Panti Or Hart

[tc6828]

Get a grip man. Do you really think what is being released to the press about Joes behaviour is true. No professional club would say anything different. However, don't believe everything you read

[Douglas Higginbottom]

Get a grip man. Do you really think what is being released to the press about Joes behaviour is true. No professional club would say anything different. However, don't believe everything you read

Not sure what I just read in your post.Could you explain it to me please.

[tc6828]

were being told what we want to here i.e. Joe is the consumate professional and is happy to being rested etc etc. Lets see what happens either Jan or Summer

[Ted Hughes]

I've not heard anyone saying Joe is 'happy' to be rested.

He just appears to be getting on with his job but I doubt he feels good about it.

No signs of any dissent though.

[Bluedj]

Thought Joe had a very good game last night, made some terrific stops and dare I say it his distribution at time was very pleasing to see (but not 100% lol). Even coming for crosses he did very well.....Thumbs up from me!

[Foreverinbluedreams]

It was good to hear the fans getting behind him. I have to wonder are these the same people that then come on forums and slag him off.

[Herb]

Thought Joe had a very good game last night, made some terrific stops and dare I say it his distribution at time was very pleasing to see (but not 100% lol). Even coming for crosses he did very well.....Thumbs up from me!

Distribution very pleasing? He hit a couple of reasonably accurate upfield punts towards the end of the game but 90% of his distribution was typical slow Joe allowing the opposition to reform, so stopping our swift counters, and even then a fair few were hoofed straight out to give possession back to plzen.
He did make a couple of quite spectacular saves but they were needlessly spectacular show-boating (something he does a lot of) on at least 2 occassions where he threw himself into over-elaborate 'here's one for the camera' poses and tipped the ball over to give corners where a decent keeper would've made the saves look like half the trouble and caught the ball for redistribution.

[zuricity]

Distribution very pleasing? He hit a couple of reasonably accurate upfield punts towards the end of the game but 90% of his distribution was typical slow Joe allowing the opposition to reform, so stopping our swift counters, and even then a fair few were hoofed straight out to give possession back to plzen.
He did make a couple of quite spectacular saves but they were needlessly spectacular show-boating (something he does a lot of) on at least 2 occassions where he threw himself into over-elaborate 'here's one for the camera' poses and tipped the ball over to give corners where a decent keeper would've made the saves look like half the trouble and caught the ball for redistribution.

You did see the disallowed goal by Kun in the first half , yes ? Or does your obsession with Joe take you beyond seeing the good things that Joe does ?

[Nigels Tackle]

his hairstyle is bloody awful

[Bridge'srightfoot]

Don't think anyone in the right mind could describe his distribution and kicking as anything above ' below average' and that's putting it kindly.

[Foreverinbluedreams]

Don't think anyone in the right mind could describe his distribution and kicking as anything above ' below average' and that's putting it kindly.

What do you make of Pants' kicking? I think it's worse than Hart's.

That said I am impressed with Pants' distribution from his hand, he seems to spot the runners quicker than Hart and his throw outs are very accurate.

[Bridge'srightfoot]

Wonder who will get the nod tomorrow. Hope it's Panti and it would be good for him to have confidence that he can actually be our number one and not just a fill in for Joe.

[AG7]

Wonder who will get the nod tomorrow. Hope it's Panti and it would be good for him to have confidence that he can actually be our number one and not just a fill in for Joe.

I agree completely!

[Moonchesteri]

Just a general point. I've noticed more and more joe hart in comments over the last week or so, just wondering if there is anything that pants has done recently to warrant being dropped?

I think I feel more confident with Costel between the sticks at the moment.

I feel the opposite for some reason. Don't know why really when you compare their forms this season..but I guess it's down to the fact I Know what a keeper Joe can be while Panty's qualities are still relatively unknown for me

I'd still keep Pantel in goal tho

[Blue2]

Is Pellers waiting for Panti to fuck up and cost us a game or what? Hart is clearly the better keeper and has been taught a lesson. Hart should be back in.

[Slim]

Rather than continuing to have Hart cost us games you mean?

[MilnersJaw]

Until pants cost us points for fuck ups, stupid decision making and bad keeping Joe can fuck off.

[Bridge'srightfoot]

Is Pellers waiting for Panti to fuck up and cost us a game or what? Hart is clearly the better keeper and has been taught a lesson. Hart should be back in.

Pants has done nothing to deserve being dropped.
Hart was costing us points every other week or so.

[Blue2]

It all comes down to one simple question. Who is the better keeper? IMO its clearly Hart.

[Slim]

It all comes down to one simple question. Who is the better keeper? IMO its clearly Hart.

IMO a better keeper in a poor run of form.

I'd expect any player to be dropped if he was playing that badly and I don't see why Joe should be immune from the same.