

Even if City ultimately prevails, it will already have been punished in the court of public opinion. Years of reputational damage, attacks on the legitimacy of its accomplishments, and efforts to discredit the Club cannot simply be undone by a successful appeal.

And consider the broader picture.

A League historically dominated by a handful of established clubs adopts financial regulations that substantially favor those incumbents. Its chief executive, appointed through a process reportedly influenced by some of those same clubs, oversees an investigation into the challenger that broke their dominance. Charges arrive during that challenger’s greatest season. An anonymous commission, constituted under a disciplinary structure connected to the League, ultimately issues a guilty verdict based on evidence the public cannot examine.

Meanwhile, a partisan media and punditry demands that the Club be punished before the appeals process has run its course.

How could anyone reasonably expect City supporters not to question this process?

So, for those wondering why Manchester City supporters are sticking together, defending their Club, and refusing to accept the prevailing narrative, there’s your answer.

We’re entitled to demand transparency. We’re entitled to question whether the process has been fair. And we’re entitled to defend our Club against those who decided long ago what they wanted the outcome to be.

We will not apologize for any of that.

And we certainly won’t play the sad clowns that this deluded circus demands.
Where's that from, Sparkle? Do you have a link, as I know a good few people that will be getting it sent to them!
https://x.com/mattseed1/status/2109711737247109454?s=46
"Its better to be thought of as being a fool and remain silent than to speak up and remove all doubt" - Abraham Lincoln
carl_feedthegoat
Donated to the site
Donated to the site
Posts: 33598
Joined: Sun Dec 25, 2005 2:51 am
Supporter of: Man City

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by carl_feedthegoat »

Just never forget this: The premier league picked the fucking so called 'independent panel' and they also PAY the so called 'independent panel'.
THEY SAY SWEARING IS DUE TO A LIMITED VOCABULARY. I KNOW THOUSANDS OF WORDS, BUT I STILL PREFER "FUCK OFF" TO "GO AWAY"
zuricity
Joe Mercer's OBE
Posts: 19620
Joined: Sat Dec 17, 2005 10:54 pm
Location: Zuerich,ch

Re: Kangaroo panel finds us guilty

Post by zuricity »

I am not going to supply the link because it is getting silly now.

However, the Beeb are stating that Burnham had two Hospitality meals at the Etihad . FFS ! one might expect the Mayor of Greater Manchester to be given lunch on Match day if invited to the Stadium.

Geez I have had Hospitality at the Etihad with owners of Professional Swiss Ice Hockey clubs and Swiss Bankers. Yes even Swiss Bankers and all legit !

what is wrong with these people ( reporters etc).
"Well I'll go to the foot of our stairs."
Post Reply