BlueinBosnia wrote:Swales4ever wrote:BlueinBosnia wrote:Dimples wrote:Serious question.
Do people think that the draw is fixed?
I don't think the draw itself is fixed, but I think the CL has been set up in such a way as to minimize the chance of upsets, and I think referees are subconsciously influenced by the fact that if they make a mistake in favour of one of the "smaller" teams, it'll be more damaging to their career than if they do so in favour of one of the "bigger" ones.
Whatever people say about the draw being fixed, there simply isn't anything statistically overly unlikely that's happened over the years, whether you look at things from the perspective of individual clubs (who have risen and fallen in the rankings) or from the ranking positions themselves. Any other way of looking at it essentially relies on emotions, and there's probably someone on a Barca forum somewhere out there whimpering that the same 2 or 3 teams always get an 'easier' draw than them, too.
well BiB... you are right when arguing that forensic evidence will hardy ever reached... but when looking at this particular draw... it gets very hard for any sensed person not to imply the blatant obvious.
I said in advance that UEFA would have made sure to reward sponsors with a SF involving the
4 most marketing attractive sides and here we have gone.
not that I want this as any hint of my smart.
I fully commend your law abiding plea and stance, though

If you're using the 'rich list' to define this, then yes, you're right. But the 4 richest clubs left in the competition weren't kept apart in 2016-17, or 2014-15, or 2013-14, or 2012-13. If you're defining 'most marketable' another way, is it how you "feel", or are you using something else to define it?
I'll repeat - I've yet to see a convincing argument with consistently applied parameters to suggest that draws are consistently beyond the realms of statistical plausibility.
again, my utmost respected mate, besides the fact that i don't consider myself fit enough to trade "academic barbs" with you, honestly, I consider this topic so blatantly obvious to not even deserves the application of strict accademic reasearching parametres...
me think:
Barca (aka UEFAlona) and and Bayern (European dominat economy tycoons's recreational playground/club) get drawn the only two accidental freak of the draw itself... and barring extreme upsets, always possible when a ball is rolling, but utmost improbable given importance/mement in the season and all, we (the global audience) and the sponsors are gonna served a SF stage made of the 4 most stars laden sides...
Again, I dont even have to use the word concede, to enforce Your exact statement on that factual evidence is impossible to reach, but... there is an exact reason why almost every true fan of the Game (the cynicist me included) does consider this competition a marketing outlet and, for a City fans special interest's perspective, a pill to be swallen in the persuit of the Historical All Time Greatest Clubs status.