pfa player of the year nominations

[Nigels Tackle]

that list can't be right...

i remember watching the fulham v united game at the beginning of the season when richard keys announced that paul scholes would be the 2010/11 player of the year......

[Blue Blood]

that list can't be right...

i remember watching the fulham v united game at the beginning of the season when richard keys announced that paul scholes would be the 2010/11 player of the year......

Haha, good memory.

Maybe united will appeal against the list...

[Tokyo Blue]

vidic and wacko will win it. It is not about playing well and hasn't been for many years.

[edgeley blue]

Charlie Adam Has had a reasonable season, wouldn't last two minutes at a top club
Scott Parker As above
Vidic The token rag, has he had a better season than Kompany ?
Gareth Bale One good match against Inter does not make a world class player or a poty contender imho
Samir Nasri Top player, would love him at City, not done much since xmas though
Carlos Tevez Truly a world class player, top scorer and puts in as much effort as any of the workhorses above. Should win

[Peter Doherty (AGAIG)]

Bale will get it.

Yeah, and he's only had 2 good games all season. Still, they gave it to Giggs and he only played 4 or 5 games all season. It seems it's press hype that wins these things rather than the genuine quality of the player's performances, otherwise it would be Vincent Kompany for me.