Should we appeal the red card?

[Cit.revenge]

Just watch it few times it s not so much with two legs , Kompany just did not pull other to much back us he need to , but not red.

[london blue 2]

Yaya off vinnie banned for a good challenge, feels like I've seen this before...

[Arjan Van Schotte]

Yaya off vinnie banned for a good challenge, feels like I've seen this before...

yes, and look what we could've won....!

it wwas a stupid chellenge for me, but the key thing is, NEITHER OF HIS FEET HIT WILSHERE!!!! he fell over (etc). how can that be a red card?

[Peter Doherty (AGAIG)]

The more I see it the less it looks like a red card, still would argue from ref's view it looked worse than it was - did VK tweak a muscle though in attempting the challenge or was that 'put on' to lessen the incident?

Wilshire kneed him in the arse when they collied.

Wilshire was going down like Gary Glitter on a Thai Spice Girl, his only goal was to get a City player sent off. Hate the little fucker and if these players are the future of English football I'll give it a wide berth.

Wilshire is fucking vermin. Expect him to join the rags in the summer.

[Plain Speaking]

I think the ref made a mistake but we are unlikely to win the appeal but it could not be considered frivolous and we should try.

There is a very good still image on the Bluemoon site which shows VK's legs just before impact.
Quite clearly he is leading with one leg almost sliding on the ground with his other leg tucked beneath his calf.

[Beefymcfc]

I think the ref made a mistake but we are unlikely to win the appeal but it could not be considered frivolous and we should try.

There is a very good still image on the Bluemoon site which shows VK's legs just before impact.
Quite clearly he is leading with one leg almost sliding on the ground with his other leg tucked beneath his calf.

And if that's the case and the fact that he got the ball it cannot be deemed as a dangerous challenge.

[Spurge]

It wasn't a red, but there's no way we will win an appeal.

All the panel will do is look at the rear angle of the tackle where both feet are off the floor, yeah he won the ball but that angle clearly shows two feet off the ground. I fear he want win an appeal. IMO Vinny should no better from what happend last season, he is always going to run a fine line in this modern age of football making that type of tackle. I think he won the ball but you just can't tackle anymore so always running the risk of a red with that type of robust tacking.

It's a fucking bad joke - winning the ball fairly has become a red card offence. It's killing the game, defenders should be allowed to defend - a stern challenge as long as the ball is played is a fair one. The only reason players are more easily injured in those sort of challenges is becasue they wear slippers instaead of boots ffs.

[MilnersJaw]

yes we should. its about time we did something instead of getting dicked over all the time and letting it lie.

[Slim]

Yaya off vinnie banned for a good challenge, feels like I've seen this before...

I was just thinking that, the game after we lose the Toure's to the ACN Kompany gets a red card....it's like last season all over again.

[johnnyondioline]

Yaya off vinnie banned for a good challenge, feels like I've seen this before...

I was just thinking that, the game after we lose the Toure's to the ACN Kompany gets a red card....it's like last season all over again.

Should work out fine then :)

[london blue 2]

He could have been killed!

[clawbaggio]

Wilshere seemed to overrun it.Only one foot into the challenge but it will probably be deemed dangerous.
If that had been that horrible cunt Vidic he would have been given the free kick.

[Michael Brookes]

Anyone else think things have gotten worse since Bernstein got the chair?

[Florida Blue]

He could have been killed!

Hmm looks to me VK technically had the ball in this photo, Wilshere came in on him. Maybe on appeal they can give Jack the card...

[Michael Brookes]

On mote they just lambasted the red and were quite explicit in that its a travesty he got sent off

[Pretty Boy Lee]

How does one slide with one foot still standing anyway?

[BlueMoonAwoken]

Jack Wilshere should be coming out and saying the tackle was perfectly timed, it was a great tackle we just collided. If all the players did that they wouldnt feel so hard done too all the time.

[WiganBlue]

He could have been killed!

looks like Wilshire has decided he is going to go down before he has even been tackled, look at his feet!

[TheGOAT]

looks like Wilshire has decided he is going to go down before he has even been tackled, look at his feet!

He slipped

[Peter Doherty (AGAIG)]

looks like Wilshire has decided he is going to go down before he has even been tackled, look at his feet!

He slipped

He actually fouled Kompany and thought the red card was for him.