zuricity wrote:CARL....you are correct.
As for the critisism of Mangala. Well in my opinion , he did well. He moved to play the rags onside for a goal but .BUT. He was in the left back position , approx. Now, as far as holding the offside line,since the ball is coming from the left.He is the one that should be calling the movement, not zabs , mdm or anyone else .So, what happened ?Demich should know better. Our defense is a shambles, we all know this. Kompany is finished. He was an average midfielder that moved to the back four . He has got away with being in a great attacking team.
We are paying the price for getting rid of Roberto (and the Chairman must now recognise that the Spafia , in this modern world of transparency, nevermind Holism, must accept that they are not good enough) .
That is absolutely not how it works setting up for a set piece from that side. If you think about it, you can imagine, if you are the right back for example, you are looking at the ball being played in, & the position of the attackers, how can you possiibly know where Managala is? He can see you, but you can't see him he is behind you.
You are relying on him to hold the line. If he sees you move, he can. It's kids stuff.
He was also legging it around like a dog chasing a balloon. But I don't agree with Neville that it's because he has no idea how to play the cb position, it's just a bit of nerves and over excitement imo. He didn't do that v Chelsea earlier. He is better than this.
I have decided I don't like Pellegrini's system of playing offsides either on set pieces or deep in general play. I think they should hold the line until the ball is kicked but sprint in immediately. Not try to do a Tony Adams. We don't have the concentration.