Ted Hughes wrote:
The 'balance' people are offering is totally out of proportion to what he actually did. It's like giving him credit for standing up or not scoring an own goal.
Yes, I like to concentrate on the negatives. That's the whole idea when assessing whether a defender is good enough; find out what his weaknesses are & try to judge whether he has shown anything to suggest that he can fix them & therefore be of some use to MCFC.
I didn't watch the match with the idea of going 'ooh look he almost followed Balotelli there but he didn't quite, but well done for trying though lad!' ' he's only eighteen you know' I watched it to find out if he looks good enough to play for City next season, as some on here would have had him doing this season! He didn't show anything. He tried his absolute best to stick with Balotelli but several times Mario shrugged him off in 3 paces. That means Sturridge loses him in two & RVP has probably already lost him.
I'll try to keep an eye out for him later in the season, in case he had a bad night, & see if he shows anything more or whether it's down to the standard of the league being poor. As it stands, he isn't close to being a City player & physically, it's doubtful he can play for us in that position. He doesn't appear to get off the ground well enough to be a Premier League cb.
I Just Blue Myself wrote:Lyon is as good as out surely. Schalke is a bit of a mess at the moment, but not sure whether PAOK can take advantage of that. Can't see PSV going through on last night's showing, sadly. We all know the state of Arsenal, but things are far from rosy at Fenerbahce as well.
Group of Death mk. III here we come...
dazlebluefrog wrote:
doesn't really matter if the Arse lose the tie as Fenerbahce will be thrown out of the CL leaving the Arse to crawl threw the "back door"into the group stages
Slim wrote:Lyon, Schalke, AC Milan and Arsenal, if two of those lose their qualifier, we get into the 2nd pot, otherwise we could have another group of death and I really want us to get out of the group this year, I pray to Navas every night.
Wonderwall wrote:dazlebluefrog wrote:
doesn't really matter if the Arse lose the tie as Fenerbahce will be thrown out of the CL leaving the Arse to crawl threw the "back door"into the group stages
Not necessarily. Thet played salzburg in the last round who are ready to lodge an appeal. Also the farcical idiots at uefa have decided to sit and discuss the situation the day after the second leg. They ate cleaely confident that arsenal will win with the help of biased officials.
Beefymcfc wrote:Slim wrote:Lyon, Schalke, AC Milan and Arsenal, if two of those lose their qualifier, we get into the 2nd pot, otherwise we could have another group of death and I really want us to get out of the group this year, I pray to Navas every night.
Weren't we in Pot 2 last season, Pot 3 the season before?
I honestly don't think it matters which Pot you are in. If it's coming out the Gp of Death, we're in it. Third time though, that'd be really fishy.
Slim wrote:Beefymcfc wrote:Slim wrote:Lyon, Schalke, AC Milan and Arsenal, if two of those lose their qualifier, we get into the 2nd pot, otherwise we could have another group of death and I really want us to get out of the group this year, I pray to Navas every night.
Weren't we in Pot 2 last season, Pot 3 the season before?
I honestly don't think it matters which Pot you are in. If it's coming out the Gp of Death, we're in it. Third time though, that'd be really fishy.
Holy hell, Dortmund were in pot 4, well that's just madness.
Slim wrote:From pot 3, we could get Porto, Marseille, and Copenhagen.
And we avoid Juve, Dortmund and Ajax who are all in pot3 with us.
Beefymcfc wrote:Slim wrote:From pot 3, we could get Porto, Marseille, and Copenhagen.
And we avoid Juve, Dortmund and Ajax who are all in pot3 with us.
So, do we want Pot 2 or 3?
Slim wrote:
If we get into pot two, Juve will also be there and with Sociedad kicking the hell out of Lyon, I expect they would be.
So pot 2 would be preferred, we could end up with Porto, Copenhagen and let's say, Shakhter Karagandy.
Now that group would have us through, only decent games would be Porto but I think it more important this time around that we just get the hell out of the group.
Slim wrote:Beefymcfc wrote:Slim wrote:From pot 3, we could get Porto, Marseille, and Copenhagen.
And we avoid Juve, Dortmund and Ajax who are all in pot3 with us.
So, do we want Pot 2 or 3?
If we get into pot two, Juve will also be there and with Sociedad kicking the hell out of Lyon, I expect they would be.
So pot 2 would be preferred, we could end up with Porto, Copenhagen and let's say, Shakhter Karagandy.
Now that group would have us through, only decent games would be Porto but I think it more important this time around that we just get the hell out of the group.
zuricity wrote:Slim wrote:
If we get into pot two, Juve will also be there and with Sociedad kicking the hell out of Lyon, I expect they would be.
So pot 2 would be preferred, we could end up with Porto, Copenhagen and let's say, Shakhter Karagandy.
Now that group would have us through, only decent games would be Porto but I think it more important this time around that we just get the hell out of the group.
NO Beefy/Slim, there should be only one pot with all the names in it. I'm getting really sick of manipulation to give the G14 a bit more dosh.
One pot, no weights, no helping the rich .
A normal one after the other draw . A draw resulting in a group of death would be acceptable to everyone.
Beefymcfc wrote:Slim wrote:Beefymcfc wrote:Slim wrote:From pot 3, we could get Porto, Marseille, and Copenhagen.
And we avoid Juve, Dortmund and Ajax who are all in pot3 with us.
So, do we want Pot 2 or 3?
If we get into pot two, Juve will also be there and with Sociedad kicking the hell out of Lyon, I expect they would be.
So pot 2 would be preferred, we could end up with Porto, Copenhagen and let's say, Shakhter Karagandy.
Now that group would have us through, only decent games would be Porto but I think it more important this time around that we just get the hell out of the group.
You're right but the reality is that it's still a long shot to hit Porto or Benfica , who are still good sides. I'm gonna be the pessimist on this and say we'll get Barca.
I'm hoping that UEFA are seeing us as a big fish and give us a fair draw but I just don't see the balls going that way. I'm with Gollum on this, it could be fixed.
Slim wrote:Beefymcfc wrote:Slim wrote:Beefymcfc wrote:Slim wrote:From pot 3, we could get Porto, Marseille, and Copenhagen.
And we avoid Juve, Dortmund and Ajax who are all in pot3 with us.
So, do we want Pot 2 or 3?
If we get into pot two, Juve will also be there and with Sociedad kicking the hell out of Lyon, I expect they would be.
So pot 2 would be preferred, we could end up with Porto, Copenhagen and let's say, Shakhter Karagandy.
Now that group would have us through, only decent games would be Porto but I think it more important this time around that we just get the hell out of the group.
You're right but the reality is that it's still a long shot to hit Porto or Benfica , who are still good sides. I'm gonna be the pessimist on this and say we'll get Barca.
I'm hoping that UEFA are seeing us as a big fish and give us a fair draw but I just don't see the balls going that way. I'm with Gollum on this, it could be fixed.
Didn't we roll Porto a couple of seasons ago in the waffa cup to the tune of 6-1?
Without any research at all, I'd say we've improved more than they have.
Slim wrote:
Yes, and in this world of unicorns and fairydust you think you're in, do you realise that this isn't the way it works? That we're talking about what will actually happen and not your deluded fantasy?
Return to The Maine Football forum
Users browsing this forum: carolina-blue, johnnyondioline, Majestic-12 [Bot], PeterParker and 109 guests