Kolarov v Clichy

[Moonchesteri]

Really delighted to have both of them in the squad, I think their different styles suit different opponents. And rather than one of them having to play at less than 100% fitness level, it's great having a quality replacement. Keep giving game time to both of them I say.

This. But, for the big/tough games it's Clichy for me.

[sheblue]

3 votes for Kolarov!!! come on own up!!

[Mase]

I voted Kola

[Niall Quinns Discopants]

I voted Kola

Me too. My fave player.

[Crossie]

Clichy is a better footballer but there is something about Kolarov that endears him. He's fucking well hard and I think some opposition players are scared of him.

Its just a shame he is too fwd thinking. I sometimes wonder if Mancini applies 3-5-2 to fit Kolarov into the team....

[Douglas Higginbottom]

only point I can raise in favour of Kolarov is that the rotation of FBs, provided City with the most sparkling Clichy ever experienced when it came time to deliver.

Other than that, I concur with the easiest poll ever.

EDIT: love to see that, for any poll, there is always someone standing for the rights of minority. I thought this time was hard to find, but not... ;)

I think Mancini showed at the end of last season who is first choice. It's just a question of involving all in the squad at different times plus Clichy has just become a father so maybe a little extra time for that. The only area Kolarov might be better is in the last 3rd but even there he too often fails to deliver with his crosses/final ball.

[Swales4ever]

only point I can raise in favour of Kolarov is that the rotation of FBs, provided City with the most sparkling Clichy ever experienced when it came time to deliver.

Other than that, I concur with the easiest poll ever.

EDIT: love to see that, for any poll, there is always someone standing for the rights of minority. I thought this time was hard to find, but not... ;)

I think Mancini showed at the end of last season who is first choice. It's just a question of involving all in the squad at different times plus Clichy has just become a father so maybe a little extra time for that. The only area Kolarov might be better is in the last 3rd but even there he too often fails to deliver with his crosses/final ball.

I totally agree. difficult to argue with You and Ted, when it comes to football.

[paul_oresteia]

Clichy all the way. Kolarov is ok as a back up... As long as Mancini sees him as nothing more than that!

[Mansour21]

They are both good LB but I think kolarov is better against teams that park the bus, he is also best free kick taker in the team.

[Ted Hughes]

They are both good LB but I think kolarov is better against teams that park the bus, he is also best free kick taker in the team.

He's the only real free kick taker in the team so far & that puts us at a disadvantage compared to almost every other club of our stature.

[Duckman]

They are both good LB but I think kolarov is better against teams that park the bus, he is also best free kick taker in the team.

He's the only real free kick taker in the team so far & that puts us at a disadvantage compared to almost every other club of our stature.

not sure about his freekick stats, but Tevez seems to be able to take them properly, yaya as well, James maybe.

But yeah, Kolarov seems to be a lot better than the rest of the group.

[Douglas Higginbottom]

They are both good LB but I think kolarov is better against teams that park the bus, he is also best free kick taker in the team.

He's the only real free kick taker in the team so far & that puts us at a disadvantage compared to almost every other club of our stature.

not sure about his freekick stats, but Tevez seems to be able to take them properly, yaya as well, James maybe.

But yeah, Kolarov seems to be a lot better than the rest of the group.

Based on the practice they often do at the end of training sessions Kolarov is the best I see.Milner would probably be 2nd best.

[Duckman]

They are both good LB but I think kolarov is better against teams that park the bus, he is also best free kick taker in the team.

He's the only real free kick taker in the team so far & that puts us at a disadvantage compared to almost every other club of our stature.

not sure about his freekick stats, but Tevez seems to be able to take them properly, yaya as well, James maybe.

But yeah, Kolarov seems to be a lot better than the rest of the group.

Based on the practice they often do at the end of training sessions Kolarov is the best I see.Milner would probably be 2nd best.

and what about Mario, Douglas?

[Dale meadows]

Far far to easy clichy all day long

[london blue 2]

They are both good LB but I think kolarov is better against teams that park the bus, he is also best free kick taker in the team.

He's the only real free kick taker in the team so far & that puts us at a disadvantage compared to almost every other club of our stature.

not sure about his freekick stats, but Tevez seems to be able to take them properly, yaya as well, James maybe.

But yeah, Kolarov seems to be a lot better than the rest of the group.

Based on the practice they often do at the end of training sessions Kolarov is the best I see.Milner would probably be 2nd best.

and what about Mario, Douglas?

Mario is easily the best at pretending he's good at freekicks

[Renato_CTID]

Clichy is perhaps the best LB in the world actually and Kolarov? Lord only knows how or if he will learn!